Bracketology Update
By Bruce Marshall
We're now at the midway point of the college basketball season. And while conference schedules are still in their early phases, we can already detect more definition in the college hoops landscape for 2014-15, as postseason berths begin to take shape.
Thus, we begin to value our "Bracketology" updates a bit more as we can begin to more accurately project where many of these teams will slot on Selection Sunday. And, at midseason, it's a good measuring stick for the first half of the campaign and an indicator where many of these teams will end up in March.
For our newest update, we include not only each team's record, but also its "RPI" (Ratings Percentage index) number, a calculation that begins to become more illuminating as we get deeper into conference action. All records and RPI are thru January 14.
As usual, for all of our "Bracketology" updates, the term "protected seed" refers to seeds 1 thru 4 in each region, and usual favorable geographic placement in the sub-regional round. As usual, we break down the projected matchups by each region, beginning with the sub-regionals, which this season will begin on Thursday, March 19, with the Dayton "First Four" games played on March 17 and 18. Remember, Selection Sunday is less than two months away!
EAST REGIONAL (Syracuse)
At Charlotte...
1 Virginia (SUR 16-0, RPI-3) vs. 16 Stony Brook (11-7, 82)...With Duke faltering within the past week, Virginia more and more looks like the class of the ACC. And as long as the Cavaliers stay undefeated, they definitely stay on top of one of the regions. The America East race sees the Great Danes from Albany setting the early pace, though most believe the home team of Strat-o-Matic on Long Island, Stony Brook, will end up as the conference rep.
8 Stanford (12-4, 38) vs. 9 George Washington (12-4, 39)...As the Pac-12 race begins to take shape, Stanford looks like an upper-division squad and has thus far avoided some of the damaging slips that have already cost other loop foes in the past couple of weeks. The pre-league win at Texas isn't looking as good as it did a few weeks ago, but solid RPI and SOS (Strength of Schedule) numbers suggest Johnny Dawkins and the Cardinal land on the safe side of the cut line. So, too, should Mike Lonergan's GW, although the A-10 race is looking more competitive than originally envisioned. How deep might the Selection Committee go in the conference come March?
At Seattle...
4 Utah (13-2, 7) vs. 13 Harvard (10-4, 41)...Larry Krystowiak's Utah is now setting the pace in the Pac-12 and indicated long ago that it means business this season. A weekend date at Arizona will be the next test for the Utes. We're a little less sure that Harvard is the class of the Ivy league than the past couple of seasons, when Tommy Amaker's side won a couple of sub-regional games and was probably good enough to merit an at-large berth if needed. But enough familiar names (such as Wesley Saunders and Siyani Chambers) remain from those recent Big Dance additions to make Harvard the Ivy favorite again.
5 Virginia Commonwealth (14-3, 4) vs. 12 Georgia (10-5, 40)/Oklahoma State (12-4/27)...VCU's impressive RPI number suggests the Rams have a shot at a protected seed. Whatever, it would appear as if the Rams and Dayton are probably going to be the highest-seeded A-10 teams called on Selection Sunday. Speaking of Dayton, as usual it will host the at-large play-in games at our favorite mid-sized arena in the country. We are not sure how the Committee is going to view the SEC, but we suspect it might go a bit deeper than many suspect, and Georgia's midweek win at Vandy was an important step for Mark Fox's Bulldogs to move into the top half of the league. We know the Committee is going to like the Big 12, where Ok State resides, though we wonder if so much depth in the league will result in some cannibalization. For now, the Cowboys' RPI suggests they make the cut, but things change quickly (ask TCU).
At Omaha...
2 Wisconsin (15-2, 8) vs. 15 Hofstra (13-5, 147)...Wisconsin might have been in position to move up into a projected number one seed had it not been minus C Frank Kaminsky and lost at Rutgers last Sunday. Which qualifies as a "bad" loss and probably keeps the Badgers on the 2-line for the time being. (The good news is that Kaminsky's concussion-related absence is expected to be short, though G Traveon Jackson will miss several weeks due to foot surgery). The CAA race looks completely up for grabs, especially with preseason favorite William & Mary (looking for its first-ever Big Dance berth) having slightly disappointed. At the moment, respected former Niagara HC Joe Mihalich has the Hofstra Pride on top of the league table.
7 Seton Hall (13-4, 18) vs. 10 Arkansas (13-3, 16)...The Hall had better not get too comfy with its projected spot in the field, as the Pirates still have the bulk of a treacherous Big East schedule to navigate. The Tuesday home loss at the Pru Center to Butler suggests that Kevin Willard's crew faces several bumps in the road still to come. Arkansas might project higher than a 10 seed, but not sure how the Committee is going to rate the SEC beyond Kentucky. The Razorbacks did their seeding prospects no favors with Tuesday night's loss at Tennessee.
At Pittsburgh...
3 Notre Dame (16-2, 47) vs. 14 Iona (12-5, 62)...Our projections at the moment have the Selection Committee going 8-deep in the ACC, with plenty of room for Notre Dame. Though the Irish lost last weekend, that home setback vs. undefeated Virginia is definitely a "good" loss, and bouncing back to score a come-from-behind win at Georgia Tech is more than enough to keep Mike Brey's Fighting Irish in protected seed territory. Meanwhile, beyond 12-5 Iona, only two teams, Quinnipiac and Rider, are even above .500 in the Metro-Atlantic, and just barely so for the latter two. The Gaels have already moved to the top of the MAAC and are rather clearly the team to beat in the loop.
6 Oklahoma (11-5, 28) vs. 11 Providence (13-5, 13)...At this time last week we probably would have had Oklahoma as a protected seed, especially after the Jan. 5 romp at Texas. But subsequent losses to Kansas State and West Virginia have Lon Kruger's Sooners sinking fast. Providence is one of several teams in the Big East scrum beneath Villanova, though it looks like RPI numbers are favorable to loop members this term, and the Friars could be one of those beneficiaries. An early win over Notre Dame is helping Providence's at-large prospects.
SOUTH REGIONAL (Houston)
At Louisville...
1 Kentucky (16-0, 2) vs. 16 Colgate (7-11, 246)/Alabama State (8-5/221)...The nuances of the RPI are too complicated to explain, but we're not sure F. Lee Bailey could defend that rating system putting Kentucky beneath a Kansas team that the Wildcats beat by 32 points earlier this season. Though Coach Cal's Cats have had a couple of recent narrow overtime escapes vs. Ole Miss and Texas A&M, we'd be shocked if UK isn't the overall number one seed in the tourney. And more shocked if UK isn't placed in Louisville for the sub-regional. We're not sure what is going to happen in the Patriot League, but surprising Colgate is setting the early pace and gets the provisional spot in the field for the moment. Strong challenges are expected to come from Lafayette and American U, but the Red Raiders might think they have their best shot at the Dance since the days of Adonal Foyle. Alabama State has started quickly in the SWAC and at 8-5 overall is the only league member close to .500 at all.
8 San Diego State (13-4, 37) vs. 9 Miami-Florida (12-4, 56)...We think there is a chance that the Mountain West could end up as a one-bid league, though two or three are probably more likely. One of those is likely to be SDSU, which is not having an easy of a ride as it has the past few seasons, but did make an important stand Wednesday at Wyoming when beating the Cowboys in a 60-52 grinder. Miami was also floundering in recent weeks but seems to have straightened out, with Tuesday's romp at Duke re-positioning Jim Larranaga's Canes back into the field.
At Columbus...
4 West Virginia (15-2, 15) vs. 13 ULL (10-5, 172)...Bob Huggins' Mountaineers might deserve a better seed than a four, especially after the midweek romp past Oklahoma in Morgantown. Whatever, WVU sure looks like a protected seed after an impressive first two months of the season. In the Sun Belt, UL-Lafayette has taken early control of the race by virtue of last week's narrow win over Georgia State. Don't be surprised if those two end up in the Belt tourney final as a year ago, when the Ragin' Cajuns scored a mild upset in overtime. We'd also keep an eye on Georgia Southern, one of the early surprises in the Belt.
5 Michigan State (12-5, 35) vs. 12 Green Bay (14-3, 65)...We've been waiting for Michigan State to shift gears and think it has finally happened with three straight wins by Tom Izzo's Spartans, including impressive recent jobs vs. Indiana and at Iowa. With the arrow pointing up in East Lansing, MSU is probably not far from protected seed territory, though a sub-regional in Columbus is probably what Izzo would prefer regardless. Brian Wardle's Green Bay is setting the pace in the Horizon League, though Bryce Drew's Valparaiso and Gary Waters' Cleveland State are giving spirited chase.
At Jacksonville...
2 Maryland (16-2, 19) vs. 15 Coastal Carolina (14-3, 110)...So far, Maryland's transition from the ACC to the Big Ten has been rather smooth, with the Terps on top of the loop heading into Thursday night action. Expect to see Mark Turgeon's troops in protected seed territory all of the way to Selection Sunday. In the Big South, Coastal Carolina looks ready for a return to the Dance. Nobody will be overlooking the Chants, either, after they gave number one seed Virginia a scare last March. Coach Cliff Ellis has also previously taken three other schools (South Alabama, Clemson, and Auburn) to the Dance.
7 SMU (13-4, 23) vs. 10 Washington (12-4, 61)...After likely being the final school out of last year's field of 68, don't expect Larry Brown's SMU to have to sweat out Selection Sunday this March. Meanwhile, Washington is now struggling to remain in the field after a recent 4-game losing streak, including an 0-3 break from the gate in the Pac-12. But Thursday's 56-43 win over recently-surging Oregon State suggests the slump might be in the rear-view mirror and barely gets Lorenzo Romar's team back into the field.
At Omaha...
3 Wichita State (15-2, 9) vs. 14 Wofford (13-4, 33)...Wichita State is not basing its Big Dance candidacy upon its subpar pointspread record, which would qualify for a CBI or CIT invitation at bast. But the Shockers continue to win and set the pace in the Valley. Right now, they're an easy call for a protected seed. With Davidson having moved out of the SoCon, Wofford is now the flagship program in the loop, and vet HC Mike Young looks to have another Big Dance rep, with star G Karl Cochran likely pacing a return visit to the Dance.
6 Butler (13-5, 14) vs. 11 Old Dominion (13-2, 22)...If this were a sub-regional matchup, it would be a rematch of a very good battle at a similar stage four years ago won by one of Butler's title game qualifiers. The Bulldogs, one of many contenders in the mosh-pit known as the Big East, helped their candidacy greatly in last Tuesday's overtime win at Seton Hall. The question in Conference USA is if it might be a multi-bid league once again this season. Jeff Jones' ODU looks to be the best of the bunch, though La Tech, UTEP, or Western Kentucky will have a shot to knock off the Monarchs in the conference tourney.
MIDWEST REGIONAL (Cleveland)
At Pittsburgh...
1 Villanova (16-1, 5) vs. 16 St. Francis, Pa. (9-6, 103)/NC Central (12-5, 101)...Developments over the past week, when Duke lost twice and Wisconsin lost at Rutgers, have helped Villanova project to the top line. With the RPI loving the Big East this season, the Cats should be looking at a favorable seed and likely the Pittsburgh sub-regional in March. Another of the 16 vs. 16 play-in games could feature the Northeast Conference, where Maurice Stokes' alma mater St. Francis (Pa.) is setting the early pace in the league race and was one of the few NEC teams above .500 in pre-league play. As always, be aware of the home team of the Pittsburgh Airport, Robert Morris, as well as Clair Bee's former Long Island U. Blackbirds. The MEAC is often involved in 16 vs. 16 play-in games, too, and NC Central has taken the lead in the league race as it looks for back-to-back trips to the Dance.
8 LSU (13-3, 46) vs. 9 Indiana (13-4, 50)...There are some Big Ten observers who believe Indiana HC Tom Crean needs this Big Dance bid to keep himself out of hot water in Bloomington. Last Saturday's win over Ohio State suggests the Hoosiers have a good shot of hanging around through the rugged Big Ten slate...and keeping Crean out of trouble. The SEC-after-Kentucky race might have a new frontrunner after LSU's impressive Wednesday win at Ole Miss. If the Tigers can win a few more on the conference trail, they could end up as the second-highest seeded team in the league.
At Portland....
4 Baylor (13-3, 25) vs. 13 Stephen F Austin (13-3, 115)...The Big 12 is so top-heavy that we believe the league could cannibalize itself, though in the end it might not cost the loop more than one Big Dance bid. Baylor, by virtue of its midweek escape at Waco vs. Iowa State, claims a protected seed in this projection (though we're still sending the Bears out to Portland). SF Austin and HC Brad Underwood need no introduction after causing havoc in last March's sub-regionals in San Diego, where the Lumberjacks upset VCU. In the meantime, they'll have to worry about Sam Houston State in what is looking like a two-team race in the Southland.
5 Ohio State (14-4, 51) vs. 12 Central Michigan (12-2, 124)...Ohio State took advantage of a soft pre-league slate and has not exactly been rolling in Big Ten play, hence the unimpressive RPI number and its slotting outside of protected seed territory. The Buckeyes do have one of the nation's top frosh, however, in G D'Angelo Russell. The MAC race is shaping up to be highly-entertaining, though as usual we don't project more than one bid from the loop. At the moment, we vote for Keno Davis' CMU, while also keeping an eye on Buffalo, Ball State, Western Michigan, Akron, and Toledo (heck, that's almost half of the league...we told you it's going to be an entertaining race!).
At Charlotte...
2 Duke (14-2, 10) vs. 15 FGCU (11-7, 148)...The storyline of the past week in college hoops was Duke's ungraceful drop from the ranks of the unbeatens, losing not just once, but twice (NC State and Miami), and looking bad in the process. That's dropped the Blue Devils off of the top line, but we're keeping them in the nearby Charlotte sub-regional...for now. Though the Ospreys of North Florida currently lead the Atlantic Sun race, FGCU and the remnants of its "Dunk City" from two years ago are still considered the team to beat in the race. Note that recent antagonist Mercer has moved to the SoCon.
7 Georgetown (11-5, 30) vs. 10 Wyoming (15-3, 76)...As mentioned earlier, the RPI is giving a lot of respect to the Big East, and the Selection Committee has never needed its arm twisted to reward teams from that loop. Georgetown still has plenty of work to do, but Tuesday's win at DePaul suggests the Hoyas should be up to the task. We're not as sure about Wyo, which saw its home win streak snapped at 13 by San Diego State on Wednesday night. The Cowboys need to prove they can win on the road in order to stay in the projected field, though to their benefit, the MW doesn't look too deep this season.
At Louisville...
3 Kansas (14-2, 1) vs. 14 Murray State (13-4, 100)...The Jayhawks' psyche took a couple of haymakers before New Year's in blowout losses vs. Kentucky and at Temple. But so far, those are the only KU losses, and the RPI obviously loves the Jayhawks, who could certainly threaten the top line by the time we get to Selection Sunday. Murray State appears the team to beat in the OVC, but Eastern Kentucky (last year's OVC Big Dance rep) and Eastern Illinois are currently making noise along with the Racers in the league race.
6 Northern Iowa (15-2, 21) vs. 11 Iowa (12-5, 52)...The Missouri Valley looks likely to be a multi-bid league once more because of UNI, with all five starters back from last season. The Panthers' credentials are good enough to make the Valley a 3-bid league in March if both Wichita and UNI should happen to lose in "Arch Madness" at St. Louis. And wouldn't this be a tasty sub-regional matchup vs. the in-state Hawkeyes, who went flat in the second half and lost by 12 to UNI on Dec. 20 in Des Moines.
WEST REGIONAL (Los Angeles)
at Seattle...
1 Gonzaga (16-1, 6) vs. 16 New Mexico State (9-9. 168)...After recent losses by Arizona, the Zags now project to the top spot in the West Regional and are a good bet to stay there as they figure, as usual, to cruise through the WCC (Arizona is already having problems in the deeper Pac-12). Expect to see Marvin Menzies' NMSU back in the Dance, as the Aggies are now beyond a tough pre-league slate and should be able to cruise through the WAC portion of their schedule.
8 Dayton (14-2, 17) vs. 9 Colorado State (16-2, 20)...Archie Miller's Dayton Flyers are proving that their run to the Elite Eight a year ago was no fluke, as they set the pace in A-10 alongside VCU. As for transfer-laden CSU, it has regained its balance after recovering from body blows inflicted by New Mexico and Wyoming at the outset of the league race. The Rams are back in stride if Wednesday's 98-42 crush job of Nevada is any indication.
At Jacksonville...
4 North Carolina (13-4, 12) vs. 13 Eastern Washington (12-4, 66)...The Tar Heels have hit a few bumps but are sitting in very nice shape with the RPI and should land in protected seed territory (though we have shipped the Heels to the sub-regional in Jacksonville instead of Charlotte). The recent win over Louisville sets up UNC nicely at the midseason point. If the matchup is to be Big Sky rep EWU, rest assured Roy Williams (or any opposing coach) will warn his troops of the Eagles, who won at Indiana in November.
5 Iowa State (12-3, 24) vs. 12 Cincinnati (11-4,31)/NC State (12-6/34)...We project the Committee going 8-deep in the Big 12, though we are not sure how those teams might be seeded, and how much damage they might do to one another in league play. Iowa State should fall safely on the right side of the cut line, and for now we keep Fred Hoiberg's Cyclones at a five seed. The other at-large play-in game at Dayton currently projects to a couple of traditional March faces, and one familiar at the "First Four" after winning at UD Arena a year ago. That would be NC State, which helped its at-large credentials with last Sunday's rousing win over Duke. We also have Cincinnati penciled here (which would be convenient for the Bearcats, with Dayton not far away). We'll see how Cincy reacts with HC Mick Cronin acting only in an advisory capacity for the remainder of this season due to health issues.
At Columbus...
2 Louisville (15-2, 26) vs. 15 North Dakota State (11-6, 157)...Keep in mind that Louisville is not eligible for the sub-regional at its KFC Yum! Center in the 'Ville, so the Cards likely are off to a place like Columbus, not too far away, for their sub-regional. The Cards have made the ACC an even tougher neighborhood this season, though we do expect Rick Pitino's team to slip on some banana peels in the league race (which the 'Ville already did, narrowly, at North Carolina). The Summit race looks wide open, and a measured vote for last year's champ North Dakota State, though South Dakota State and Oral Roberts (back in the Summit after a brief stay in the Southland) figure to chase the Bison into March.
7 St. John's (12-4, 43) vs. 10 Davidson (12-3, 53)...After an 0-3 break from the gate in Big East play, we were wondering if we should drop Steve Lavin's St. John's out of the field entirely. But Wednesday's win at Providence might steady the Red Storm, who still project to the safe side of the cut line. As for Bob "Leslie Nielsen" McKillop's Davidson, it seems to be transitioning easily from the SoCon to the A-10, owning one of the nation's most potent offenses.
At Portland....
3 Arizona (14-2, 11) vs. 14 UC Davis (12-3, 117)...Arizona's recent stumbles at UNLV and Oregon State suggest there could be more slippery spots to come for the Cats with the bulk of the Pac-12 road schedule still to come. Although we do not project UA to slide out of protected seed territory. As for Kimberly Guilfoyle's alma mater UC Davis, it assumed frontrunner status in the Big West with last Saturday's overtime win over Long Beach State. Star G Corey Hawkins looks like he could be the difference-maker in the league, though don't forget how a sub-.500 Cal Poly side (still lurking) won the conference tourney at Anaheim last March. The Aggies are looking for their first-ever Big Dance invitation.
6 Texas (12-4, 32) vs. 11 Alabama (12-4, 44)...There probably wasn't a team drop as much in the past week as Texas, which was looking at a 2 or 3 seed prior to a Jan. 5 blowout loss to Oklahoma, and a subsequent loss on Saturday vs. Oklahoma State. With plenty of tough dates to come in the Big 12, the Horns could drop further. As for Bama, it might need a Big Dance bid to keep the heat off of HC Anthony Grant. The Tide had a 6-game win streak stopped on Tuesday at South Carolina, but Bama appears as good a candidate as any to emerge as the second team in the SEC behind Kentucky.
Last four in: Georgia, Oklahoma State, Cincinnati, NC State
Last four out: Illinois, TCU, BYU, Penn State
Next four out: Temple, Florida, Tulsa, Saint Mary's