Not saying what GB did was right. If I was mod and has this exact situation I would just tell each poster no more visiting that persons threads. If you do warnings and bans. I don't care if they are threads from 2003. Take it to the rubber room. That's what it's for. They both have done unjust to each other with Justine posting multiple petition threads and GB not going through with this bet. But it can't keep going on if that is all that was done. Like I said from the start if money was involved everyone would be saying their is a debt to owe, pay it.
The two things aren't comparable IMO.