Excellent work in this thread, AL. You make one of the most powerful points possible against any religion. It's largely determined by where you were born and who you were born to. I especially like your point about how could a just and loving god deal out such uneven starting hands.
As you can see from the discussion with believing Christians, they interpret it more for their own convenience. That is why there are as many as 30,000 different sects of Christianity that arrived at their separate beliefs through different interpretations of what is basically the same book.
The Bible is a flawed book full of contradictions, atrocities, absurditites, numerous statements contradicted by science and the "loving" god committing horrendous acts of murder, cruelty and mental torture. The god of the Old Testament and New Testament are clearly two different entities that have been rolled into one religion. I've been debating believers on the internet almost since there was an internet, and I can tell you that they have responses for every criticism a non-believer can make with the bible(*cough*festeringZit*cough*), but those whose minds aren't tainted by belief can see how those arguments strain credulity.
Of course debating religion is separate from the debate concerning the existence of a supreme being and and afterlife. For me personally, I know these questions are bigger than me and I am perfectly content with saying "I don't know". But as for religions...I DO know. They're nonsense.