Sherwood's MLB baseball thread picks w/analysis

Search

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,203
Tokens
Yesterday010.00-2.10
Last 30 Days320.00+2.28
Season to Date320.00+2.28

<tbody>
</tbody>

All plays are for 2 units
HOME TEAM IN CAPS

Wednesday, April 2


Seattle +129 over L.A. ANGELS
Seattle has hit three jacks and has scored 18 runs in the first two games and when a team is feeling it like Seattle is, they can’t wait to get back to the park. Now these hot-bats will face a back-of-the rotation starter in Hector Santiago. There were openings in the back-end of the Anaheim rotation and Santiago snuck into one of them. Santiago, who came over from the White Sox via a trade, impressed early in spring training but he ended it with a rough start against the Diamondbacks' Triple-A squad in which he gave up six runs in five-plus innings. Despite the outwardly impressive numbers, there are reasons to beware: His ERA looks good, but he’s been helped by favorable strand percentages the past two years. Santiago’s xERA says this isn’t the skill set of a sub-4.00 pitcher and he walks too many batters (113 BB in 224 career innings). Santiago also gives up a lot of fly balls as evidenced by his 37%/44% groundball/fly-ball split over his career. Going from US Cellular Field (RH HR +38%) to Angel Stadium (RH HR -10%) will help but right now the Mariners have some pop in their bats. Santiago’s fastball velocity is also heading in the wrong direction, as it declined from 93.8 in 2011 to 91.8 in 2013. Lastly and another concern for Santiago is that he had a big IP boost from 2012 to 2013. Even with the move to Anaheim, beware. This is a risky skill set that could hurt your bankroll.

James Paxton went 3-0 with a 1.50 ERA in 24 innings for Seattle as a September call-up. Paxton features a mid-90s heater, a changeup he'll use anytime and a curve as his out pitch. Paxton has maintained a 55% groundball rate throughout his minor-league career and matched that in the aforementioned 24 innings last September. Erosion of command on the way up the ladder is a concern but as 25-year-old ground-baller with three plus pitches, there's just too much upside in him to ignore as a pooch against the Halos. Paxton certainly has value this early in the season and we’re on it.

Minnesota +129 over CHICAGO
2:10 PM EST. Kevin Correia is not going to dazzle anyone and we wouldn’t back him as the chalk with counterfeit money. However, he’s not the chalk here and he’s consistent enough to at least give his offense a chance to go off. Skills don't get more consistent than Correia’s, as there's little variance in yearly xERA or skills. That’s not necessarily a good thing because Correia’s pitch-to-contact approach minimizes his value and his 2010 shows how thin the margin for error is. That said, this one has nothing to do with backing Correia and everything to do with taking back a tag against Felipe Paulino.

Paulino will pitch his first major league game since having Tommy John surgery in July 3 of 2012. As he worked his way back from TJS in the minors last season, Paulino fanned 26 in 27.2 IP, but he walked 15 and allowed 35 hits. The same pattern emerged in spring training, as he struck out 21 in 22.2 IP but walked 10 and gave up a whopping 32 hits, the second most of all AL pitchers. Not having pitched in the majors for a year and a half and struggling to throw strikes and get hitters out in spring training is precisely the type of pitcher we’re happy to take back a price against. The Twinkies are not a very good team but remember that every team in baseball will win 60 games this year and for the Twins, this could certainly be one of the them. Overlay.

MILWAUKEE -1 +112 over Atlanta
1:10 PM EST. With injuries to two of their best starters, Atlanta was forced to bring in some outside help and ended up with Aaron Harang, who signed with Atlanta on March 24. Really? Harang was released by Seattle in August after an absolutely brutal run (5-11, 5.76 in 120 IP), got picked up by the Mets and did some competent work for them in September. Skills were reasonably in line with prior years that delivered better results, but don't get sucked in. "Competent" is the upside; "bankroll-killer" is the downside. This is Harang’s sixth team in the past 12 months, not years. He has a job only because of an inordinate amount of injuries to starting pitchers throughout the majors. Of the 107 pitchers in the majors to work at least 140 innings last season, Harang had the third worst ERA in that group and the worse xERA and that was pitching the majority of those innings at the AL’s friendliest pitcher’s park. Aaron Harang is a pure stiff that has maybe four starts left in his career.

The Brewers have not gone off yet with just four runs in their first two games but that was facing a couple of very good looking Braves' starters. Things get much easier here for Milwaukee’s offense and we also love that Matt Garza makes his first start in his new digs because the fans will be extra jacked up in support of this significant signing. Early in his career, Garza’s poor skill foundation held him back. The last three seasons his skills have blossomed. A stress fracture in his elbow shortened his 2012 and 2013 seasons but his arm looked stronger as the season went along in 2013. His four-seam fastball velocity jumped from 92.8 in the 1H to 93.4 mph in the 2H and his swinging K% leaped from 9% to 11% over the same period. He finally got a better feel for his changeup, as he had a career-high 13% swinging K% with that pitch. If his elbow holds up, Garza could finally post a long-awaited breakout this season. He also figures to get plenty of run support here.

BALTIMORE +103 over Boston
Not convinced that the Red Sox should be favored here. John Lackey shed extra pounds and distractions in driven return from TJS, coaxing his strongest skills in years. Ks and groundballs were plentiful in the first half and 69%/0% dominant start/disaster start split brought him home in the 2H. With a clean arm and a clear head, Lackey stands a fair chance of repeating but we’re not buyers this early. Lackey had a rough spring with a 6.27 ERA over 24 innings. He’s been a very slow starter in April over the past three years with an ERA of 4.85 and that includes two starts at this park in which he had a BAA of .296 to go along with an ERA of 4.77. The Orioles have a legit shot of being the highest scoring team in baseball and it sure doesn’t hurt that current O’s have a solid .276 BA against Lackey in 254 career AB’s.

On Aug 22 of last season Ubaldo Jimenez was 9-7 with a 4.00 ERA. He then knocked out eight straight pure quality starts with a 71/10 K/BB ratio, insisting he did so by finally reconciling his velocity drop and adopting a new pitch mix. Jimenez clearly made some adjustments mid-way through 2013. Yes, strand % and hr/f helped his ERA in the second half but this was clearly a different pitcher, with a big improvement in control and a sustained high strikeout rate. Jimenez claims to have made adjustments to account for his diminished velocity (96 mph fastball as recently as 2010; 92 mph the past two years). The pitch breakdown backs him up; he used his fastball a lot less, with a lot more sliders and split fingered fastballs in 2014. While his W-L record and ERA have been all over the map, xERA says that other than 2012, he’s been a pretty consistent pitcher. The Orioles are no joke and anytime we can take a tag back with them at home when the opposition’s pitcher isn’t a dominant one, we’re almost always going to accept it. No exception here.
 

New member
Joined
Apr 23, 2009
Messages
2,582
Tokens
Hi Sherwood,

Why not go with Cleveland if you had them yesterday and postponed to today with same pitchers?

thanks
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,203
Tokens
Hi Sherwood,

Why not go with Cleveland if you had them yesterday and postponed to today with same pitchers?

thanks

When teams play a DH, they use two different lineups and sometimes you don't get the best lineup available. Also, DH's often end up in a split so if I don't play the dogs in both games, I generally lay off.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
12,044
Tokens
Hey sherwood good luck as always and that you mention about the red Sox being favored in this situation has me taking Boston. It's not that is the only reason as I look for them to get to Jimenez in this game. But I had to mention that it's the don't make sense theory and also my belief
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,203
Tokens
The don't make sense theory is not a bad angle at all key. Best of luck in every other game you play today.
 

Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2006
Messages
148
Tokens
If Trevor Plouffe could throw a ball 70 ft my twins would have been a win. That guy drives me nuts!
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,203
Tokens
If Trevor Plouffe could throw a ball 70 ft my twins would have been a win. That guy drives me nuts!

Yeah, that was rough indeed. 2-run lead in the ninth for Twins and Brewers throw a 2-hitter and lose. Still, Twins had so many chances to score more and could have been up 5 in the ninth instead of 2. Back to the drawing board.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,203
Tokens
Yesterday130.00-3.42
Last 30 Days450.00-1.14
Season to Date450.00-1.14

<tbody>
</tbody>

Thursday, April 3

Colorado -110 over MIAMI
12:40 PM EST. Jacob Turner can be labeled as a failed prospect at this point in his career but there are reasons to keep him on your radar. He gained nearly one mph on his four-seam fastball in 2013. He missed a lot of bats in 2012. Nearly all of Turner’s problems come against LH bats and there are some notable lefties in the Rockies lineup like Justin Morneau and Carlos Gonzales among them. Turner went 3-8 with a 3.74 ERA in 118 IP for the Marlins last year. He looked like he was taking a step up but he hit a wall in 2H, losing fastball velocity and command. Turner’s low K rate versus LHB (29 K in 239 plate appearances) is still a lingering issue. Turner is still very young (23) and has a 1st-round pedigree but nothing here says 2014 is the year.

Franklin Morales is an interesting case. He posted his best skills in 2012 but a late-season shoulder injury bled into 2013, leaving additional health issues in its wake (back, chest, shoulder again). His last six weeks were very impressive last year but it was a tiny sample. Morales’ gaudy numbers in spring training could be a sign of things to come. Looking strong after missing close to 150 games to injury in 2012-2013, Morales fanned 28 in his 25.2 spring innings, limiting batters to a .194 BA. Manager Walt Weiss made special notice of Morales controlling the tempo with which he worked and gaining control of his cut fastball, particularly against RHB. The good news here is that the Marlins will send up mostly right-handed hitters to the plate. With a career record of 13-18 to go along with a 4.38 ERA, Morales is an under the radar starter that could bring nice profits early on. We’ll test that here (risking 2.2 units to win 2).

TAMPA BAY -1 -107 over Toronto
The Rays’ bats have gone silent the past couple of games after a strong showing in the opener but they figure to wake up again here against Brandon Morrow. An entrapped radial nerve in Morrow’s right forearm cut loose two-thirds of his season and put an end to 2013's misery. Trouble with strand rate has haunted most of his recent seasons and now a steep K rate dive and injury questions are piling on. Seems he's ready for the season in terms of heath but his skills are in a serious three-year decline. In 2010 and 2011, Morrow put up an xERA around 3.50 and a strong strikeout rate of 10 K’s per nine innings. Those days are long gone, as his injury shortened 2013 ended with just 6½ K’s per nine and a low 9% swinging strike rate. Morrow is a fly-ball pitcher (+40%) who is missing fewer bats and even when he was food, he lacked mental toughness. Now that’s he’s more fragile than ever, the Rays figure to be the first team to take advantage of Morrow this season.

Chris Archer went 9-7 with a 3.22 ERA in 129 innings last season. Archer is another thoroughbred from the Tampa pitching stable. He showed his youth when he struggled with control in first half last year but got it together after the break. His command improvement gets our attention and so does the fact that he’s mastering his changeup, a solid third pitch behind his mid-90s fastball and good slider. With groundball percentage bent and dominance vs RHB, Archer is one to invest in. (risking 2.14 units to win 2).
 

New member
Joined
Oct 26, 2009
Messages
897
Tokens
With you on the Rockies! A little more urgency in this spot for them to tie this series. Hope the bats woke up yesterday.
 

Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2006
Messages
148
Tokens
Just snake bitten lately. Lead all game and give it away in the 8th and 9th innings!
 

New member
Joined
Nov 7, 2009
Messages
2,439
Tokens
tailed on rockies sucked they blew it at the end but really marlins had a lot of opportunities throughout the game thought colorado would hang on but in the end didn't deserve to win either on to the next game thanks again for the work sherwood you done with the hockey plays we've missed you over there
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,203
Tokens
Thanks, it's a long season and they'll be games where I pull it out in the eighth and ninth. Luck evens out over time and I feel like I have a pretty good read on these pitchers. My only regret was not having Cubs today. I actually wrote them up at +163 and when he line dropped o +151, I passed. That won't happen again.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,203
Tokens
Yesterday110.00-0.20
Last 30 Days560.00-1.34
Season to Date560.00-1.34

<tbody>
</tbody>

All plays are for 2 units.
HOME TEAM IN CAPS


Arizona +121 over COLORADO
We’re all about value and there is no value whatsoever in playing a lot of these #4 and #5 starters in the rotation when spotting a price. Juan Nicasio of the Rockies is among that group. In 55 career starts, Nicasio has 15 wins. He has a career ERA of 4.92 with a WHIP of 1.45. Nicasio finally put together a full season a year ago but the results were less than expected. His strikeouts were down, especially in the first half and his command never reached an acceptable mark. Nicasio’s groundball/fly-ball split last year of 45%/34%, an unfortunate 66% strand rate and a K increase in the second half provide some hope but that’s been his story forever. At age 27 and without any great stretches in his career, Nocasio is just hanging onto his job and is not worth reaching for as a favorite.

The Diamondbacks are struggling with just one win in six starts but they faced some tough pitching in Australia and they’ve scored five runs or more in four of those six games. After playing San Fran and Los Angeles, the D-Backs take a step down in class when facing this Rockies team that lost three of four in Miami to open the year. Randall Delgado is another one of those #4 or #5 starters in the rotation but he’s not the one spotting a tag here and he does have better career numbers than Nicasio in terms of WHIP and ERA. Delgado is just 24 years old. There were mixed results for this former top prospect after his June call-up last year. He traded in Ks for more control but the net gain was minimal, although he did show some flashes. We also like that the Delgado has had some modest success against current Rockies with just eight hits allowed in 37 AB’s for a BAA of .216. Current D-Backs have a .310 BA against Nicasio in 58 career AB’s. Lastly, the Rockies bullpen has been atrocious (giving up 21 hits in 60 AB for an OBP of .426) and that was in four games at pitcher-friendly Marlins Park. Once the starters are out of this game and it’s tied, close or the D-Backs have the lead, our chances of winning increase even more. In the end, the Rockies-Nicasio-Rockies pen combo is one that does not warrant this price and we’re on it.

Philadelphia +133 over CHICAGO
Not interested in the Cubs spotting a tag like this against anyone, especially when the pitching matchup doesn’t favor them by a wide margin. In this case, we’re not even sure the pitching matchup favors the Cubs. Roberto Hernandez got a new name last year and some new skills. Hernandez posted his best strikeout rate since his Fausto days and the best command of his career. He perhaps deserved better, as he completely outpitched his 4.89 ERA with a very respectable xERA of 3.53. Blame it on his horrific hr/f but with his solid groundball/fly-ball ratio of 53%/24%, he's worth a bit of speculation.

Travis Wood was a pleasant surprise in 2013. Seemingly out of nowhere, he posted career-bests in ERA, WHIP, and Ks. However, a quick glance at Wood's skills indicates the success will likely be short-lived. Wood's breakout was fueled by luck more than anything else. A trifecta of fortunate hit%, strand%, and hr/f converged all at once. Don't expect that to happen again. There really wasn't any growth under the hood. Wood’s K rate and other skills remained below league average and were both slightly down from his 2012 numbers. An xERA of 4.45 each of the last two years sets a much better expectation than 2013's ERA. Wood's ERA trend looks enticing on the surface but his skill set simply doesn't support this level of production over the long haul. A repeat of last season not only looks like a long shot but it also has Wood very overvalued.

Chicago +138 over KANSAS CITY
When Jeremy Guthrie arrived in Kansas City in the middle of the 2012 season, it was probably a relief to leave behind the hitter’s parks of Coors Field and Camden Yards. He did well in the second half of 2012 and had 15 wins for the Royals in 2013. Guthrie may never see that success again. He doesn’t strike out many batters, even with good control, his command is lackluster. While Guthrie’s ERA approached 4.00 last year, xERA shows that he’s fundamentally the same pitcher he’s been for years. Expect some ERA regression in 2014. His general lack of dominance can be seen in his below average dominant start/disaster start split. You can see from Guthrie’s ERA and hit% history that only good fortune can nudge his ERA under 4.00. There are two things Guthrie excels at, eating innings and generating work for defenders behind him so when he inevitably blows up, don’t be the one caught laying a big price with him.

Erik Johnson has some solid upside. Problem is, he's got less than 150 IP in the high minors so there is some risk involved, but at this price against Guthrie, the South Side with Johnson going has some value. Johnson, 23, put up exceptional numbers in just his second full season and was rewarded with a September call-up. Johnson only allowed more than two earned runs in one of his 24 starts last season, coupled with a 131/40 K/BB ratio over 142 minor league innings. He is a physical pitcher (6'3, 235) with a power build, aggressive demeanor and approach on the mound. Johnson has shown improvement in both his repertoire and pitch sequencing and attacks hitters with a heavy 90-96 mph fastball, solid slider, curveball, and an improving change-up. He pounds the lower half of the zone, inducing lots of groundballs and his slider has become a reliable swing-and-miss out-pitch. Johnson got a little taste of the big leagues last year and that also is a positive. He does not project as a #1 or #2 starter but a very dependable #3 or #4 who can provide lots of innings with a good number of strikeouts and a solid ERA. That said, when a tag like this is offered against Guthrie, you can pencil us in almost every time and we certainly make no exception here.

OAKLAND -1 +101 over Seattle
It’s not customary for us to be spotting runs in this pitcher friendly park but this one warrants it. While Chris Young may be healthy now, this is a man who hasn't pitched since 2012 when he threw 115 innings that season. Prior to that, Young threw 24 innings and 20 innings in '11 and '10 respectively. If there was a health grade lower than F, Young would own it. What's more, and this is no misprint, Young has NEVER posted an xERA under 4.25 for any season in his career. Take that under advisement and stay as far away from this guy as possible.

Dan Straily may seem like a starting pitcher with a limited ceiling given his mediocre 3.96 ERA last season but there are more reasons for optimism if you give him a closer look. Straily’s high strikeout rates he posted in the minors is no mirage. He owns an elite 11.1% swinging strike rate at this level and he is dominant against RH bats. His command evaporates against lefties but he worked on that in the off-season along with a few other minor tweaks. Truth is, Straily has a filthy slider with a top-tier swinging strike rate. His prior profile as minors K leader suggests more strikeouts are coming. At age 24 and with his strikeout potential, Straily has 2014 breakout potential worth speculating on.

Milwaukee +138 over BOSTON
2:05 PM EST. Jake Peavy will continue to be overpriced because of his pedigree over the years and because of the team he pitches for. Problem is, Peavy’s skills faded badly down the stretch and have now been on a significant decline in three of his past four seasons. Peavy’s fly-ball rate over the last three years was 39%, 42% and an alarming 47% last year. As a fly-ball pitcher with poor durability and with close to 2000 career innings, Peavy's risk is starting to outweigh his reward and we’ll look to take advantage of that here.

A hamstring injury cost Marco Estrada a third of the season in 2013. When he returned he had a dominant second half. Estrada’s 2013 mirrored his superb second half in 2012, so he's showed plus-plus ability twice. Estrada is still flying under the radar, given that he has not topped 140 IP in a season during his career. That said, he was one of just 11 starters who have posted a 110+ base performance value during each of the last two seasons. This past spring, Estrada went 4-0 in six starts. He posted an ERA of 2.12 and walked just two hitters in 25 innings. Throwing in a hitter's park led to Estrada’s ERA-damaging HR in the first half of last year but his skills command our full attention. He’s on the cusp of the next level and is certainly worth a wager while still under the radar.
 

Joe Public
Joined
Aug 13, 2008
Messages
417
Tokens
thanks sherwood!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,119,929
Messages
13,575,374
Members
100,883
Latest member
iniesta2025
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com