Psst...The Secret's Out
You think you're pretty clever, don't you? You've probably had several players filed away in the back of your mind as potential breakout stars, just waiting for the chance to strike on draft day. Well, guess what? People talk. Too much for their own good, sometimes. We're blessed with limitless resources for fantasy information and conversation, and while this is fantastic for the consumer, the oversaturation can be double-edged.
Many publications are valuing the same players highly, directly affecting their Average Draft Position (ADP), whether the player in question has earned it or not. So, that guy you thought was a "sleeper" last fall? Yeah, everybody already knows about him. What I aim to do with this column is point out just a few of these players and some possible contingency plans should they slip off the board early.
By the way, you can access our constantly updating Average Draft Position (ADP) in the new Rotoworld Draft Guide. It's the perfect way to monitor how some of your favorite "sleepers" are faring in early mocks. We're helpful like that.
Brett Anderson (LHP, Athletics) Current ADP: 162.99
The emerging fantasy ace, Anderson has been one of the fastest risers in recent weeks, blowing right past more established starters like John Danks and Ryan Dempster. And in truth, it's hard not to be impressed by the 22-year-old southpaw. Anderson was 11-11 with a 4.08 ERA and 1.28 WHIP during his rookie season, and while those numbers don't jump off the page, consider that he was 8-4 with a 2.96 ERA over his final 17 starts, averaging 8.9 K/9 and a stingy 2.3 BB/9, almost mirroring his output over two seasons in the minor leagues (9.7 K/9 and 1.9 BB/9).
There isn't much to suggest a fluke was at work here. Anderson compiled a 50.9 percent groundball rate during his rookie campaign -- compared to 56.5 percent in the minor leagues --- and he dominated right-handers to a .247 batting average against last season -- compared to .257 in the minor leagues. Best of all, he pitches half of his games in the Oakland Coliseum, one of the kindest pitcher's parks around. I realize I'm not doing much to deter you from drafting him and there's a reason for that. He's good. Just don't be surprised to see that ADP creep up even more in the next few weeks, increasing the likelihood that one of your leaguemates will reach for him early.
Worthy alternative: Clay Buchholz (RHP, Red Sox) Current ADP: 203.78
There's six starters for five spots in Boston, but if you've listened to early reports on Daisuke Matsuzaka and Tim Wakefield, it would take an utter implosion for Buchholz to be on the outside looking in once the season begins. Take heed of the small sample size, but the 25-year-old right-hander was 4-1 with a 2.87 ERA and 26/9 K/BB ratio in 37 2/3 innings last September, closely resembling the same pitcher who dominated Triple-A Pawtucket. This could finally be his time to shine.
Miguel Montero (C, Diamondbacks) Current ADP: 143.4
We might be witnessing the next "Big M" behind the plate here. You know, as in Mauer, Martinez, McCann, and until last season at least, Martin. The 26-year-old Montero is currently being selected after the likes of Jorge Posada and Kurt Suzuki in mocks and while that's fine for right now, look for the Arizona backstop to creep past them as drafts continue. Montero found his way into fantasy relevancy last season after batting .294/.355/.478 with 16 homers and 59 RBI in 425 at-bats, taking the starting job away from Chris Snyder.
He batted .316 with 11 home runs and 40 RBI after the All-Star break and only the aforementioned Mauer topped his 900 OPS during the second half. Making judgments based on small sample sizes can be dangerous, of course, but the catcher position is one of the few where it's okay to speculate. In turn, look for Montero to be an overwhelmingly popular selection in drafts this month, as many of your leaguemates would rather invest in a player on the way up than a player like Martin who is trying to reestablish their value. Just be sure that his ADP doesn't outshine his true worth.
Worthy alternative: Geovany Soto (C, Cubs) Current ADP: 150.2
This is what buy-low opportunities are made for. Soto collapsed in a bad way last season, but aside from his .254 batting average on balls in play (as opposed to .332 in 2008 and his .359 career mark in the minor leagues), not much changed in his hit profile. Now 40 pounds slimmer, look for a healthy rebound.
Nolan Reimold (OF, Orioles) Current ADP: 197
The perfect candidate for a late-round value pick, Reimold has experienced a dramatic jump in recent weeks as it appears he is fully-healed from surgery on his left Achilles' tendon. The former second-round draft pick was a pleasant surprise upon his promotion last May, batting .279/.365/.466 with 15 homers, 35 extra-base hits, 45 RBI and eight stolen bases in just 358 at-bats. We'd like to see him convert some of those infield flies (16%) into line drives (14.4%), but with a solid contact rate (80.3%), we're optimistic about his chances of at least maintaining a similar batting average.
With his power profile in the minors, it's not too crazy to think that Reimold could put up 25 homers and double-digit stolen bases with a full season of at-bats, especially on a healthy Achilles. Keep an eye on Felix Pie and Luke Scott if he struggles, but manager Dave Trembley has given every indication that Reimold will be his starting left fielder this season. His current ADP is palatable for a late-round flier, but any higher and you'd be better off speculating on the game-changing speed of Julio Borbon (Current ADP: 188.7).
Worthy alternative: Travis Snider (OF, Blue Jays) Current ADP: 234.7
There's plenty of intriguing outfield options as we work our way to the bottom of the draft board, but Snider has the most power potential among them. The Jays sent the former first-round pick back to Triple-A Las Vegas last season while they were still in contention, but Snider is virtually assured of an everyday job this time around, for better or worse.
Elvis Andrus (SS, Rangers) Current ADP: 153.6
Believe it or not, Andrus is currently being drafted behind Rafael Furcal and just ahead of Orlando Cabrera. While this makes him a tremendous value right now, look for everyone's favorite sleeper at the position to continue to climb draft boards throughout March. And with good reason. Andrus batted .267/.329/.373 as a 20-year-old last season and looked much more comfortable as the season wore on, batting .280/.342/.395 after the All-Star break. Granted, Jose Reyes wasn't around for most of the season, but Andrus quietly led all major league shortstops with 33 stolen bases during his rookie campaign.
Keep in mind that Andrus compiled a .275/.343/.361 batting line over four seasons in the minors, so those who draft him will have to hope that he is not merely meeting a temporary ceiling, because as it stands right now, Andrus is not a top-10 fantasy shortstop. Still, be prepared with the very real possibility that your leaguemates would rather bank on the upside of Andrus -- say, a .280 batting average and 45 stolen bases -- as opposed to drafting boring veterans like Furcal and Miguel Tejada.
Worthy alternative: Erick Aybar (SS, Angels) Current ADP: 193.2
Another player with top-10 shortstop potential, Aybar should get an opportunity to sit atop Mike Scioscia's batting order this season. Time will tell if he's truly up to the task, but the 26-year-old made dramatic strides across the board last season. If he can add a few more steals to his game, it won't sting to lose out on Andrus.
Ian Stewart (3B, Rockies) Current ADP: 128.3
Oh, the price we'll pay for power. While Stewart has held pretty steady in recent mocks, he has garnered considerable attention this offseason in part because of his prodigious thump, but also due to his eligibility at both second and third base. Stewart, who turns 25 in April, swiped the starting third base gig away from Garrett Atkins last season, slamming 25 homers in just 425 at-bats. Early mock drafters are so impressed that they are currently selecting him ahead of Chipper Jones and Howie Kendrick. While the power is enticing, Stewart batted just .228 last season -- eighth lowest among players with at least 450 plate appearances -- including a .178 batting average against left-handers.
His .293/.374/.524 batting line in the minors hints at something more, but unless he can make more contact (72.1 percent last season, 70.9 percent career), strike out a little less (32.5 percent last season) or hit a few more line drives (just 14.1 percent last season) his batting average will stay relatively low. If anything, this is a year you should be drafting a third baseman high, so if you plan to roll the dice on him, be prepared for a trigger-happy owner to snag the versatile Stewart before you have the chance.
Worthy alternative: Chris Davis (3B, Rangers) Current ADP: 159.7
He undoubtedly burned you last season, but when you really think about it, these two compare pretty favorably. While Davis struck out 150 times last season, he still managed to homer 21 times in 391 at-bats. While he primarily played first base last season, Davis is a sneaky choice in leagues with 10-game eligibility. Davis just made it at third, playing in 11 games there last season. He'll hold off Justin Smoak for now.