2* Memphis Tigers +11.5 -110
The Line: Due to public perception, USF easily gets double digits here, and the public is still laying it. No fishy lines here. I came into this game expecting USF to be double digits, and they are completely overvalued.
Motivation: USF has been a program on the rise, and for the first time in school history was ranked preseason. They saw their ranking rise to #10 after a strong start, but after this team was exposed, they dropped fast and now went from playing for a potential BCS game, to the first day of bowl games. We have seen USF get up and get motivated for big upsets over major BCS schools like Auburn, West Virginia, etc. But they have also been the victim to let downs vs. teams they shouldnt lose to. You have to expect Memphis to be the motivated team here, and USF to come out flat, regardless of where this game is.
My Line: USF -3
Trends: Memphis won the most recent meeting in 2004 31-14. Tigers are 8-2 ATS in their last 10 games as an underdog of 10.5 or greater. Bulls are 3-8 ATS in their last 11 games as a favorite. Bulls are 1-4 ATS in their last 5 non-conference games.
Stat of the Game: Memphis sports 5 receivers with at least 25 catches this year, showing how they can spread the ball and remain balanced.
Analysis: Conference USA is very similar to the Big East, IMO, with not much seperating the two conferences. In fact, my formulas give South FL a strength of schedule of 62 and Memphis 69, showing that their schedules weren't that far off. USF can take advantage of finesse teams, with predictable attacks, but they struggle vs. offenses with balance. Memphis has balance on offense with a playmaking QB that can run with the ball, a 1,000 yard rusher, and 5 receivers that have at least 25 receptions. Memphis can spread the ball around and most importantly they can run the ball, running clock and keeping Grothe on the sideline. Meanwhile, USF is a one man show and teams have figured out USF - stop Matt Grothe. He is their leading passer and leading rusher by a mile. Ford has only 350+ yards on the ground this year, their leading rusher that is a RB. USF sports 3 players with 25+ catches. And after graduating their stud cornerbacks, and their stud running back a few years ago, this team has quietly gotten progressively worse, while getting built up in the media simply because Grothe was still the QB and Selive was still rushing QBs. However, USF has backed off their blitzing now that they have new corners, and Selvie has seen his sack total drop tremendously. Memphis does a terrific job of protecting the QB, ranking 26 in the country in sacks allowed, and his scrambling ability means Memphis should be able to convert 3rd downs and keep the chains moving - a category that they already have the advantage in over USF.
Memphis has not lost a lot of games by double digits this year. In fact, just two games. One to Ole Miss who is a very good, underrated team and one to East Carolina at East Carolina when East Carolina was playing very good football. Other than that, they have kept all of their losses close. USF is not built to blow people out as evidenced by their schedule. Tenn-Martin (horrible), Syracuse (horrible) and NC State (when they were playing very bad football and didnt have their starting QB going), are the only 3 teams USF has beaten by double digits. Common opponents UCF, and Louisville, both beat Memphis and USF by similar margins - less than double digits.
USF comes backing into this bowl game, losing 5 of their last 7 games. Memphis, meanwhile, comes in winning 3 of their last 4. USF has also only scored 14 PPG in their last 5 games, a major sign that Grothe being a one man show does not cut it for this offense. Memphis has holes in the defense, but if they can stop Grothe, key in on him, run the football on offense and continue to spread the wealth, and pound that ground game, they have a very good shot at winning this game straight up.
11 points is way too much here. USF is simply not what they used to be, and these two teams are very comparable.
USF 27
Memphis 24