Who's the best white player in the NBA....

Search

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
35,366
Tokens
Well, how good do you think they would be?

Theyd be a competitive team, but they definitely wouldn't dominate. That would be the weakest defensive team in the history of the NBA. That squad would have trouble stopping the sixers. It's pretty much Gasol and 4 defensive liabilities.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,617
Tokens
Theyd be a competitive team, but they definitely wouldn't dominate. That would be the weakest defensive team in the history of the NBA. That squad would have trouble stopping the sixers. It's pretty much Gasol and 4 defensive liabilities.

Yeah perhaps their defense would hurt them enough vs an offense like the Clippers or GS but they would be so good offensively which limits transition points since they would be able to set their defense. Then they would be a really good defensive rebounding team.

Their 9th man would be better than most teams 5th best player pretty much every single game. That type of depth really adds up.

Look at how much the Spurs depth adds up, their bench would be way better than the Spurs even.
 

New member
Joined
Apr 21, 2002
Messages
28,149
Tokens
opinion on subject voided

The guy was top 10 in DPOY voting last season. It's kinda shocking that anyone, much less 2 people in this thread, think he's not a good defender.
 

New member
Joined
Apr 21, 2002
Messages
28,149
Tokens
Last series was a prime example..

AD took it too Bogut. Obliterated him.. Draymond green was put on him and was very successful..
Bogut had no chance..
So unless you mean as a shot blocker by drivers... But I dont think bogut can guard any decent offensive big men

He was top 10 in DPOY voting last season. Guy is on the court because he's a terrific defender. Judging him because he can't guard the best offensive PF of the last few decades isn't really a good way to evaluate his body of work.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
35,366
Tokens
Yeah perhaps their defense would hurt them enough vs an offense like the Clippers or GS but they would be so good offensively which limits transition points since they would be able to set their defense. Then they would be a really good defensive rebounding team.

Their 9th man would be better than most teams 5th best player pretty much every single game. That type of depth really adds up.

Look at how much the Spurs depth adds up, their bench would be way better than the Spurs even.

Spurs would kill that team. That would not be a very athletic squad man. Even minny fans were well aware of loves weak defense. Korver/Dragic/Redick on the perimeter? Yikes
 

Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
17,713
Tokens
He was top 10 in DPOY voting last season. Guy is on the court because he's a terrific defender. Judging him because he can't guard the best offensive PF of the last few decades isn't really a good way to evaluate his body of work.

if he's a top 10 DPOY, than yeah, I can..
They literally had to put an undersized player on him because he was better at defendingAD.. by miles..

So how is he the top10 Defensive player in the league when you have to put someone else on him
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,617
Tokens
Spurs would kill that team. That would not be a very athletic squad man. Even minny fans were well aware of loves weak defense. Korver/Dragic/Redick on the perimeter? Yikes

They would have a weakness but they would be strong at everything else. Redick is actually a decent defender.

Another thing is that if this team were to really exist, they would be so deep that nobody would need to play more than 32 mins or so which would keep them fresh. Besides Gasol, no one injury would really hurt this squad that much since most of the other guys are fairly interchangable.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,617
Tokens
if he's a top 10 DPOY, than yeah, I can..
They literally had to put an undersized player on him because he was better at defendingAD.. by miles..

So how is he the top10 Defensive player in the league when you have to put someone else on him

Green is a top 10 defender too and far better equipped to defend someone 10-15 feet away from the basket.
 

Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
17,713
Tokens
done some digging and been shocked at some of the defensive numbers I see on Bogut.. I was a fan of his - big fan until I saw him live... then I started paying more attention to his defense..

Either I'm very wrong..
Or he's a great rim protector vs smaller players and just awful against offensivelytalented big men...
 

Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
17,713
Tokens
Green is a top 10 defender too and far better equipped to defend someone 10-15 feet away from the basket.

a top 10 defensive player shouldnt killed murdered like he did.. I guess he holds his own in the paint vs driving guards. but i've seen nene and big al murder him.. I've seen him live 3 times and i saw no defense from bogut in those games
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,617
Tokens
Most defense from NBA bigs isn't about 1 on 1 low post D. It is about rim protection and screen roll defense.

And yes he is going to rank very highly in most of the D metrics

Also Green plays way bigger than his size on defense. His versatility defensively is a big reason GS was so good this year.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
35,366
Tokens
They would have a weakness but they would be strong at everything else. Redick is actually a decent defender.

Another thing is that if this team were to really exist, they would be so deep that nobody would need to play more than 32 mins or so which would keep them fresh. Besides Gasol, no one injury would really hurt this squad that much since most of the other guys are fairly interchangable.

Dragic and Gasol pick and roll with love, Korver, and Reddick on the outside would be very difficult to stop but it's nothing that isn't done in the league right now. They'd be good but teams like the Bulls, cavs, Rockets, Clippers, Spurs, Thunder, and warriors would still be better. Redick is a good defender on good defensive team but with Korver and Dragic out there, he'd get owned. It would be pretty bad. I mean even right now when Redick guards harden he basically just gives him a lane to the right relying on Jordan and Griffin to help. They'd win games but definitely wouldn't dominate the NBA.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,617
Tokens
Dragic and Gasol pick and roll with love, Korver, and Reddick on the outside would be very difficult to stop but it's nothing that isn't done in the league right now. They'd be good but teams like the Bulls, cavs, Rockets, Clippers, Spurs, Thunder, and warriors would still be better. Redick is a good defender on good defensive team but with Korver and Dragic out there, he'd get owned. It would be pretty bad. I mean even right now when Redick guards harden he basically just gives him a lane to the right relying on Jordan and Griffin to help. They'd win games but definitely wouldn't dominate the NBA.

Their starting lineup is by no means earth shattering. Neither is Memphis though and that is a top 5 NBA team. Gasol is worth a lot.

They would be better much better offensively than Memphis, not as good defensively and have an infinitely better bench. You have to keep in mind their bench is basically the best NBA bench of all time by far. It's like Gortat-Dirk-Hayward-Parsons. That is really gonna add up over a season and then 2 months of playoffs. Really it kinda makes the question unfair.

If it was just the best 5 white guys then yeah the best teams should be able to beat them.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
35,366
Tokens
Their starting lineup is by no means earth shattering. Neither is Memphis though and that is a top 5 NBA team. Gasol is worth a lot.

They would be better much better offensively than Memphis, not as good defensively and have an infinitely better bench. You have to keep in mind their bench is basically the best NBA bench of all time by far. It's like Gortat-Dirk-Hayward-Parsons. That is really gonna add up over a season and then 2 months of playoffs. Really it kinda makes the question unfair.

If it was just the best 5 white guys then yeah the best teams should be able to beat them.

I love how you're just ignoring Conley, Randolph, and Allen and acting like its all Gasol and replacing those guys with anybody would produce the same results.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,617
Tokens
Memphis is a good team but the all whiteys would be better offensively with all that shooting and spacing. I would take Memphis 5 over all whitey 5 though.

Because of their staggering depth, the all white team would probably win like 65 games. However, when you get to the playoffs and benches get shortened and defense matters more then their biggest edge would be worth less and their biggest weakness would be amplified. A top tier team that was healthy should be able to beat them. They would obviously be able to survive injuries more than other teams though because of their never ending supply of solid white players.

Teams like the Clippers, Spurs, GS, healthy Cle do dominate. So when I said the all white team would dominate I didn't mean dominate those teams.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
35,366
Tokens
Golden St is a better offensive team than your all whitey lineup and Conley, Allen, and Randolph are giving them fits. Your all whitey team would have a lot of trouble against Conley and Allen. If they can guard the splash bros, they can guard Redick and Korver, lol.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,617
Tokens
Gasol, Love, Dirk...all white frontcourt crushes GStates offensively

Also the all-white team would have a white coach, Greg Popovich. With all that offensive talent at his disposal that would be tough to beat.

The depth makes it kinda unfair and skews the question. If it was the best white starting lineup then yeah it probably doesn't win a playoff series (I guess that would depend which conference too)

But CHOPs question was best 15 white guys
 

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
35,366
Tokens
Gasol, Love, Dirk...all white frontcourt crushes GStates

Also the all-white team would have a white coach, Greg Popovich. With all that offensive talent at his disposal that would be tough to beat.

Lmao!! That's funny.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
35,366
Tokens
Curry, Green, Thompson, Iguodala, and Barnes would destroy that team. Gasol is literally the only matchup problem. The other 4 trying to play defense against GS??? Hahaha! That would be fun to see.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,119,828
Messages
13,573,630
Members
100,877
Latest member
kiemt5385
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com