Who is the most overrated QB of all time?

[soonerfanjames]

Ron Mexico

 

[pubguy]

any black QB not named doug williams, warren moon, and ill give ya randall cunningham to

That guy in Philly has lived up to the hype for the most part.

 

[Uno]

vick without a doubt.

 

[RedElephants]

that's your list of possible overrated QBs???

It is if you are going to ponder putting Favre on the list. If you are, you might as well put them all up there. You have to be considered good to be over rated don't you.

My Top 3 Over-Rated QB's:

1. Joe Namath- Joe Wille was a dominant athlete in both basketball and football in high school. He was great at Alabama until he damaged a knee badly. From that point he got the Courage Award more than the Greatest Qb Achievement. He played on injuries no man should have and was damaged goods by the time he got to the Jets. His fame is that one Super Bowl. But I can't help but wonder in today's world what he could have done healthy.

2. Troy Aikman-Aikman’s career production, by any measure, was only average. He was surrounded by a Hall of Fame running back, a Hall of Fame receiver, and at least one Hall of Fame offensive lineman (Larry Allen). That fact that all this talent led to very ordinary career numbers from Aikman tells us that he was, at least during the regular season, a very ordinary quarterback.

3. Warren Moon- mediocre efficiency numbers, poor playoff performances and a record-setting case of fumble-itis.

 

[dealerguy04]

and i will give you mcnabb as well you are right he has never had anything but westbrook and a bunch of bums outside of TO for a couple years

 

[pubguy]

2. Troy Aikman-Aikman’s career production, by any measure, was only average. He was surrounded by a Hall of Fame running back, a Hall of Fame receiver, and at least one Hall of Fame offensive lineman (Larry Allen). That fact that all this talent led to very ordinary career numbers from Aikman tells us that he was, at least during the regular season, a very ordinary quarterback.

Bradshaw for the same reasons.HOF skill players on offense and 6 or 7 HOFers on defense. How many times did he get away with just throwing it up for Swann or Stalworth?

 

[quantumleap]

2. Troy Aikman-Aikman’s career production, by any measure, was only average. He was surrounded by a Hall of Fame running back, a Hall of Fame receiver, and at least one Hall of Fame offensive lineman (Larry Allen). That fact that all this talent led to very ordinary career numbers from Aikman tells us that he was, at least during the regular season, a very ordinary quarterback.

Bradshaw for the same reasons.HOF skill players on offense and 6 or 7 HOFers on defense. How many times did he get away with just throwing it up for Swann or Stalworth?

Beat me to it!! I've been saying this since the early 80's.

:toast:

 

[CarolinaKid]

Doug Williams get my vote here...ck

 

[dealerguy04]

bradshaw definately give me a defense and all the talented guys in the league and call me a quarterback

 

[Fearloathing]

I am a Cowboys fan too and I still just pulled my hair out watching Aikmen throw it right to the wrong jersey. Can't remember how many times I screamed at the Screen for them to just hand it to Emmitt lol.

 

[NorthernStar]

If you are looking at supposedly grerat qb who were over rated look no further than Elway.

 

[dealerguy04]

If you are looking at supposedly grerat qb who were over rated look no further than Elway.

LMAO!!! you are the winner of the stupidest comment in forum history anywhere Elway was top 3 all-time and many feel the best ever:nohead:

 

[dealerguy04]

you are from minnesota though so you wouldn't know what a great QB is

 

[Fearloathing]

Elway was legit I think...I think Montana is as well...Marino is my most underrated as much as most are going to hate that comment.

 

[pubguy]

If you are looking at supposedly grerat qb who were over rated look no further than Elway.

Top three in 4th qtr comebacks, 5 SBs - first three without much additional offensive talent. I wish my Texans had such an overrated QB!

 

[AlistairCookie]

Well, I don't know any other QBs who would be losing by 3+ TDs with two interceptions and two dropped interceptions who would STILL have the announcers and the network and producers still standing in line to suck his nutz.

 

[pubguy]

Well, I don't know any other QBs who would be losing by 3+ TDs with two interceptions and two dropped interceptions who would STILL have the announcers and the network and producers still standing in line to suck his nutz.

The legend had a poor performance tonight in his third game with a new team. The sky is falling. We're all doomed. Favre overrated. LOL

 

[C-Gold]

Mike Vick.

 

[Harvey Dent]

Joe Namath rather easily

 

[Joe_Hallenbeck]

I think Manning is a better QB than Favre. Although none of Favre's offensive teammates in any part of his career will be joining him in Canton.

However, in 10-20 years, are you going to brag to your kids that you saw Peyton Manning play in person or that you saw Favre? If you said Manning, you either:

a. are a homosexual

or

b. a colts fan