Bits: Josh Rutledge shipped to Triple-A
Eric Karabell
A week ago, Josh Rutledge of the Colorado Rockies was among the top 10 second basemen on ESPN's Player Rater. Now he's on his way to Triple-A Colorado Springs. Talk about a swift fall from grace!
Rutledge, a 23rd-rounder, on average, in ESPN live drafts still ranks above such players as Adrian Gonzalez, Billy Butler, Yoenis Cespedes, Starlin Castro and Michael Bourn on the Player Rater, and remains on pace for 18 home runs, 18 stolen bases and 92 runs scored. However, his lack of plate discipline and defensive struggles earned him the demotion. It's a shame, too, because quite a few fantasy owners are going to need a replacement; Rutledge began Wednesday owned in 95 percent of ESPN standard leagues (that number was already down to 85 percent as of Thursday morning). Rutledge's demotion likely will be a short-term one, but I wasn't high on Rutledge to begin with because he just refuses to embrace the art of drawing even a modest number of free passes. Between Double-A Tulsa and the Rockies last season, he drew 23 walks in 670 plate appearances.
<OFFER>The Rockies are apparently going to give the underwhelming DJ LeMahieu the second base job, but there's nothing to see here from a fantasy perspective. I compare LeMahieu to Chicago Cubs Gold Glover Darwin Barney in that the Rockies are probably better off using him because he's so defensively capable, but offensively, let's just say they'd need to bat him eighth. Of course, he did hit second Wednesday, but I don't see that lasting. I saw a Rockies beat writer compare LeMahieu to longtime big leaguer Jamey Carroll. Optimism abounds!
What has happened to Rutledge points out how different fantasy baseball and real-life baseball can be. In the fantasy world, the five home runs and five stolen bases the athletic Rutledge has delivered make him enticing, but his poor OBP told the larger tale. Combine that with his poor defense and Rutledge has barely been a replacement-level player so far, and for those thinking he just needs to figure out how to hit away from Coors Field, consider that he actually has better road numbers. Alas, the guy is only 24, and this will be his first appearance at Triple-A, so chances are we will see him again soon, and his skill set, while a bit flawed, is enticing nevertheless. In NL-only formats you wait for Rutledge, considering he has hit 13 home runs and stolen 12 bases in as many attempts over 434 big league at-bats. In fact, he could become a 20-homer/20-steal player with a bit more polish.
One of fantasy's more popular sleepers heading into this season has lost his opportunity for now, which is pretty rare if you think about it. It's not as though LeMahieu is Washington Nationals infield prospect Anthony Rendon, a real-life first-rounder and potential future star. And for those wondering whether outfielder Eric Young Jr. will get another chance to play second base and regain that eligibility, forget it. His defense was subpar there in the past, and he's at least usable in the outfield. Young really isn't doing enough at the plate to keep his leadoff job anyway, and when Michael Cuddyer comes off the DL later this week and goes right back into the Rockies lineup -- he was a top-20 overall hitter on the Player Rater when a bulging disk in his neck forced him out -- Young and first baseman Todd Helton each figure to lose playing time.
Box score bits (NL): One might think Pittsburgh Pirates lefty Francisco Liriano is a must-add at this point because his three-start ERA is an even 1.00, and he has fanned 25 batters in 18 innings following Wednesday's impressive seven shutout innings against the Cubs. Just be prepared to dump the guy when he starts walking everyone. Liriano has shut down the Cubs, New York Mets and Milwaukee Brewers, all teams with 18 or fewer wins. Next week he gets the Detroit Tigers and a matchup with Justin Verlander. If Liriano dominates there, and avoids command issues, then I'm interested. His ERA has been over 5.00 three of the past four seasons for a reason. … Philadelphia Phillies second baseman Chase Utley is likely DL-bound today because of an oblique strain. Freddy Galvis will replace him, and while Phillies fans might think he's the next Ryne Sandberg, fantasy owners can ignore him. … Mets top prospect Zack Wheeler pitched five effective innings for Triple-A Las Vegas on Wednesday after missing a start because of a sore shoulder. Wheeler could be a big leaguer in a few weeks, but don't assume he's the next Matt Harvey, either. There is major upside, though. … San Diego Padres rookie Jedd Gyorko homered again Wednesday, his fifth of May. Frankly, this is not surprising news. He should end up with 20-plus home runs.
Box score bits (AL): New York Yankees right-hander Hiroki Kuroda left his Wednesday start early because of a bruised right calf, but he was getting torched anyway. His season ERA remains a solid 2.67, so keep him owned, but remember that he's 38 and injuries happen. … Minnesota Twins Opening Day starter Vance Worley was hammered Wednesday and promptly demoted to Triple-A. Hope you didn't buy in to a guy with average stuff. Rumor is right-handed prospect Kyle Gibson could be promoted soon. If so, he'd immediately become the team's top starting pitcher, but fantasy owners shouldn't drop a top-60 starter to get him. … Speaking of pitchers to avoid, Cleveland Indians right-hander Ubaldo Jimenez is one of the most added pitchers in ESPN leagues. On Wednesday, the Tigers shredded him for six runs in four innings. Yes, there is strikeout potential here, but as good as people think his May has been, his ERA for the month is 4.79. Avoid him! … Indians backup catcher Yan Gomes homered again, giving him three this week. He's not a top-20 catcher, but he ranks higher on the Player Rater than Salvador Perez, Ryan Doumit and Jonathan Lucroy, if you need a decent second catcher. … Still avoiding Houston Astros closer Jose Veras? His save Wednesday gave him eight for the season, the same number Jonathan Papelbon and Glen Perkins have.
Eric Karabell
A week ago, Josh Rutledge of the Colorado Rockies was among the top 10 second basemen on ESPN's Player Rater. Now he's on his way to Triple-A Colorado Springs. Talk about a swift fall from grace!
Rutledge, a 23rd-rounder, on average, in ESPN live drafts still ranks above such players as Adrian Gonzalez, Billy Butler, Yoenis Cespedes, Starlin Castro and Michael Bourn on the Player Rater, and remains on pace for 18 home runs, 18 stolen bases and 92 runs scored. However, his lack of plate discipline and defensive struggles earned him the demotion. It's a shame, too, because quite a few fantasy owners are going to need a replacement; Rutledge began Wednesday owned in 95 percent of ESPN standard leagues (that number was already down to 85 percent as of Thursday morning). Rutledge's demotion likely will be a short-term one, but I wasn't high on Rutledge to begin with because he just refuses to embrace the art of drawing even a modest number of free passes. Between Double-A Tulsa and the Rockies last season, he drew 23 walks in 670 plate appearances.
<OFFER>The Rockies are apparently going to give the underwhelming DJ LeMahieu the second base job, but there's nothing to see here from a fantasy perspective. I compare LeMahieu to Chicago Cubs Gold Glover Darwin Barney in that the Rockies are probably better off using him because he's so defensively capable, but offensively, let's just say they'd need to bat him eighth. Of course, he did hit second Wednesday, but I don't see that lasting. I saw a Rockies beat writer compare LeMahieu to longtime big leaguer Jamey Carroll. Optimism abounds!
What has happened to Rutledge points out how different fantasy baseball and real-life baseball can be. In the fantasy world, the five home runs and five stolen bases the athletic Rutledge has delivered make him enticing, but his poor OBP told the larger tale. Combine that with his poor defense and Rutledge has barely been a replacement-level player so far, and for those thinking he just needs to figure out how to hit away from Coors Field, consider that he actually has better road numbers. Alas, the guy is only 24, and this will be his first appearance at Triple-A, so chances are we will see him again soon, and his skill set, while a bit flawed, is enticing nevertheless. In NL-only formats you wait for Rutledge, considering he has hit 13 home runs and stolen 12 bases in as many attempts over 434 big league at-bats. In fact, he could become a 20-homer/20-steal player with a bit more polish.
One of fantasy's more popular sleepers heading into this season has lost his opportunity for now, which is pretty rare if you think about it. It's not as though LeMahieu is Washington Nationals infield prospect Anthony Rendon, a real-life first-rounder and potential future star. And for those wondering whether outfielder Eric Young Jr. will get another chance to play second base and regain that eligibility, forget it. His defense was subpar there in the past, and he's at least usable in the outfield. Young really isn't doing enough at the plate to keep his leadoff job anyway, and when Michael Cuddyer comes off the DL later this week and goes right back into the Rockies lineup -- he was a top-20 overall hitter on the Player Rater when a bulging disk in his neck forced him out -- Young and first baseman Todd Helton each figure to lose playing time.
Box score bits (NL): One might think Pittsburgh Pirates lefty Francisco Liriano is a must-add at this point because his three-start ERA is an even 1.00, and he has fanned 25 batters in 18 innings following Wednesday's impressive seven shutout innings against the Cubs. Just be prepared to dump the guy when he starts walking everyone. Liriano has shut down the Cubs, New York Mets and Milwaukee Brewers, all teams with 18 or fewer wins. Next week he gets the Detroit Tigers and a matchup with Justin Verlander. If Liriano dominates there, and avoids command issues, then I'm interested. His ERA has been over 5.00 three of the past four seasons for a reason. … Philadelphia Phillies second baseman Chase Utley is likely DL-bound today because of an oblique strain. Freddy Galvis will replace him, and while Phillies fans might think he's the next Ryne Sandberg, fantasy owners can ignore him. … Mets top prospect Zack Wheeler pitched five effective innings for Triple-A Las Vegas on Wednesday after missing a start because of a sore shoulder. Wheeler could be a big leaguer in a few weeks, but don't assume he's the next Matt Harvey, either. There is major upside, though. … San Diego Padres rookie Jedd Gyorko homered again Wednesday, his fifth of May. Frankly, this is not surprising news. He should end up with 20-plus home runs.
Box score bits (AL): New York Yankees right-hander Hiroki Kuroda left his Wednesday start early because of a bruised right calf, but he was getting torched anyway. His season ERA remains a solid 2.67, so keep him owned, but remember that he's 38 and injuries happen. … Minnesota Twins Opening Day starter Vance Worley was hammered Wednesday and promptly demoted to Triple-A. Hope you didn't buy in to a guy with average stuff. Rumor is right-handed prospect Kyle Gibson could be promoted soon. If so, he'd immediately become the team's top starting pitcher, but fantasy owners shouldn't drop a top-60 starter to get him. … Speaking of pitchers to avoid, Cleveland Indians right-hander Ubaldo Jimenez is one of the most added pitchers in ESPN leagues. On Wednesday, the Tigers shredded him for six runs in four innings. Yes, there is strikeout potential here, but as good as people think his May has been, his ERA for the month is 4.79. Avoid him! … Indians backup catcher Yan Gomes homered again, giving him three this week. He's not a top-20 catcher, but he ranks higher on the Player Rater than Salvador Perez, Ryan Doumit and Jonathan Lucroy, if you need a decent second catcher. … Still avoiding Houston Astros closer Jose Veras? His save Wednesday gave him eight for the season, the same number Jonathan Papelbon and Glen Perkins have.