I'm looking at this 2 different ways, and I'm a little torn. One, from an overall WL record and two from an individual sport record.
My system is generally played to flip, betting him to lose after a win. So overall, I would be fading since he won yesterday. Also, 5-8 this month.
From an individual sport standpoint, in the NBA he should probably be on a fade labby since he's 4-8 in NBA and on an 0-4 streak (on the wrong side, ALL NYK games). BUT, having gone 0-4, one could say he's due a win, since he rarely posts 5L streaks, overall and in any sport.
In the end, I think there's just more arguments for him to lose, than win. I took the Pacers +3.5.