The topic was best qb in the game and right now it's Brees and it's not close .Ya Brees has not won any big games but he's allways had piss poor teams . Peyton has lost MANY MORE BIG GAMES THEN HE HAS WON.
8-7 playoff rec is relly great hu
dude you need to read the WHOLE THREAD before posting
8-7 playoff rec is relly great hu
dude you need to read the WHOLE THREAD before posting
Nice job trying to divert the focus away from your failed attempt to prove that Brees is better than Manning.
However, to answer your question - I would take the Patriots over the Colts, but I would take Manning over Brady. I used to think that Brady was the better QB, but have since realized the error of my ways. Manning is the best QB in the NFL right now. Period. Also, Brady isn't looking so hot lately...
Now, if you want to go back to the other discussion. Both teams are 2-0. Sure, Brees has more yards and TD's than Peyton, but he did last year as well, and their team went 8-8. Manning doesn't have some spectacular team and he still managed to take them to 12-4 last year.
Brees might be a great fantasy football QB, but in real life Manning is the better QB.
The Colts should be 0-2 and i'll say one thing bout Manning he's the best REGULAR SEASON QB EVER. But when the playoffs come around he's one of the worst the stats don't lie 8-7 .And what did that 12-4 team do last year in the first round of the playoffs ??? lose liek he has on 6 other times
Hmmm well i don't see how the 'greatest qb of all time can have a 8-7 rec in playoffs ?
when theres a guy in N.E that is 14-3 IN THE PLAYOFFS and won 3 Super Bowls .the only reason Manning has a title is causs the pats shit the bed in 06
but the bottom line is if you don''t think Brees is the best QB RIGHT NOW
then you are just dumb
How can you call the guy the best qb in the nfl when he's 8-7 when it counts the most?
when theres a guy in N.E thats 14-3 come on man
i bet if you put Brady in that Colts offence for all thoes years he would have a lot beter rec then 8-7 in the playoffs . for the longest time bradys best wr was Troy Brown? Branch? Patten ? lolol
I fail to see how your arguments between Manning and Brady have anything to do with your last statement about Drew Brees.
I mean, c'mon. They played the lowly Lions and an Eagles team that lost their star QB and had the wind knocked out of them.
Like I said, Brees is a great fantasy football QB. But, in the clutch when a QB has to lead their team down the field for a win? Experience? Overall great performances? I mean Peyton Manning is a 1st Ballot Hall of Fame QB that is already ranked in the top 10 all time in many lists. Brees has none of this. There is nothing about Manning that makes him any less of a QB this year and two games don't make up the difference for Brees to take the lead.
Your comments are asinine and show your utter lack of understanding of the QB position, let alone the game of football...
What is Bress Playoff record? Kind of hard to place a guy as best...with no rings? Your argument is ridiculous and just plain stupid....You try to say Brees is best because of his recent record, which is great and he will get credit when he gets a ring and plays more than a handfull of post season games. Keep throwing out post season stats for Peyton....Atleast he has a few stats.:grandmais
Tom Brady has 27,000 yards passing and 199 TD's
Manning has 46,232 yards passing and 336 TD's
Tom Brady has a career 92.5 Passer Rating
Manning has a career 94.9 Passer Rating
It doesn't matter really. Brady has more rings. Both are going to be Hall of Fame QB's and there will be endless debate about who is the better QB.
However, the fact that you are throwing this argument out there to cloud the original argument just shows how weak your other argument is.
Please child, don't try to cover up your shame by luring me into a much more debateable argument. Brady vs. Manning is an argument for the ages.
However, Manning vs. Brees is just ridiculous...
