Obama Condemns Bill His Own Advisors Wrote

Search

Banned
Joined
Nov 9, 2005
Messages
3,981
Tokens
The FACT is that the vote that you point to was a vote on a CONFERENCE REPORT, not the actual bill. The vote I referenced was a vote on the ACTUAL BILL. The ACTUAL BILL passed on May 6 by a 55-44 vote along party lines. The Nov. 4 action was not a vote on the bill, but rather was a vote on a conference report.

<TABLE><TBODY><TR><TD>Vote Number:</TD><TD>Senate Vote #354 in 1999 [primary source]</TD></TR><TR><TD>Date:</TD><TD>Nov 4, 1999 3:30PM</TD></TR><TR><TD>Result: </TD><TD>Conference Report Agreed to</TD></TR><TR><TD>Related Bill:</TD><TD>S. 900 [106th]: Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
I don't expect you to recognize facts. I expect you to keep spinning. So now go prove me right...
Regarding Gramm-Leach-Bliley, McCain did vote FOR the original version when it first came up for a vote in the Senate (Senate vote #105, May 6). But then the bill went into conference committee, and some changes were made. During this period, there was intense lobbying, both pro and con, and much pressure in favor of the bill from the Clinton administration.
When the amended legislation returned to the Senate from conference committee for the final vote, McCain now refused to vote for it (Senate vote #354, Nov. 4).
Biden did the reverse switch. He did vote against the legislation in its original form (May 6). But the massive lobbying effort in favor of the bill between May and November influenced Biden. Also, the Clinton Administration pushed him strongly to vote Aye. Robert Rubin, Clinton's Secretary of the Treasury, canvassed the legislators and 'explained' why this 'reform' was absolutely crucial. Rubin had been a top dog at Goldman-Sachs before he joined the Clinton Administration, and after he left the treasury he moved into the leadership of Citigroup. (Rubin, you see, is a Democratic champion of the 'little people.')
Biden voted FOR the bill in November, i.e., the bill that became the law, just as I said he did. .
The link you posted is to a listing of the Senate vote in MAY, the vote on the preliminary form of the legislation that went to the conference committee. The link I provided above is to a listing of Senate votes on the final form of the bill, the one that became law, the one that actually matters. And, in THAT vote, Biden voted for the bill, McCain did not. Will you admit your mistake?
I claim that BOTH major parties are guilty of favoring the big corporations, and selling out the common people. You tell us that Democrats like Clinton, Rubin and Biden are champions of the common interest. This is ideological nonsense. Yet, your ideological bias is so strong that you 'see' Joe Biden voting AGAINST Gramm-Leach-Bliley, when it is insdisputable that he voted FOR it.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
14,280
Tokens
Regarding Gramm-Leach-Bliley, McCain did vote FOR the original version when it first came up for a vote in the Senate (Senate vote #105, May 6). But then the bill went into conference committee, and some changes were made. During this period, there was intense lobbying, both pro and con, and much pressure in favor of the bill from the Clinton administration.
When the amended legislation returned to the Senate from conference committee for the final vote, McCain now refused to vote for it (Senate vote #354, Nov. 4).
Biden did the reverse switch. He did vote against the legislation in its original form (May 6). But the massive lobbying effort in favor of the bill between May and November influenced Biden. Also, the Clinton Administration pushed him strongly to vote Aye. Robert Rubin, Clinton's Secretary of the Treasury, canvassed the legislators and 'explained' why this 'reform' was absolutely crucial. Rubin had been a top dog at Goldman-Sachs before he joined the Clinton Administration, and after he left the treasury he moved into the leadership of Citigroup. (Rubin, you see, is a Democratic champion of the 'little people.')
Biden voted FOR the bill in November, i.e., the bill that became the law, just as I said he did. .
The link you posted is to a listing of the Senate vote in MAY, the vote on the preliminary form of the legislation that went to the conference committee. The link I provided above is to a listing of Senate votes on the final form of the bill, the one that became law, the one that actually matters. And, in THAT vote, Biden voted for the bill, McCain did not. Will you admit your mistake?
I claim that BOTH major parties are guilty of favoring the big corporations, and selling out the common people. You tell us that Democrats like Clinton, Rubin and Biden are champions of the common interest. This is ideological nonsense. Yet, your ideological bias is so strong that you 'see' Joe Biden voting AGAINST Gramm-Leach-Bliley, when it is insdisputable that he voted FOR it.

Keep spinning. :103631605
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,120,952
Messages
13,589,255
Members
101,020
Latest member
nicholasbryansedor
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com