Bubble Update
March 4, 2016
We're now down to single-digit days in the countdown to Selection Sunday as the final games of the regular-season take place this weekend, and conference tourneys take center stage for the next week. The final full "Bracketology" update will be ready early enxt week. In the meantime, we have an updated Big Dance seeding list as of midweek.
1 - Kansas, Villanova, Michigan State, Virginia
2 - North Carolina, Xavier, Oklahoma, Miami-Fla
3 - Maryland, Oregon, West Virginia, Indiana
4 - Utah, Purdue, Wichita State, Kentucky
5 - Texas A&M, Duke, Iowa State, Arizona
6 - Baylor, Cal, Wisconsin, Providence
7 - Texas, South Carolina, Iowa, Dayton
8 - Notre Dame, Vanderbilt, Texas Tech, Colorado
9 - Pitt, Seton Hall, Saint Joseph's, Cincinnati
10 - UConn, VCU, Saint Mary's, Southern Cal
11 - San Diego State, St. Bonaventure, Butler, Monmouth
12 - Valparaiso, UALR, George Washington*, Temple*, Gonzaga*, Michigan*
13 - Chattanooga, UAB, Akron, Hawaii
14 - Princeton, UNCW, Belmont, Stephen F. Austin
15 - Stony Brook, South Dakota State, Weber State, New Mexico State
16 - FGCU, Winthrop, Hampton*, Texas Southern*, Wagner*, Bucknell*
*-Projected play-in game participants
Last four at-large byes...VCU, Butler, Southern Cal, St. Bonaventure
Last four in...George Washington, Temple, Gonzaga, Michigan
First four out...Tulsa, Syracuse, LSU, Houston
Next four out... Creighton, Washington, Ohio State, Alabama
Following is a last look at upcoming major conference tourney action and the "bubble" ramifications in each league.
AMERICAN
Bubble...Cincinnati, UConn, Temple, Tulsa, Houston
Conference Power Rating-7th
Tourney March 10-13 at Amway Center, Orlando, FL
Last year...NCAA-2 (Cincinnati-second round, SMU); NIT-3 (Temple-semifinals, Tulsa-second round, UConn).
NOTES...The most "bubble-icious" league in the land, perhaps, with no Big Dance locks into the final weekend of the regular, but a loop that nonetheless figures to get at least three bids. Who is likely left out of those mentioned above? Houston rates the longest shot, though its win last Sunday at UConn at least moved the Cougs back into the discussion, and the Thursday win over Cincinnati suddenly makes it appear possible for UH to get a scall on Selection Sunday. A deep foray in Orlando next week would at least have to make the selection committee take a further hard look at Kelvin Sampson's team. As for the Bearcats, they could really use a win over SMU on Sunday, or else face several must-win games next week in orlando. Meanwhile, Temple and Tulsa must take care of business this weekend to keep themselves viable heading into Orlando. UConn missed a chance on Thursday when losing big at SMU and has work to do next week in Orlando, though the Huskies should benefit on Selection Sunday from no truly bad losses. Temple is looking better after the Thursday win over Memphis, but has a lot to lose if it can't win at Tulane on Sunday.
ACC
Solid...North Carolina, Virginia, Miami-Florida, Duke, Notre Dame
Looking Good...Pittsburgh
Bubble...Syracuse
Conference Power Rating-2nd
Tourney March 9-13 at Verizon Center, Washington, D.C.
Last year...NCAA-6 (Duke-Champion, Notre Dame-Elite Eight, Louisville-Elite Eight, NC State-Sweet 16, North Carolina-Sweet 16, Virginia-second round); NIT-2 (Miami-Fla.-Runner-up, Pittsburgh)
NOTES...There will be a lot of jockeying for favorable NCAA Tourney seeds among the power teams at the Verizon Center next week. Should Virginia or North Carolina win the event, either will likely get a spot on the top line, and there remains a chance that both could end up as No. 1 seeds in their assigned regions. There also remains some bubble drama; with a chance to effectively seal an at-large bid, Pitt dropped the ball (literally and figuratively) in Wednesday's painful-to-watch loss at Virginia Tech. Which is not a terrible defeat, as Buzz Williams' Hokies now seem NIT-bound in their bounce-back season. But after their marquee win over Duke on Sunday, the Blacksburg trip offered the Panthers a chance to start making Big Dance preparations. Pitt should still make the field of 68, perhaps comfortably, but Jamie Dixon's team probably has a ceiling of an 8 seed right now. Which leaves us Syracuse, whose case has been reduced to moral victories, such as the close loss on Big Monday at North Carolina. But the Orange are still looking for a late push that lands it on the safe side of the cut line. We suspect they'll need to beat Florida State in the regular-season finale this weekend and avoid an early exit in D.C. next week to stay in the mix. Failure on either count might mean the NIT instead for Jim Boeheim. Clemson, by the way, is now officially off of the bubble after a gallant run peaked at midseason, but fizzled in recent weeks.
ATLANTIC 10
Solid...Dayton
Looking Good...Saint Joseph's
Bubble...George Washington, St. Bonaventure, Virginia Commonwealth
Conference-8th
Tourney March 9-13 at Barclays Center, Brooklyn, NY
Last year...NCAA-3 (Dayton-Second Round, Davidson, Virginia Commonwealth); NIT-3 (Richmond-Quarterfinals, George Washington-Second Round, Rhode Island-Second Round).
NOTES...Whew! Man, did Dayton need that midweek win at Richmond, which was not quite as tight as that 85-84 final score indicated (the Spiders hit a long three-ball at the final buzzer to make the score look a bit better for them and a lot better for any UR backers at the Vegas sports book who bet early and took the 1 1/2 points before the price dropped to 1!). On the heels of three losses in four games, the Flyers weren't exactly in bubble trouble, but there is at least no remaining worst-case scenario that could put Archie Miller's team even in a hint of danger. Though the recent wobble has likely cost the Flyers a protected seed. Elsewhere there is still a lot to play for heading into Brooklyn. St. Joe's is probably safe, but we can't yet say a lock after another loss to St. Bonaventure on Wednesday. For the Bonnies, it was their second win over the Hawks in a bang-up month that saw them also win on the road at Dayton and beat another bubbler, GW. There are bad losses at Duquesne and La Salle in A-10 play, and no significant wins to speak of in November and December, but Bona is 13-4 in a fairly well-regarded league. There is also now a little bit of buzz surrounding Bonnies star G Marcus Posley, whose 47 points Wednesday vs. St. Joe's marks a Division I scoring-high for this season. George Washington has something that Bona doesn't...quality non-conference wins over Virginia and Seton Hall. But the Colonials have their own bad losses (try DePaul and Saint Louis) that are going to keep them on the bubble into tourney week and require a good run in Brooklyn. VCU would be looking a lot safer if not for a recent loss at George Mason, but the Rams could go a long way to locking up an at-large bid if they can beat visiting Dayton on Saturday.
BIG EAST
Solid...Villanova, Xavier, Providence, Seton Hall
Bubble...Butler, Creighton, Marquette
Conference-5th
Tourney March 9-12 at Madison Square Garden, New York City, NY
Last year...NCAA-6 (Xavier-Sweet 16, Villanova-Second Round, Georgetown-Second Round, Butler-Second Round, Providence, St. John's).
NOTES...Since our first conference tourney preview in issue No. 26, both Providence and Seton Hall have moved onto safe ground. The Friars had a pair of semi must-win games in the past week vs. DePaul and Creighton to solidify their Big Dance bid, and got the job done. Along with worthy early-season marks and that huge win at Villanova in January, we don't think the Friars have anything to worry about, even after a wobbly February. The Hall's recent home wins over Xavier and Providence also have locked the Pirates into the field of 68. Not quite there is Butler, though the Bulldogs helped themselves immensely with the Wednesday win over Seton Hall after surviving a calamitous late-game meltdown at Georgetown on Sunday. With good non-league wins over Temple, Cincy, and Purdue, we're thinking Chris Holtmann's team might be able to lock up a bid before it takes the floor at Madison Square Garden if it can beat Marquette on Saturday. As for the Golden Eagles and Creighton, each might have Hail Mary-pass hopes to get back into the bubble discussion, and would probably have to advance to the Big East finale to even get that much mention, though their best ways to get to the Dance will be to win in New York next week. Otherwise, we're afraid both fall a bit short.
BIG TEN
Solid...Michigan State, Maryland, Indiana, Iowa, Purdue, Wisconsin
Bubble...Michigan, Ohio State
Conference-4th
Tourney March 9-13 at Bankers Life Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
Last year...NCAA-7 (Wisconsin-Runner-up, Michigan State-Final Four, Iowa-Second Round, Maryland-Second Round, Ohio State-Second Round, Indiana, Purdue); NIT-1 (Illinois).
NOTES...The bubble mix in the Big Ten has been reduced by one since our last update, as Wisconsin is now solidly in the field after its breathtaking run over the past five weeks. With no one expecting much of an encore this season in Madison after back-to-back Final Four runs and the departures of key cogs Frank Kaminsky and Sam Dekker, it has hardly been an uneventful campaign, with Bo Ryan's late-December retirement and a 9-9 start with losses to Milwaukee, Marquette, and Western Illinois at home, a point when even an NIT invitation seemed a longshot. Does any team better exemplify this wacky 2015-16 season? And when do the Badgers take the interim off HC Greg Gard's title? Any bubble attention next week in Indy thus turns to Michigan, whose 20-10 SU record does not overwhelm. But in a season like this when those 10 defeats involve only high-level foes, a team stays in the mix. John Beilein's bunch helps its cause immensely if it can win this weekend vs. faltering Iowa, whose recent skid has taken it out of protected seed territory and the likely assignment to the preferable Des Moines sub-regional. Let's get serious, however...the Hawkeyes are not going to land on the wrong side of the cut line. Can't say the same about Ohio State, which did beat Iowa last week and has a December win over Kentucky...but only one other top-100 win. The Buckeyes can get very serious about their at-large chances if they can upset Michigan State this weekend. But that's a big if, as the Spartans are back on the ascent and taking aim at a top regional seed, which they likely secure if they win in Indy next week.
BIG 12
Solid...Kansas, Oklahoma, Baylor, Iowa State, West Virginia, Texas
Looking Good...Texas Tech
Conference-1st
Tourney March 9-12 at Sprint Center, Kansas City, MO
Last year...NCAA-7 (Oklahoma-Sweet 16, West Virginia-Sweet 16, Kansas-Second Round, Baylor, Iowa State, Oklahoma State, Texas).
NOTES...There's a chance we get two top-line teams from the Big 12, though at this point we'd say that Oklahoma has to win the event in Kansas City next week for a top regional seed. Otherwise the Sooners likely settle for a 2 slot but, most importantly, get ticketed to the nearby Oklahoma City sub-regional at The Peake. As for white-hot Kansas, it could end up as the number one overall seed and could stay on the top line even if its loses at Sprint Center next week. If Texas Tech wins its regular-season finale this weekend vs. Kansas State, we'd be prepared to call the Red Raiders a lock. Just in case they lose, however, they risk taking a 3-game losing streak into Kansas City, and a quick exit at Sprint Center could put them back in the soup. But Tubby Smith's team bought itself plenty of cushion with its recent 3-week blitz, as well as owning the top-rated schedule in the country. Those sort of credentials are usually good enough to qualify for the Dance.
BIG WEST
Bubble...Hawaii
Conference-13th
Tourney March 10-12 at Honda Center, Anaheim, CA, home of the NHL Ducks
Last year...NCAA-1 (UC Irvine); NIT-1 (UC Davis); CBI-1 (UC Santa Barbara)
NOTES...Prior to last week's stunning home loss to underdog UC Riverside, some regional observers believed Hawaii might have an at-large case. Now, unless some divine intervention arrives from the ghost of Don Ho, that appears very unlikely, and we'll have to see how the Rainbow Warriors deal with the conference tourney in the middle of enemy territory in Orange County (Anaheim Honda Canter), where local teams and top contenders UC Irvine and Long Beach State figure to be well-supported. Although the team many are watching is UCSB, which has made late surges in the past for shrewd, vet HC Bob Williams and had won six straight heading into Thursday's game at the Thunderdome vs. UCR.
COLONIAL
Conference tourney champ will be only Big Dance rep
Conference-10th
Tourney March 4-7 at Royal Farms Baltimore Arena, Baltimore, MD
Last year...NCAA-1 (Northeastern); NIT-1 (William & Mary); CBI-1 (Hofstra); CIT-2 (James Madison, UNC-Wilmington).
TOURNEY PREVIEW...The CAA Tourney has not only been wide-open in recent years, but it has featured many nail-biters and cliffhangers to boot. Any hoop junkies in the mid-Atlantic region who want to see some exciting action and are willing to risk a trip into downtown Baltimore should be well-rewarded. Regional observers believe there are six teams (UNCW, Hofstra, William & Mary, James Madison, Northeastern, and local Towson) with legit shots in this event, which commences on Friday.
CONFERENCE USA
Bubble...UAB
Conference-22nd
Tourney March 8-12 at Birmingham-Jefferson Civic Center, Birmingham, AL (not the home court of UAB, which plays at Gene Bartow Arena)
Last year...NCAA-1 (UAB-Second Round); NIT-3 (Old Dominion-Semifinals, La Tech-Quarterfinals, UTEP); CIT-1 (Middle Tennessee).
NOTES...With UAB's bubble chances appearing extremely remote, C-USA appears to be a one-bid league. Once again, however, the Birmingham venue suggests that Jerod Haase's hometown Blazers are the team to beat. Last year, they won as an underdog; this year they wear the target as the favorite. But there are legitimate cases to be made for no fewer than six other contenders (La Tech, Middle Tennessee, Marshall, Old Dominion, and slightly longer-shots UTEP and Charlotte). Those looking to prepare for the NIT, CBI, CIT, and the new Vegas 16 should keep a close watch on developments, as C-USA reps are likely to be popular in those non-Big Dance events.
HORIZON
Bubble...Valparaiso
Conference-19th
Tourney March 5-8 at Joe Louis Arena, Detroit, MI
Last year...NCAA-1 (Valparaiso); NIT-1 (Green Bay); CIT-2 (Cleveland State-Second Round, Oakland).
NOTES...So, does Valpo have an at-large case? We think the Crusaders should, and note a couple of pre-league losses when dealing with injuries. The Crusader profile really does not look much worse than Wichita State's, though we suppose there is a case to be made for the Missouri Valley being a stronger league than the Horizon. By how much, we're not sure. So, to be safe, Bryce Drew's team is best advised to win the conference tourney, where local foes Detroit and Oakland, and perhaps Green Bay, loom as the top contenders. The venue for this event is now Joe Louis Arena in Detroit, the home of the NHL Red Wings and rarely a basketball venue since the Pistons were forced to play a few playoff games in 1985 in the building. So even though there might be a local edge for the Titans and the Motown suburb-based Golden Grizzlies, none of these teams in the Horizon has ever played a game at the Joe, and it is not really a long drive for fans of most of the teams in this regional league (Valpo only 3 hours or so away by car).
MID-AMERICAN
Conference tourney champ will be only Big Dance rep
Conference-10th
Tourney first round March 9 at campus sites; quarters, semis, and Final March 11-14 at Quicken Loans Arena, Cleveland, OH
Last year...NCAA-1 (Western Michigan-2nd round); NIT-1 (Toledo); CIT-3 (Ohio-3rd round, Eastern Michigan-2nd round, Akron).
TOURNEY PREVIEW...We stretched things a couple of weeks ago when putting Akron on the bubble. But after the Zips suffered recent losses at Kent State and Miami-Ohio, James Carville couldn't even sell the Akron at-large candidacy to the selection committee. So, as usual, it's win or else for Akron and everyone else next week in Cleveland, as the MAC will continue its 0-for-this-millennium streak of failing to get multiple entries into the Big Dance (1999 was the last time accomplished). No team appears completely out of the mix, as even Miami-Ohio, which had struggled all season, has scored a few wins lately. There is not a league tourney with as many teams having a chance as the MAC.
MISSOURI VALLEY
Solid...Wichita State
Bubble...Northern Iowa
Conference-11th
Tourney ("Arch Madness") March 3-6 at Scottrade Center, St. Louis, MO
Last year...NCAA-2 (Wichita State-Sweet 16, Northern Iowa-Second Round); NIT-1 (Illinois State-Second Round); CBI-1 (Loyola-Chicago-Champion); CIT-1 (Evansville-Champion).
NOTES...Don't argue with us about Wichita, which we assure you will be in the field of 68 no matter what happens at Arch Madness in St. Louis this weekend. A 23-7 record overall, a 16-2 mark in the Missouri Valley (both losses by single digits), the No. 1 per-possession defense (adjusted for competition) in all of college basketball, a top-10 rank in Ken Pomeroy's adjusted efficiency, and a top-25 perch in the BPI are already good enough for an "up" vote. The Shockers' flaws on paper can be explained in large part by the early-season injury to PG Fred VanVleet, who missed all three games at the Disney World Tourney during Thanksgiving week, which wound up being losses to USC, Alabama, and Iowa. It took VanVleet to get healthy, but the Shockers ended up roughly where we thought they would be. By virtue of wins over North Carolina, Iowa State, and Wichita, Northern Iowa can cling to the periphery of the bubble due to the VCU example of 2011, when the Rams were apparently the last team in when no bracketologist had them close to the final cut. Then VCU went out and made it to the Final Four. In St. Louis this weekend, also do not dismiss Evansville or late-charging Illinois State, which beat Wichita four weeks ago and shocked the Shockers at Scottrade Center last March.
MOUNTAIN WEST
Bubble...San Diego State, Boise State
Conference-9th
Tourney March 9-12 at Thomas & Mack Center, Las Vegas, NV (home court of UNLV)
Last year...NCAA-3 (San Diego State-Second Round, Wyoming, Boise State-First Four); NIT-1 (Colorado State).
NOTES...Shouldn't Boise at least get some mention when the selection committee meets next week in Indianapolis? The Broncos dipped for a bit at midseason but have seemingly recovered and did KO San Diego State on the road last week. Which, in Big Dance terms, might have been more significant for damaging the Aztecs' at-large hopes. But SDSU's profile has been helped in recent weeks by a surge from Cal, which is the Aztecs' only non-conference victim of note. The new buzz in the Mountain is to keep an eye on recently-surging Fresno State, the only MW team other than Boise to beat SDSU this season. But the best advice for either the Broncos or Aztecs is to simply win the conference tourney at the Thomas & Mack Center and not have to worry about Selection Sunday. We do suggest paying attention to the MW Tourney if interested in scouting for other non-Big Dance postseason events, as many MW reps figure to populate those competitions.
PAC 12
Solid...Oregon, Utah, Arizona, Cal
Looking Good...Colorado, Southern Cal
Bubble...Washington, Oregon State
Conference-3rd
Tourney March 9-12 at MGM Grand Garden Arena, Las Vegas, NV
Last year...NCAA-4 (Arizona-Elite Eight, UCLA-Sweet 16, Utah-Sweet 16, Oregon-Second Round) NIT-2 (Stanford-Champion, Arizona State-Second Round); CBI-1 (Colorado-Second round).
NOTES...Recent developments to note in the Pac are Oregon securing at least a share of its first Pac crown since 2002, plus and the recent surge by Utah which has likely put the Utes in protected seed territory. There has also been a recent and alarming dip by Southern Cal, which lost five of six before temporarily righting the ship in a Wednesday win over Oregon State. That victory got SC to 20 wins and has moved it closer to safety, but a loss in the regular-season finale to Oregon and a quick exit in the Pac-12 Tourney next week in Vegas would give the committee an excuse to kick out the Trojans, who would have lost 7 of their last 9 in that scenario. The other recent storyline has been Oregon State, which took a blow in its Wednesday loss to the Trojans at Galen Center but remains the object of enormous affection by the RPI, which had the Beavs as high as 28 earlier this week. Why the love for OSU? Because Wayne Tinkle's team played just four non-Pac foes who currently exist outside the RPI top 150, and only two (Quinnipiac, Cal State Fullerton) are hovering near the dreaded 300 range. Throw in a road game against Kansas, a road win at top-100 UC Santa Barbara, a neutral-court victory over bubbly Tulsa, and there's your bubble case!
SEC
Solid...Kentucky, Texas A&M
Looking Good...South Carolina, Vanderbilt
Bubble...Alabama, Ole Miss, LSU, Florida
Conference-6th
Tourney March 11-15 at Bridgestone Arena, Nashville, TN (home of the NHL Predators)
Last year...NCAA-5 (Kentucky-Final Four, Arkansas-Second Round, LSU, Ole Miss, Georgia); NIT-3 (Vanderbilt-Quarterfinals, Alabama-Second Round, Texas A&M-Second Round).
NOTES...The recent "it" team in the SEC is Vandy, which can move into the "solid" category with a win at Texas A&M this weekend. If the Dores lose in College Station, they are probably going to have to do a bit of good work in next week's SEC Tourney, which for the second straight year is being held in Vandy's hometown on Nashville. As for South Carolina, its weak pre-league slate is proving a bit of a problem with the computer numbers, but as long as they don't lose both vs. Georgia and Arkansas before heading to Nashville next week, the Gamecocks should be safe. The bubble cases for LSU and especially Florida (with four straight losses into this weekend's regular-season finale at Mizzou) and Bama (loser of 3 of its last 4) are looking increasingly dicey.
SUN BELT
Bubble...UA-Little Rock
Conference-20th
Tourney March 10-13 at Lakefront Arena, New Orleans, LA
Last year...NCAA-1 (Georgia State-Second Round); CIT-2 (ULM-Runner-up, UL-Lafayette-Third Round).
NOTES...Well, what about UALR's chances as an at-large, if the Trojans need to go that route? They have kept chugging thru the Sun Belt and will be top seed for next week's tourney at the UNO Lakefront Arena. The computer numbers are good. There are non-conference wins at bubbly San Diego State and Tulsa. We would have said they're in no matter what happens next week in New Orleans until they lost in a stunner on Thursday at Appalachian State. Now, is anyone up to knocking off UALR and its highly-ranked scoring defense? UTA is down top scorer Kevin Hervey and faded from the race after his injury. Which leaves UL-Monroe and UL-Lafayette and maybe Georgia State (which slumped at midseason but appears to be regathering) as the two most likely to give the Trojans a scare.
WEST COAST
Looking Good...Saint Mary's
Bubble...Gonzaga
Conference-12th
Tourney March 3-8 at Orleans Hotel Arena, Las Vegas, NV
Last year...NCAA-2 (Gonzaga-Elite Eight, BYU-First Four); NIT-1 (Saint Mary's); CBI-1 (Pepperdine); CIT-1 (Portland).
NOTES...Is it just us, or do these other bracketologists seem to enjoy kicking Gonzaga's at-large chances the way Stephen Colbert likes to trash Donald Trump? We still think the Zags have a decent shot at an at-large, though of course they will want to win the WCC Tourney in Las Vegas to guarantee avoiding what would be their first Big Dance miss since 1998. Whether Gonzaga has a top-50 win depends largely on which way the RPI wind is blowing and whether that wind has knocked UConn below or above that semi-arbitrary line of demarcation. Though the Zags' narrow escape from Provo, and a desperate BYU team, last Saturday night was a positive sign for Mark Few's team. As for Saint Mary's, it felt compelled to add Tuesday's oddball bit of scheduling against WAC contender Grand Canyon to help the profile. It would have been a torpedo hit to lose to Dan Majerle's Antelopes, but instead it is another win to help (perhaps not much, but at least a bit) the Gaels' computer numbers. The at-large feels very reachable, if needed, in Moraga.