Is it possible to beat casino Craps consistently?

Search

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,504
Tokens
Never played craps but can't imagine being able to learn how to control the dice
 

New member
Joined
Aug 24, 2013
Messages
511
Tokens
Sorry, but you are 100% wrong.

Every single bet is -EV, every single solitary one.

Sigh..... I really dont undertsand what there is not to get here. It is so simple. Every role of the dice is an independent event. The past outcomes have no impact on the odds of any single roll. It is so simple and the fact that an experienced player cannot get it is just hard for me to understand. I am a bit surprised at how many people believe in fairy-dust and magic over probability here.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,504
Tokens
I know a lot of smart people who can't grasp this simple concept.
Only way someone can believe in a table being hot or cold is if they believe in magic.

Yes tables do get hot and cold but it's completely random and the events that took place before the next hand have has no effect.
 

Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2006
Messages
4,447
Tokens
I work in a casino and I stopped tying to explain this to people. I would always end up feeling like a dick by the end of the conversation. It blows my mind that otherwise intelligent people cannot understand basic math.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 29, 2006
Messages
1,946
Tokens
Lot of people here who don't understand math. Forget them.

My question is legit, if you were able to practice on casino tables with casino dice for as long as you wanted would it be possible to consistently (or just better than average) roll specific numbers? I know the foam baffling at the end seems like it would make it impossible, but everything is possible.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
Hmm, Find this thread Very Interesting.... too bad that it's 2:30am, otherwise I would go into more Detail on my thoughts.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
I still think you could control a throw once every 10 times or so, sliding a 6 would make the field a ++ bet win on 9,10,11,12 -- 4 winners--2 loses

and c0ming out it would make the pass line ++ (7W ,8 45.4%,9 40% ,10 33%,11 W,12 L) ==== 53%

You already answered the question, where this just won't be allowed
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2008
Messages
9,460
Tokens
This has been a fun thread... Is like saying that in instance in holdem... is more likely you will get AA after you got KK or QQ because your seat is "hot". I'm baffled that people argue math.

Cold and hot streaks exist, no doubt, but there is no way to predict when are they coming or for how long, I have seen streaks that last 3 hands or throws... I have seen ones that last 6, 8, 10... get the drill?

Just because the previous event was in your favor doesn't mean the next one will as the two events are 100% unrelated mathematically. In your mind, they are related, and that my friend, is superstition.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
Lot of people here who don't understand math. Forget them.

My question is legit, if you were able to practice on casino tables with casino dice for as long as you wanted would it be possible to consistently (or just better than average) roll specific numbers? I know the foam baffling at the end seems like it would make it impossible, but everything is possible.

correct ... this is why they put the pyramid rubber wall backing on, Yes it's made of Rubber.

You can get away with not hitting the wall, once... maybe twice. ( not back to back rolls ) But the "Boys" will say something. and they won't be happy.
Even banking off the mirror they get pissed, so you need to change your roll every once in a while.
Some Casinos not care, others do.

Not hitting the wall is the Only way ( other than Sliding ) * which is not allowed, to have an edge Controlling the dice.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
Agreed that streaks do exist, but your EV in craps is going to be exactly the same whether you try to play the streaks or you ignore them. Each roll of the dice is an independent event.

Blackjack is a little bit different, in that IF you are tracking/counting cards, you can gain an edge by betting more when there is a higher % of tens/aces left in the deck. Blackjack hands aren't completely independent of previous hands dealt between shuffles.

Roulette is another game where each spin is independent, and people can track the streaks all they want, but their EV is going to be exactly the same whether you try and play the streak, or if you ignore it. Well, unless you think there is some physical anomaly in the roulette wheel...

Your answer is Above

someone else said it too, maybe it was Zit as well.....

Dice do not Remember what they did the roll before.
 

Rx Alchemist.
Joined
Aug 16, 2007
Messages
3,342
Tokens
I was a math minor, and have taken graduate level math and statistics courses, you should take my word for it. But, Michael Shackelford (the Wiz of Odds) is the leading expert out there (at least the most widely known) on game theory. I'll repeat his quote, and maybe it will sink in. He also teaches gaming theory at UNLV...

"Roulette balls and dice simply have no memory. Every spin in roulette and every toss in craps is independent of all past events."

Then how do you explain the phenomenon of regression towards the mean?
 

FreeRyanFerguson.com
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
13,308
Tokens
This has turned into quite a long and spirited thread. Glad to have been a part of it.

Cyyyk, don't believe I ever said anything about taking advice from dealers. What I said was that dealers (read: guys who stand hour upon hour at gambling tables and see most everything over time) would verify that short term streaks do happen and have bad effects on most bankrolls.

Quoting math facts is laughable to me. I am near a genius when it comes to math/probability.... but I also am well aware that these non-negotiable truths have little to do with short-term outcomes (FACT). The "long run" is based on multimillions of bets calculated on computers. We don't sit there as real people and play enough hands to experience the "long run". Is that understood? I am talking about real money and how it plays out in the short term (which is the timeframe that we experience in the casino).
Not to single anyone out…. But there are posters on this board who can quote us all sorts of mathematical facts and historical facts…. But have never placed a real money sports bet bigger than ten grocery dollars.
Similarly, there may be pure math wizards who can quote the theory of table games from books and calculations…. But have never played a table game for serious money…. Or know how the real world mixes in and comes in contact with the pure math.
Also, please allow me to add….. I am not nor have I ever been a craps player. I have however played more big money BJ (and won) than many on here combined (I feel sure).
Hard headed people betting into a hot shoe /dealer has cost knowledgeable BJ players tons of money. Not because they don’t understand the math…… because their human nature is causing them to exercise poor judgment. Does not change the math… but totally controls the outcome in the “short term”.
Yep, you're a near genius.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,504
Tokens
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,998
Tokens
Then how do you explain the phenomenon of regression towards the mean?

"Regression towards the mean" (RTTM) doesn't deal with individual trials (spins/rolls in our case). It deals with samples of data from a larger population. For example, if one were to see 10 reds spins in a row in roulette, RTTM would say that it is less likely that you're going to get another run of 10 reds in a row or more, and it's not because the roulette wheel has a memory, it's because you've just seen an unlikely event, and probability says that chances are the next string of trials is going to be closer to the mean. RTTM in no way mitigates against or is contrary to the "Gambler's Fallacy" which says that past events have no bearing on independent trials. RTTM doesn't say that if you see 10 reds in a row, that the next one is more likely to be black, it says if you see 10 reds in a row, you're not likely see a larger streak of reds over the next 10+ spins.

Another way to look at it is, say you have a batter who is a lifetime .300 hitter (say Wade Boggs) over 15+ years. One year he hits .218. RTTM says that chances are the next year he's going to hit better than .218. Not because of the previous years results, but because he is a .300 hitter.

Hope that helps.
 

Member
Joined
May 22, 2005
Messages
31,627
Tokens
we used to like to play at the four queens, it is a real low roller place and the tables were not crowed and had real soft landing areas. one nite we were beating them bad and of course it got crowded and the pit was sweating it big time. the pit boss was sweating and screaming at me constantly, but they didnt kick me out or cut me off.

next trip we go there and get killed every time we play. Finally i examined the tables and they had cut ridges into the landing areas of all the tables, and covered it up with the felt so it wasnt obvious. this made the dice fly all over the place, weather you hit the back wall or not. Shows how much they worry about controlling the dice [Losing]. usually wait till the pit isnt looking and there is a lot of money out there to slide the dice.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,998
Tokens
we used to like to play at the four queens, it is a real low roller place and the tables were not crowed and had real soft landing areas. one nite we were beating them bad and of course it got crowded and the pit was sweating it big time. the pit boss was sweating and screaming at me constantly, but they didnt kick me out or cut me off.

next trip we go there and get killed every time we play. Finally i examined the tables and they had cut ridges into the landing areas of all the tables, and covered it up with the felt so it wasnt obvious. this made the dice fly all over the place, weather you hit the back wall or not. Shows how much they worry about controlling the dice [Losing]. usually wait till the pit isnt looking and there is a lot of money out there to slide the dice.

I find it strange that the pit boss would be screaming at you... what was he saying? Unless he suspected you of controlling the dice somehow, he should have been thanking you every time you threw...
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,119,810
Messages
13,573,480
Members
100,871
Latest member
Legend813
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com