Why do I win at betting NFL but not college football? by Covers
When it comes to the North American sports betting scene, football rules the world. It's college on Saturdays and NFL on Sundays - two days that hold priority over the rest of the week’s wagering schedule.
So maybe you’re killing it in college but can’t seem to win Sundays. Or you dominate the pro game but the NCAA kids are draining your bankroll like you’re the one putting them through school. What the hell is wrong – it’s all football. Right? So why do I suck at one and not the other?
It’s an age-old question sports bettors of all shapes (squares) and sizes (whales) have asked themselves.
I win at NFL, but suck at capping college…
Too many teams
There are 128 FBS football programs out there and umpteen FCS schools making guest appearances during the course of the season. If you think you can get a good grip on all of them, you’re losing before you even place a bet.
If you’re golden on the NFL gridiron but can’t seem to have Saturday success, perhaps you’re getting in over your head with the 70-something college games available each week. You’re used to 32 NFL teams, so why not narrow down your strike zone and concentrate on just a conference or two.
Focus on learning as much as you can about the Big Ten, ACC or Pac-12. Conference play is kicking off, so if you’ve been getting smashed with all the non-conference clashes and FCS punching bags, now is the best time to trim your pickings.
Bigger mismatches
When you bet on NFL games, there’s a certain standard you expect when the whistle blows. These dudes are the best of the best, so you’re going to get a fair shake in just about every game.
The same can’t be said for college. Power programs like Alabama, Oregon and Ohio State have more talent picking splinters out of their butts on the bench than leagues like the Sun Belt and C-USA have on their All-Conference teams.
A double-digit dog is a rare commodity in the pros but an every-week occurrence in the college ranks. And trying to make sense of a 30-point NCAAF spread is like reading IKEA instructions in Japanese for the hardcore NFL fan. Where do we start?
Even within the same conference, a school like Georgia is on a completely different level than a program like Vanderbilt. Guys go to UGA to make the jump to the pros. Guys go to Vanderbilt to cure Ebola. Push comes to shove on the football field, the guy in the lab coat tends to get the points - lots of them.
Approach to games
Many successful NFL cappers build a career on going against the grain. The media have been buzzing about the Cardinals and their dominance over their first three opponents, and the public is jumping all over Arizona, moving the spread from -6 to -7. Screw you, I’m fading the Cards.
Contrarian capping holds a lot more water on Sundays than it does Saturday. You might be able to make some money walking into the wind in NFL, but college demands a much more wide-open approach. It may sound like a cliché, but every game is different – especially when it comes to college football.
For example, in the NFL, an injury to a starting lineman may not have any impact on how a team performs, with a stacked depth chart and experience waiting in reserves. Hit a college team with the same injury to a starter and you start bringing in red-shirt freshmen who can’t even grow a mustache yet.
Others factors that have more importance to college bettors are coaching matchups, momentum, and revenge spots and rivalry games. It’s easy to get a 20-something, testosterone-fueled meat head hyped up about kicking someone’s ass just because that’s school tradition. Get some!
That same motivational technique doesn’t quite have the same effect on a grown-ass man trying to put his kids through private school with performance incentives plastered all over his multi-million dollar NFL contract.
I’m awesome at college, but crap at NFL…
Sharper lines/Public influence
You’re a sucker fish or one of those weirdo lobster things in your dentist’s fish tank. In other words, you’re a bottom feeder feasting on the crap at the bottom of a sea of college football teams.
You swoop in and snatch up Mountain West Conference opening odds and you count down the seconds until MAC totals hit the board in the middle of the week. You’re like one of those crazy extreme couponing moms that gets a high on the best deals and takes advantage of the softer numbers showing up in the mid-major leagues.
But when you go bargain shopping in the NFL, where there are only 32 teams and oddsmakers know them inside and out, you aren’t finding the same early value in the odds.
Your Saturday college plays swung an average of four points since post and you’re looking to middle the hell out of your bookie. Your Sunday plays, on the other hand, have inched a combined 1.5 points since hitting the board and there’s zero wiggle room on those wagers. If you settle for one more NFL push you’re going to pooch punt your iPhone into the neighbor’s pool.
And when you do find an NFL wager with extra value stuffed inside the crust, it’s not long until the public sucks everything good out of it and swings the vig. You could end up paying a lot more for a wager you liked Tuesday but made on Wednesday.
For some small-conference college games, you may be a handful of bettors getting involved at the book. For NFL matchups, you’re just one of the thousands of faces to inch your way to the counter and take your ticket.
Level of Parity
We’ve heard the “On any given Sunday…” spiel over and over again, but it seems the old football hymn speaks truer in recent years.
Sure, you have your elite teams, but not like you had 30 years ago – or even 10 or 15 years ago when teams like the Patriots and Rams were consistently giving a double scoop of points each week. We’ve already seen Baltimore take a tumble and Seattle and Indianapolis look like run of the mill squads.
College football cappers getting down on the pros can often underestimate just how good each and every NFL team is, especially when you’re used to the canyon-like divide between many of the top teams in college football and the schools ranked second and third behind them in the conference.
“When you take the top two or three teams and the bottom two or three teams out of the equation, any team can beat any team on any given Sunday,” says Covers Expert Marc Lawrence. “You simply need to put tape over the names of the teams and handicap accordingly.”
Team news
Old school handicappers used to get newspapers from all over the country, trying to find that one story from the team’s beat reporter that would give them the inside edge over the oddsmakers. A key injury, a coach’s game plan, or a bad week of practice – anything that could be used as ammo when placing your bets.
Now, the internet makes all those papers – from Spokane to Syracuse – available at our finger tips and oddsmakers are usually the first ones to find out when news breaks. However, the opportunity is still there when it comes to the small college programs, who have one local guy and maybe a student reporter posting info on Twitter.
While you can squeeze out some valuable tidbits from college football team news, the NFL has such a huge blanket of coverage that you get updates straight to your phone if a backup WR sneezes.
Trying to base your bets on what you read in the newspaper, online, off Twitter or heard being shouted at full blast on ESPN – seriously guys, did everyone just come from a rock concert? – is like asking for cheese and sauce when you order a pizza. It’s already been factored in.
If you’re able to scoop your bookie when a NFL suspension suddenly comes down or a starting pro QB is ruled out, more power to you. But chances are the game will be off the board or already adjusted by the time your browser finally loads.