Barring scratches, Kentucky Derby winner Nyquist will break from post 3, the post used by both Secretariat and California Chrome to win the Preakness. Since 1963, horses breaking from post 3 have won nine times, tied with post 6 for most wins. On the other hand, post 1 (drawn by Cherry Wine) has a record of just 52-2-6-9 in the same time period, the two winners being Tabasco Cat in 1994 and American Pharoah last year.
The Derby winner
Nyquist enters the Preakness following a win in the Kentucky Derby two weeks prior, and recent history has been favorable to the Derby winner. Since 1963, the Derby winner has won the Preakness 21 times in 50 attempts (three Derby winners did not compete in the Preakness). That’s a record of 50-21-10-6, and it’s even stronger in the past 20 years as they have a record of 19-10-4-1 since 1996, when Grindstone was retired just days after his Derby win.
The Derby runner-up
Exaggerator is looking to turn the tables on Nyquist, having already lost to him four times in his career, most recently when he ran second to him in the Derby. Since 1963, 39 times the second-place finisher in the Derby ran again in the Preakness, and in all but two of those times faced the Derby winner again. In 18 of those 37 races, the Derby winner repeated, and eight times they replicated the Derby order of finish. Only three times did the Derby runner-up win the Preakness, Forward Pass in 1968 (who was later awarded the winner’s share of the purse in the Derby), Summer Squall in 1990, and Prairie Bayou in 1993. In that time, the Derby runner-up has compiled a Preakness record of 39-3-12-8.
http://www.drf.com/news/preakness-2016-inside-numbers