4* wisconsin +4.5
4* Illinois -2.5
i know these are very unpopular picks so this will be a particular lengthy post... if nothing else, it will serve as a view from the other side
First off i do not hate sparty... i played them @ cal week 1. but a few things bother me about them that makes me want to fade them as a favorite...
they are a run-based offense, yet are #82 in ypr
a run based offense needs a strong rush defense, yet they are #77 ypr defense
but they are 7-2.
in conference games, they are tied for #10 in ypr and #10 in defense ypr and haven't even played penn st yet
but they are 4-1 in conference games
is it wrong to think those numbers can not sustain a winning record..??
i am not going to sing the virtues of wisconsin bc they have underperformed this year... but the qb change seemed to provide a little spark for them last week and there is at least a little momentum going for them
everyone knows about the 2 huge games msu has just played-a demoralizing blowout loss to oh st followed by a great emotional comeback win @ rival michigan-their biggest win in years! now they have to get up for a sleepy noon kickoff to play a 4-4 team coming off a win that needs this game badly
what is being overlooked is that this is mich st's TENTH STRAIGHT game..!! fatigue, both physical and mental, eventually take it's toll, especially on a team w/ a lot of first year starters
now let's look at iowa/illinois...
there's an overwhelming sentiment that iowa will run all over illinois, which is a good enough reason to play them... but take a look at these numbers in B10 games. Illinois has played 5 conference games (at penn st) while iowa has played 4, so let's throw out the psu game since they are without question the best offensive team in the conference and look at defensive ypr for each team's 4 conference games, which includes two common opponents and four other teams of relative even strength
Team A: 3.1/2.7/3.4/4.6 (high 4.6, low 2.7)
Team B: 2.0/3.4/3.2/3.6 (high 3.6, low 2.0)
I'd be willing to bet half my bankroll which team you think is iowa and which you think is illinois... but you're wrong..!!
Team A, whose numbers are clearly inferior, is Iowa
Team B, whose numbers are clearly better, is Illinois
Now even if you don't buy that Illinois run defense is better than Iowa, you certainly can't say that Iowa has a distinct edge...
Furthermore, these are the defensive rankings for ypr of iowa's opponents:
47/57/69/75/77/86/92/maine
they have yet to face a decent run defense, so while their ypr seems very good, they've accomplished this against weaker run defenses... in conference, they haven't played ohio st or penn st, the two best run defenses in B10
Now on defense Iowa has to face the #8 pya offense in the nation and #1 pya in B10... and while iowa's defensive pya seems pretty good, look at the offensive pya they have faced:
36/48/56/68/71/77/78/maine
this is BY FAR the best pass offense they will have faced all season
Finally, look at the spread: +2.5... with such an extremely small % of games decided by 1 or 2 pts, iowa basically has to win outright... and again, if they have to win, then they basically have to win by 3. so both illinois and iowa, in order to cover this game, have to do the same thing: win by 3!! kinda takes the "underdog" aspect out if it, doesn't it..??
3 games ago we were all on Iowa @ MSU... depending on when you got the line you got +9.5 or after dr bob hit it you got under a td... it was one of the few instances where the whole board was on a side and it covered... so now you go from getting over a TD @ msu to getting less than a FG a few weeks later.... whether iowa covers or not, there is ABSOLUTELY NO LINE VALUE at this price
One last thought on both of these games:
B10 is essentially divided into 3 parts this year:
the best-penn st, oh st
the worst-mich, purdue, indiana
while you can rank the 6 other programs however you like, they make up "the middle"
these 4 teams make up the middle, so we shouldn't be surprised at any outcome for these 2 games... but fading a 4-1 "middle" team after their biggest win in years, or playing a home "middle" team against another "middle" team after a loss to a different "middle" team to essentially win (-2.5) shouldn't be such unpopular picks
good luck