2010 NL Outfield Overview
NL Outfield Overview
I think the elite NL outfielders are all rated rather appropriately. I have the top five as Ryan Braun, Matt Kemp, Matt Holliday, Justin Upton and then Jason Bay, before a significant drop-off to Carlos Lee at No. 6. Bay might be the best value pick in the group.
For my complete projections and writeups of over 1,000 players, check out Rotoworld's online draft guide.
Underrated
Carlos Lee (Astros) - Lee is likely done as a candidate to reach double figures in steals, but he's hit .300 in four straight seasons and driven in 100 runs in five straight. If not for a broken hand in 2008, he might also be working on a streak of five straight seasons of 160 games played. In a better lineup, he'd be a pretty good bet for 90 runs scored and 120 RBI, but the Astros should still be able to get him to 80 and 110 or so. That he's slipping in early drafts this year is probably the result of him fading to 26 homers last year. I rate him as the No. 13 outfielder in mixed leagues, though. He's one of the safest picks in the top 20.
Conor Jackson (Diamondbacks) - I think it's safe just to write off Jackson's 2009, when he hit .182 in 99 at-bats through mid-May and then missed the rest of the season with Valley Fever. He's completely over the illness now, as he demonstrated by going down to the Dominican Republic over the winter and hitting .425/.561/.589 in 94 plate appearances. The Diamondbacks are probably going to bat him second in between Stephen Drew and Justin Upton, giving him the chance to put up solid numbers in all five categories. No, he's probably not much more than a 15-homer guy, but he hit .300 and stole 10 bases in 2008 and he could score a bunch of runs for 5x5 leaguers this year.
Chris Young (Diamondbacks) - I'm typically guilty of overhyping a couple too many Diamondbacks every year, in part because the ballpark is such a haven for hitters, but if it ever all clicks for the team, the results could be incredible. Everyone in the team's lineup has impressive upside, and we saw Upton, Mark Reynolds and Miguel Montero break through last year. Young has gone in the other direction, of course. Since his 32-homer, 27-steal season in 2007, he's been a bust as a fantasy outfielder, and he was actually sent back to Triple-A for a time last year. Still, the power hasn't gone anywhere and he could go back to stealing bases if he wants to. There's no reason he can't be a $20 fantasy outfielder even as a .250 hitter. Of course, he came in at .212 last year, so he has some work to do. But it'd be crazy to ignore him if he could be had at $10 or so.
Overrated
Manny Ramirez (Dodgers) - From a fantasy perspective, I'm not sure Ramirez is anything more than Lee with a worse chance of staying healthy. A hand injury took a toll on Ramirez's numbers after he returned from his steroids suspension last year, and that should be in the past now. However, Ramirez turns 38 in March, and outside of his two-month run at the end of 2008, he hasn't been a dominant force in three years. If he gets 550 at-bats, then he's probably a top-15 outfielder, but I'm ranking him 22nd for now.
Jayson Werth (Phillies) - Durability is an even bigger factor here. Prior to 2009, Werth's career high in at-bats was 418. He served five stints on the disabled list between 2005 and 2008, with one costing him the entire 2006 season. If Werth reaches 550 at-bats again, he can be penciled in for about 30 homers and 100 RBI. However, the price just doesn't make sense this year. Many are treating him as though he's a top-10 outfielder, but paying for the best-case scenario is ill-advised.
Shane Victorino (Phillies) - I wouldn't be targeting any of Philadelphia's outfielders this year, but Victorino may well provide the worst value of the bunch. A big problem is that he's moving from second to seventh in the lineup. Victorino has scored 100 runs in back-to-back seasons, but there's no way that's going to happen again if he hits ahead of Carlos Ruiz and the pitcher all season. He's also something of a durability concern with the way he throws his body around, though he has played in 146 and 156 games the last two seasons. I doubt he'll stand out in any category this year, so I'm ranking him 38th in the outfield.
Brad Hawpe (Rockies) - Hawpe has kept his OPS in the 900 range four straight seasons and he's been pretty durable, but he's a 30-year-old who has reached 90 runs or RBI once in his career (116 RBI in 2007). He's also never hit .300 or finished with 30 homers. He has three steals in three years. While he'd be a great fit in the middle of any major league lineup, he's rarely been an excellent fantasy outfielder and he's likely already peaked.
Sleepers
Jason Heyward (Braves) - OK, who didn't see this one coming? Heyward isn't actually a sleeper anymore. He may be approaching the point at which he's a mid-round pick in mixed leagues. He's an awfully dangerous selection at that price -- the Braves have some big financial incentives to justify sending him down for two months -- but it's becoming more and more likely that he'll be their Opening Day right fielder. My best guess if he gets 500 at-bats: a .270 average, 20-22 homers and 80 RBI. He could also swipe 10 bases. I doubt he'll be a $20 player as a rookie, but he might end up being worth at least $15.
Jonny Gomes (Reds) - It's hard to believe that Gomes' .267/.338/.541 line with 20 homers in 281 at-bats last year didn't result in any market in free agency. The Reds re-signed him for $800,000 and have him battling Chris Dickerson and others for the left-field job. Gomes traditionally feasts on lefties, but he also put up an 858 OPS against righties in limited action for Cincinnati last year. I think the easier league and Great American Ballpark suit him very well, and a 30-homer season is within reach in 2010.
Jim Edmonds (Brewers) - Edmonds has plenty of work to do to make the Brewers, considering that the team already has a left-handed-hitting fourth outfielder due $2 million in Jody Gerut. There probably won't be room for both, but if Edmonds shows something this spring, someone will take him on. He may well find himself a better situation elsewhere. Edmonds hit .256/.369/.568 in his 250 at-bats for the Cubs in 2008 before taking last season off. The power and on-base ability should still be there to make him an asset against righties, though he's almost certainly not a center fielder any longer.
NL Outfield Overview
I think the elite NL outfielders are all rated rather appropriately. I have the top five as Ryan Braun, Matt Kemp, Matt Holliday, Justin Upton and then Jason Bay, before a significant drop-off to Carlos Lee at No. 6. Bay might be the best value pick in the group.
For my complete projections and writeups of over 1,000 players, check out Rotoworld's online draft guide.
Underrated
Carlos Lee (Astros) - Lee is likely done as a candidate to reach double figures in steals, but he's hit .300 in four straight seasons and driven in 100 runs in five straight. If not for a broken hand in 2008, he might also be working on a streak of five straight seasons of 160 games played. In a better lineup, he'd be a pretty good bet for 90 runs scored and 120 RBI, but the Astros should still be able to get him to 80 and 110 or so. That he's slipping in early drafts this year is probably the result of him fading to 26 homers last year. I rate him as the No. 13 outfielder in mixed leagues, though. He's one of the safest picks in the top 20.
Conor Jackson (Diamondbacks) - I think it's safe just to write off Jackson's 2009, when he hit .182 in 99 at-bats through mid-May and then missed the rest of the season with Valley Fever. He's completely over the illness now, as he demonstrated by going down to the Dominican Republic over the winter and hitting .425/.561/.589 in 94 plate appearances. The Diamondbacks are probably going to bat him second in between Stephen Drew and Justin Upton, giving him the chance to put up solid numbers in all five categories. No, he's probably not much more than a 15-homer guy, but he hit .300 and stole 10 bases in 2008 and he could score a bunch of runs for 5x5 leaguers this year.
Chris Young (Diamondbacks) - I'm typically guilty of overhyping a couple too many Diamondbacks every year, in part because the ballpark is such a haven for hitters, but if it ever all clicks for the team, the results could be incredible. Everyone in the team's lineup has impressive upside, and we saw Upton, Mark Reynolds and Miguel Montero break through last year. Young has gone in the other direction, of course. Since his 32-homer, 27-steal season in 2007, he's been a bust as a fantasy outfielder, and he was actually sent back to Triple-A for a time last year. Still, the power hasn't gone anywhere and he could go back to stealing bases if he wants to. There's no reason he can't be a $20 fantasy outfielder even as a .250 hitter. Of course, he came in at .212 last year, so he has some work to do. But it'd be crazy to ignore him if he could be had at $10 or so.
Overrated
Manny Ramirez (Dodgers) - From a fantasy perspective, I'm not sure Ramirez is anything more than Lee with a worse chance of staying healthy. A hand injury took a toll on Ramirez's numbers after he returned from his steroids suspension last year, and that should be in the past now. However, Ramirez turns 38 in March, and outside of his two-month run at the end of 2008, he hasn't been a dominant force in three years. If he gets 550 at-bats, then he's probably a top-15 outfielder, but I'm ranking him 22nd for now.
Jayson Werth (Phillies) - Durability is an even bigger factor here. Prior to 2009, Werth's career high in at-bats was 418. He served five stints on the disabled list between 2005 and 2008, with one costing him the entire 2006 season. If Werth reaches 550 at-bats again, he can be penciled in for about 30 homers and 100 RBI. However, the price just doesn't make sense this year. Many are treating him as though he's a top-10 outfielder, but paying for the best-case scenario is ill-advised.
Shane Victorino (Phillies) - I wouldn't be targeting any of Philadelphia's outfielders this year, but Victorino may well provide the worst value of the bunch. A big problem is that he's moving from second to seventh in the lineup. Victorino has scored 100 runs in back-to-back seasons, but there's no way that's going to happen again if he hits ahead of Carlos Ruiz and the pitcher all season. He's also something of a durability concern with the way he throws his body around, though he has played in 146 and 156 games the last two seasons. I doubt he'll stand out in any category this year, so I'm ranking him 38th in the outfield.
Brad Hawpe (Rockies) - Hawpe has kept his OPS in the 900 range four straight seasons and he's been pretty durable, but he's a 30-year-old who has reached 90 runs or RBI once in his career (116 RBI in 2007). He's also never hit .300 or finished with 30 homers. He has three steals in three years. While he'd be a great fit in the middle of any major league lineup, he's rarely been an excellent fantasy outfielder and he's likely already peaked.
Sleepers
Jason Heyward (Braves) - OK, who didn't see this one coming? Heyward isn't actually a sleeper anymore. He may be approaching the point at which he's a mid-round pick in mixed leagues. He's an awfully dangerous selection at that price -- the Braves have some big financial incentives to justify sending him down for two months -- but it's becoming more and more likely that he'll be their Opening Day right fielder. My best guess if he gets 500 at-bats: a .270 average, 20-22 homers and 80 RBI. He could also swipe 10 bases. I doubt he'll be a $20 player as a rookie, but he might end up being worth at least $15.
Jonny Gomes (Reds) - It's hard to believe that Gomes' .267/.338/.541 line with 20 homers in 281 at-bats last year didn't result in any market in free agency. The Reds re-signed him for $800,000 and have him battling Chris Dickerson and others for the left-field job. Gomes traditionally feasts on lefties, but he also put up an 858 OPS against righties in limited action for Cincinnati last year. I think the easier league and Great American Ballpark suit him very well, and a 30-homer season is within reach in 2010.
Jim Edmonds (Brewers) - Edmonds has plenty of work to do to make the Brewers, considering that the team already has a left-handed-hitting fourth outfielder due $2 million in Jody Gerut. There probably won't be room for both, but if Edmonds shows something this spring, someone will take him on. He may well find himself a better situation elsewhere. Edmonds hit .256/.369/.568 in his 250 at-bats for the Cubs in 2008 before taking last season off. The power and on-base ability should still be there to make him an asset against righties, though he's almost certainly not a center fielder any longer.