Guys it's impossible to compare players from different eras (bigger, stronger, faster, different game etc) You MUST compare a player based on the competition he faced during his time. (except for basketball, long story) Both Ice and Jman are correct!!! Ozzie was the most dominate shortstop of his time by far, best shortstop ever!!! And as the years go by, players become faster, bigger, thus having more range, it will be more and more difficult to see the 1986 Ozzie Smith, starting for any big league team decades from now. Just 18 years ago Tony Mandrich was on the cover of SI (he also took roids) for benching 225 an unheard of 39times. Now many players are able to do that no big deal, just goes to show you how fast things change.