Peyton

[JiveTurkey]

oh yea forgot about Gonzo

 

[Shamrocks33]

be deemed a hero for throwing 4 yard checkdown flats on a superbowl winning drive even though over 50% of starting nfl qbs couldve done the same thing with that kicker, defense, and coaching staff? :>(

How bout the 50 TD season? Kicker help him there too hno:

 

[bad-golfer]

well i was wrong on this one Manning is playing the best QB in the NFL right now

So i'll bump this one not all people only bump threads to make them selfs look good

 

[Coulter]

Screw Brees or Manning. I am going with Tavaris Jackson. Did you see that throw to Asante Samuel last year in the playoffs. Now that was clutch. Hey, it was one more play than Brees made last year in the playoffs.

 

[awmllc2000]

Best in the NFL right now...No question.

 

[JackTripper]

Screw Brees or Manning. I am going with Tavaris Jackson. Did you see that throw to Asante Samuel last year in the playoffs. Now that was clutch. Hey, it was one more play than Brees made last year in the playoffs.

 

[MemphisMonroe]

Lil bro ELI being overshadowed in this thread. Best QB going today.@)@)

(Only QB to beat 2007 PATS and a ring quicker than Peyton and making C average WR's look like pro bowlers).

 

[ClayBetting]

Lil bro ELI being overshadowed in this thread. Best QB going today.@)@)

(Only QB to beat 2007 PATS and a ring quicker than Peyton and making C average WR's look like pro bowlers).

IMO Eli is top 3 but Peyton is #1 right now. The guy is playing the best ball of his entire hall of fame career right now...

 

[Ketch]

manning will break all the records before hes done

 

[ColonelLingus]

Who gives a shit about who's the best?

Manning being the best earned him exactly zero playoff wins last year. Zero the year before as well. As far as I'm concerned, he can have the "BEST EVER" title all day if it makes his fans feel better about themselves.

Enough with the dick measuring and lets get on with the season. Christ, we are only four games in. I hope we don't have to read the drooling over Mannings nutsack every week.

 

[ClayBetting]

Enough with the dick measuring and lets get on with the season. Christ, we are only four games in. I hope we don't have to read the drooling over Mannings nutsack every week.

The beautiful part is that YOU DON'T have to read anything you don't want to. So, we can have a happy discussion like we want to, and you don't have to read it... Nice having these freedoms...

 

[bad-golfer]

ok so how does my post look now ?


i told you guys Manning is not a winner in playoffs and Brees set super bowl records so for the guys who don't know the score

Manning 1 Super Bowl
Brees 1 Super Bowl

ps that 'greatest qb throw a nice pick to give the saints the title

out !!!

 

[awmllc2000]

manning-1
Brees-1

 

[Ataraxy]

Best in the NFL right now...No question.

ps that 'greatest qb throw a nice pick to give the saints the title

 

[Ataraxy]

but what the hell has Brees accomplished?

How many times has Brees even put his team in a position to get to the super bowl?

Keep bashing Manning, but everything you say reflects on Brees too, because there is nothing Brees has done that Manning hasn't done better...

The Super Bowl didn't just net the Saints a win, but added some names to the record books as well. At 82.1%, QB Drew Brees now has the highest Super Bowl career completion percentage.

 

[awmllc2000]

ps that 'greatest qb throw a nice pick to give the saints the title

Yeah he threw a pick. all the greats do it. Still the best in the NFL. No question about it.(<)<

 

[bad-golfer]

Yeah he threw a pick. all the greats do it. Still the best in the NFL. No question about it.(<)<

dude did you watch the game?

Brees was setting records wile Manning was trying not to fuck up witch he did ..Manning is now 9-9 in playoffs is that great?

with all the talent he's had around him guy should have had at least 3 rings. when it comes down to it guy is not a playoff qb reg season hes great but when it counts hes not

out

 

[awmllc2000]

dude did you watch the game?

Brees was setting records wile Manning was trying not to fuck up witch he did ..Manning is now 9-9 in playoffs is that great?

with all the talent he's had around him guy should have had at least 3 rings. when it comes down to it guy is not a playoff qb reg season hes great but when it counts hes not

out

Was at the game. Trying to not fuck up? lol

 

[awmllc2000]

I graduated from Purdue. I have been a Brees fan for years. With that being said, he has really progressed into a good QB. On the same tier as Manning? No, not yet!

 

[bad-golfer]

I graduated from Purdue. I have been a Brees fan for years. With that being said, he has really progressed into a good QB. On the same tier as Manning? No, not yet!

in to a really good qb? lol dude what is wrong with you Brees has been the best qb for like 2-3 years now and has JUST AS MANY RINGS AS MANNING

i don't see how the hell people can call Manning the best all time when his playoff rec is 9-9 and take away the 2006 playoffs it's 5-9

sure sounds like the best to me

and i am done with this thread i think brees and manning made my points for me in the super bowl

out