Lets take a look at the defenses in the years that these two have played
Defensive Ranking (Yards)
Manning Warner
1998 29 DNP
1999 15 6*
2000 21 23
2001 29 3
2002 8 played 7 games
2003 11 played 2 games
2004 29 13
2005 11 8
2006 21* lost starting job to Matt Leinart??????
2007 3 17
2008 11 19
*Won Super Bowl
Couple of notes:
1.) Warner has only won 1 Super Bowl (lost one as a 14 point favorite)
2.) Lost starting job to Leinart. Laughable
3.) Benefited from better defenses and weaker NFC his entire career
4.) Let Peyton play for the Rams/Giants/Cardinals from 1998-2008, he would have at least 3 rings and even more mezmerizing statistics than he already does.
Not really and argument here. Anyone that was picking a quarterback to lead a team and his/her choices were Manning or Warner, no sane human would pick Warner
Defensive Ranking (Yards)
Manning Warner
1998 29 DNP
1999 15 6*
2000 21 23
2001 29 3
2002 8 played 7 games
2003 11 played 2 games
2004 29 13
2005 11 8
2006 21* lost starting job to Matt Leinart??????
2007 3 17
2008 11 19
*Won Super Bowl
Couple of notes:
1.) Warner has only won 1 Super Bowl (lost one as a 14 point favorite)
2.) Lost starting job to Leinart. Laughable
3.) Benefited from better defenses and weaker NFC his entire career
4.) Let Peyton play for the Rams/Giants/Cardinals from 1998-2008, he would have at least 3 rings and even more mezmerizing statistics than he already does.
Not really and argument here. Anyone that was picking a quarterback to lead a team and his/her choices were Manning or Warner, no sane human would pick Warner
Peyton Manning is 0-10 vs JAvon Kearse was0-4 vs Florida, the guy has been a choker since he was 18. Falling on his ass on the 1 yd line and letting his team down is nothing new with this guy. most of those 8 post season choke jobs he was the chalk. 13 td 17 int 3-8 outside of the 06 year.
An FYI for the forum:
Railbird has hated both of the Mannings since they were in college. Something about them being a foot taller than him and paying more in taxes each year than what he makes in a decade.
Hey Rail,
How's those last two Heisman QB's from USC working out in the NFL? Any SB rings for those two clowns? :lol:
Railbird has hated both of the Mannings since they were in college. Something about them being a foot taller than him and paying more in taxes each year than what he makes in a decade.
Hey Rail,
How's those last two Heisman QB's from USC working out in the NFL? Any SB rings for those two clowns? :lol:
they are about equal. honestly peyton has had an unbelievable supporting cast for the majority of his career and should have more wins than he has.
the years where warner had faulk, bruce etc... you could put him up against mannings best years and it comes out a wash.
warner's best years also came against the old rules that favored the defense. mannings break out year was against defenses that were no longer aloud to rough up the receivers.
the years where warner had faulk, bruce etc... you could put him up against mannings best years and it comes out a wash.
warner's best years also came against the old rules that favored the defense. mannings break out year was against defenses that were no longer aloud to rough up the receivers.
even though the carolina defense sucks we will see the real kurt warner this weekend.i would have loved to have seen kurt warner trying to win at foxboro against the patriots in the playoffs when it was 10 degrees and snowing.the only thing that kept peyton manning from winning 3 superbowls was bill belechic and the patriots defense if he was in the nfc and didnt have to face the patriots manning would have as many rings as tom brady.
