Let’s take a look at the 2013-14 preseason picks by AP and see what we find.
The AP preseason top 25 listed the following: (1) Alabama, (2) Ohio St, (3) Oregon, (4) Stanford, (5) Georgia, (6) South Carolina, (7) Texas A&M, (8) Clemson, (9) Louisville, (10) Florida, (11) Florida St, (12) LSU, (13) Okla State, (14) Notre Dame, (15) Texas, (16) Oklahoma, (17) Michigan, (18) Nebraska, (19) Boise St, (20) TCU, (21) UCLA, (22) Northwestern, (23) Wisconsin, (24) USC, (25) Oregon St.
Here is the AP final poll for 2013-14: (1) Florida St, (2) Auburn, (3) Michigan St, (4) S. Carolina, (5) Missouri, (6) Oklahoma, (7) Alabama, (8) Clemson, (9) Oregon, (10) UCF, (11) Stanford, (12) Ohio St, (13) Baylor, (14) LSU, (15) Louisville, (16) UCLA, (17) Okla State, (18) Texas A&M, (19) USC, (20) Arizona St, (21) Notre Dame, (22) Wisconsin, (23) Duke, (24) Vanderbilt, (25) Washington.
So the following teams dropped out of the top 25 by the end of the season – the number in brackets beside each team’s name is the ATS record for 2013-14: Florida (4-8), Texas (6-7), Michigan (7-6), Boise St (6-7), TCU (4-8), Northwestern (3-9), and Oregon St (7-6). Combined these teams that were ranked in the AP preseason poll that did not stick until the final poll went 47-66 ATS (42%).
By contrast the following teams were not ranked in the preseason top 25 but made the final top 25. Again their ATS records are shown same as above: Auburn (12-2), Mizzou (11-2-1), UCF (8-5), Baylor (9-4), UCLA (9-4), Arizona St (7-7), Duke (10-3-1), Vanderbilt (7-6), and Washington (7-6). Combined these teams went 80-39 ATS (67%).
This past season’s results are pretty standard going back several years. Teams that were not ranked in the preseason AP poll that make the final AP poll are bet on teams as a group. In fact at 7-7 Arizona St was the only break even team ATS out of that group. People that rode Auburn, Mizzou, Baylor, UCLA and Duke went 51-15-2 ATS (77%).
The trick is to do your homework and try to find those teams as early as possible, ideally before the season starts. But as the season unveils usually by the end of Sept some unrated teams are already being ranked or off to much better starts than expected.
Let’s take a little time to take this all in. I will be back in a few days and do the same breakdown for Phil Steele’s 2013-14 preseason top 25 and how they fared by the final poll. As a rule no less than 7 teams don’t make it for any preseason poll, AP, Steele, or otherwise. But these two are consistent and respected so I will concentrate on these. Then we will begin to analyze the 2014-15 preseason polls for both the AP and Phil Steele. I will base the AP poll on Steele’s annual prediction of who will be on that poll. That poll will not actually come out until August, much too late to do what we want to do. BOL