Thursday's Tip Sheet
By Joe Nelson
College football is back and gone are the days of just one marquee game on opening night. This season’s Thursday night card features 10 contests, including several major conference teams in action in important games. Here is a look at three of the biggest games that will open up the 2015 college football season Thursday night.
Match-up: South Carolina Gamecocks vs. North Carolina Tar Heels
Venue: Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, North Carolina (Neutral Site)
Time/TV: Thursday, Sep. 3, 6:00 PM ET – ESPN
Line: South Carolina -2.5, Over/Under 64.5
Last Meeting: 2013, South Carolina (-12) 27-10 at home
South Carolina has been accustomed to playing on opening night and it usually has been a successful outing, including beating the Tar Heels to open the 2013 season the last time these programs met. Last season, a South Carolina squad that opened the season in the top 10 of the national rankings was blown out at home against Texas A&M. The Gamecocks lost 52-28 as a 10-point favorite and the final score was closer than the game ever felt as the Aggies made a big opening statement and wiped away the lofty season goals for the Gamecocks immediately.
This season, the expectations are far more grounded for Steve Spurrier’s squad entering his 11th season with the program. Sophomore Connor Mitch won a multi-player battle at the quarterback position and the Gamecocks will have new personnel throughout the offense with very few starters from 2014 returning. One of those returnees is wide receiver Pharoh Cooper, who had the second most yardage in the SEC last season and figures to rate as a 2016 NFL draft prospect as a receiver and a kick returner despite lacking great height.
South Carolina has been a sound defensive team for most of Spurrier’s tenure, but that changed in 2015 with over 30 points per game allowed and over 430 yards per game allowed. The Gamecocks allowed 34 or more points in six of the eight SEC games. The defense has most of last season’s key players back, but this will be a difficult opening matchup going up against a potentially explosive North Carolina offense. The Tar Heels fell short of expectations last season as has been the norm on the football field in the last decade in Chapel Hill. North Carolina returns junior quarterback Marquise Williams, who was the team’s top rusher as well as passer last season and most of his teammates from starting roles last season on the offense are also back.
Larry Fedora has seen the Tar Heels decline in wins each of the last two seasons after going 8-4 in 2012 and last season the Tar Heels allowed 39 points per game and 498 yards per game, featuring the worst defense in the ACC. This is a program known for producing NFL talent on defense but the front seven has lacked that type of talent the last two years and the defense is not likely to make a huge leap forward in 2015 as more high scoring showdowns could be possible. The total on this game is set rather high and it seems likely that South Carolina might have a more conservative approach early with a young quarterback while hoping to keep the Tar Heels off the field. Despite looking like a great offensive team on paper, it is worth noting that the Tar Heels posted just 28 points combined in the final two games last season with ugly losses to average NC State and Rutgers teams.
Historical Trends: South Carolina is just 3-6 ATS in neutral site games going back to New Year’s Day 2009, but the Gamecocks are on an 11-3-1 ATS run since 2000 when favored by 3 or fewer points. South Carolina is 7-10 ATS in season openers going back to 1998 though 5-5 ATS under Spurrier with the defeat last season as the first S/U loss. Under Fedora, North Carolina is just 5-8 ATS as an underdog with only three S/U upset wins, all of which came as an underdog of fewer than seven points. The Tar Heels are 2-6 S/U in neutral site games going back to 2004, but they did win the Belk Bowl against Cincinnati in this stadium after the 2013 season. North Carolina has just one S/U win in six meetings between these teams since 1988.
Match-up: Michigan Wolverines at Utah Utes
Venue: Rice-Eccles Stadium in Salt Lake City, Utah
Time/TV: Thursday, Sep. 3, 8:30 PM ET – FOX Sports 1
Line: Utah -5.5 Over/Under 46.5
Last Meeting: 2014, Utah (+3.5) 26-10 at Michigan
Even in a down cycle, Michigan remains one of the most prominent college football programs in the nation and the hiring of Jim Harbaugh back to Ann Arbor puts the Wolverines back in the national spotlight. Harbaugh inherits a veteran roster and his reputation for quick success in his previous stops has many feeling very optimistic about Michigan’s chances to seriously compete right away in the Big Ten. Harbaugh has not officially announced a starting quarterback with Iowa transfer Jake Rudock and junior Shane Morris both in the mix. While it was a very disappointing 5-7 season for Michigan in 2014 under Brady Hoke, a -16 turnover margin and a handful of close losses are things that could turn around this season to produce better results with a similar roster.
Michigan actually had very respectable defensive numbers last season allowing just 22 points per game and 311 yards per game with particular success against the run, allowing just 3.2 yards per rush. The Wolverines also allowed only one 300 yard passing game all season. Seven starters are back on the defense and there is little reason to expect much of a drop off with the secondary for Michigan looking especially strong. In last season’s home meeting with Utah, Michigan lost 26-10 at home, but the Wolverines had more yards only to be burned by four turnovers and a punt return touchdown as Utah did not look like a vastly superior team.
The Utes wound up 9-4 last season for the most successful season for the program since moving to the Pac-12. Utah was in the Pac-12 South race for much of the season, but while it could be argued that Michigan underachieved last season, the Utes certainly overachieved with all five Pac-12 wins coming by six or fewer points and some great fortune with two double-overtime wins. Travis Wilson returns at quarterback after posting efficient numbers last season, but the Utes are a bit depleted at the receiver position with only one last season’s top four receivers back. Devontae Booker will carry a heavy load for the offense after rushing for over 1,500 yards last season, but Michigan will not be an easy team to rush against and Booker had just 34 yards in the matchup last season.
Utah will be a productive defensive team with the potential to force turnovers again as the front seven looks very promising even with the departure of Nate Orchard who had 18.5 sacks and was a second round pick in the NFL draft. The secondary remains the question mark for the Utah defense with injuries taking a toll on the defensive backs last season and limited experience for this season’s group. This is a huge home date for Utah with a truly marquee matchup for a home opener, something that has not occurred since at least 2010 when Utah beat a ranked Pittsburgh team to start the season. This will be a key game in determining the trajectory of the season for two programs looking to take the next step.
Historical Trends: Michigan last opened the season with a true road game in 1998 though the Wolverines did lose to Alabama to open the 2012 season in Arlington. Michigan is 5-1 ATS in season openers since 2009 with the loss to the Tide as the lone miss, but they were a heavy home favorite in most of those games. Michigan is on a 6-10 ATS run as a road underdog since 2009 and since 2007, Michigan is just 12-24-1 ATS in all road games. Utah is just 11-21 ATS as a home favorite of fewer than 10 points since 2000 while going just 3-7 ATS in season openers under Kyle Whittingham, though with just two S/U losses.
Match-up: TCU Horned Frogs at Minnesota Golden Gophers
Venue: TCF Bank Stadium in Minneapolis, Minnesota
Time/TV: Thursday, Sep. 3, 9:000 PM ET – ESPN
Line: TCU -14.5, Over/Under 57.5
Last Meeting: 2014, TCU (-16.5) 30-7 at home
Coming off a 4-8 season in 2013, TCU was certainly pegged as a team likely to improve in 2014 and when the Frogs dominated Minnesota in week 2 of the season, TCU started to get some attention. That game was in Fort Worth and while the Frogs had a big early lead, they were aided greatly by turnovers to pull away and were held well below their eventual season production average in the 30-7 win. Trevone Boykin was mostly unknown nationally at the start of last season and he did not have a great game vs. the Gophers, but by the end of last season, he was one of the most productive quarterbacks in the nation. He will enter the 2015 season in the spotlight as one of the Heisman favorites on a national title contender.
TCU has almost everyone back on offense and it was a team that scored over 46 points per game with over 530 yards per game. Top returning wide receiver Josh Doctson is recovering from a broken hand but he is expected to play and Boykin and senior running back Aaron Green will provide great threats on the ground. The questions for TCU are with an inexperienced defense that lost six of the top seven tacklers from last season on a defense that allowed a lot more yardage than the 19 points per game average against suggests. Five times TCU allowed 27 or more points and the statistics were padded a bit facing two lightweight foes in non-conference play.
The Big Ten West looks a bit wide open this season with three teams making coaching changes and if not for a more difficult schedule than its peers, Minnesota might be tabbed to take the title. The Gophers draw both Michigan and Ohio State from the East for a big disadvantage in the division race, but it has been a steady climb forward in four years for the program under Jerry Kill. With back-to-back 8-5 seasons, this is now a respectable program and the Gophers have started to win some big games, winning at Michigan and at Nebraska last season while also blowing out rival Iowa at home. This is a great opportunity for the program with a chance to make a huge national splash to start the season in one of the biggest home dates in many years.
Minnesota lacks flash on offense and with few returning receivers and the loss of 1,600 yard rusher David Cobb as the offense will lean heavily on imposing junior quarterback Mitch Leidner’s legs and a conservative offensive approach. The offensive line will be a strong point and against a formidable offense expect Minnesota to aim to move the chains and limit the possessions in the game. Minnesota does have some promise on defense with a quality linebacker corps and great depth up front as they should be a fairly difficult team to run against despite some inconsistency last season. It is a tough task for the Gophers in the opening week, but also a great opportunity while being a statement chance for TCU to pick up a quality road win and earn a spot on top of the national playoff conversation after being left out last season.
Historical Trends: TCU is just 4-8 ATS as a road favorite going back to 2011, going 1-4 ATS when laying 10 or more points in that span. In any venue, TCU is on a 31-18 ATS run when favored by at least 14 points, including a 49-0 S/U record as the last outright loss for the Frogs under Gary Patterson as this big of favorite came at SMU early in the 2005 season. Minnesota is 9-5 ATS as a home underdog since 2011 under Kill with the Gophers 6-1 ATS as a double-digit home underdog under Kill, including six straight ATS wins with three outright upset wins.