Four Downs: Stafford, Greene sharp, but ...
Eric Karabell
Detroit Lions quarterback Matthew Stafford eventually picked apart the Philadelphia Eagles in a 26-23 comeback overtime victory Sunday, but I'm skeptical about this young quarterback and whether to truly trust him the rest of this season.
Stafford looked downright awful for three quarters, then put up 220 of his 311 passing yards in the fourth quarter and overtime. According to ESPN Stats & Information, he was 1-for-5 for 28 yards and an interception on throws at least 15 yards downfield through three quarters.
<offer>Stafford ultimately ran for a touchdown, threw for another and ended up with 20 fantasy points in standard leagues, his finest fantasy performance of the season, but it wasn't pretty. Plus, 20 fantasy points in a given week wasn't such a struggle last year, when he topped 5,000 passing yards and 40 touchdowns. Stafford scored 22 or more points in eight games. For most of Sunday, he wasn't the same guy. If Stafford hadn't accomplished what he did a year ago, finishing fifth overall with 333 fantasy points (more than 20 per week), expectations would be considerably lower today. Well, perhaps they still should be.</offer>
<offer></offer>
<offer>Stafford salvaged his game Sunday, but don't pretend all is well, and it's why I ranked him as a borderline top-10 quarterback in my end-of-season rankings this past Tuesday. I sure would look into selling high on him if you've got another top-12 quarterback option. Yes, I would rather have Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Tom Brady, Robert Griffin III, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton and both Mannings than Stafford, and looking at Detroit's pending schedule, it might not be long before Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, Tony Romo and even Andrew Luck catch him, too. Perhaps the hip injury that likely hindered Stafford in September remains a factor. The Lions came off their bye week and looked terrible offensively for three hours, with the most consistent aspect of their game being their repeated penalties.
Philly's secondary folded late, but Stafford will be facing better defenses the next two weeks in the Chicago Bears and Seattle Seahawks. It will be tougher to trade a quarterback coming off a 12-point game, or if he's limping. Next week the Lions are back in Chicago, scene of Stafford's four-interception performance in Week 10 last year. The Bears' defense entered this Week 6 tied with Aaron Rodgers for fifth overall in fantasy points, and this unit has scored the same five touchdowns Stafford has in five games. The final four weeks of the season, at fantasy playoff time, Stafford will be in Green Bay and Arizona, then hosting the Atlanta Falcons -- will they still be undefeated by then? -- and then the Bears again. That's just not appealing.
Fantasy owners can choose to trust the Stafford who excelled late Sunday, but we can't erase what happened through three quarters, with fewer than 100 passing yards, or really, the first mediocre month. It took a while for Stafford to get in sync with Calvin Johnson on Sunday, as Megatron had just one reception entering the fourth quarter. He finished with 13 points, which isn't so special, but it beats nothing, and Cincinnati Bengals stud A.J. Green and New York Giants "dancer" Victor Cruz are just as dominant at this point, perhaps more so. Green and Cruz will replace Johnson atop my year-to-end wide receiver rankings Tuesday.
None of this means Stafford and Johnson owners should wantonly sell off their first- or second-rounders for nobodies, but fantasy football is a game about value, and so far 2012 has not looked much like 2011 for these fellows. There's no harm in keeping these guys, but if you're a trading fool and want to cash in on perceived value, don't let the final 20 minutes of Sunday's comeback win cloud your judgment.
Second down: New York Jets running back Shonn Greene totaled 12 fantasy points in his past four games, rushing for no more than 40 yards in a game, so Sunday's 161-yard, three-touchdown explosion in Indianapolis shouldn't be overrated. I can't sell high fast enough. Seriously, Greene is better than he looked the past month, but the Jets don't face the Colts again. They have the New England Patriots and Miami Dolphins the next fortnight. Greene was below average much of 2011, as well, topping 15 fantasy points in only two contests. This was not Greene turning the corner to stardom, this was the Colts being the Colts.
Third down: Patriots tight end Aaron Hernandez returned to the lineup Sunday and had six catches, 30 yards and a 1-yard touchdown. Meanwhile, Rob Gronkowski owners continue to grumble that their second-round pick is underachieving. The fact is both fellows should be top-10 tight ends, but it's a bit late to get proper return on draft-day investment for either. Hernandez was a risky play in Week 6, but won't be moving forward. While he didn't appear fully recovered from an ankle injury that cost him essentially four games, this is a top-10 tight end. Same with Gronkowski, though he's clearly not 100 percent. If you can still sell high on Gronkowski, pointing out his 2011 numbers, do so.
Fourth down: Two struggling Dallas Cowboys running backs thrived Sunday, which tells us … we're past the point of fearing the once-vaunted Baltimore Ravens defense. That defense, which lost several key players Sunday, allowed a franchise-record 227 rushing yards Sunday. Over the past two weeks, opponents have rushed for a league-high 352 yards between the tackles. In other words, Arian Foster, Trent Richardson, Darren McFadden and Rashard Mendenhall (twice!) should enjoy future meetings. As for the Cowboys, DeMarco Murray and Felix Jones each topped 90 rushing yards, but don't get too excited. Murray sprained a foot and left early, opening the door for the forgotten Jones, who entered play with five fantasy points all season. Murray's status for Week 7 remains unknown, but certainly his durability has been in question before. Jones will likely be a popular add, but we've seen his act in the past.
</offer>
Eric Karabell
Detroit Lions quarterback Matthew Stafford eventually picked apart the Philadelphia Eagles in a 26-23 comeback overtime victory Sunday, but I'm skeptical about this young quarterback and whether to truly trust him the rest of this season.
Stafford looked downright awful for three quarters, then put up 220 of his 311 passing yards in the fourth quarter and overtime. According to ESPN Stats & Information, he was 1-for-5 for 28 yards and an interception on throws at least 15 yards downfield through three quarters.
<offer>Stafford ultimately ran for a touchdown, threw for another and ended up with 20 fantasy points in standard leagues, his finest fantasy performance of the season, but it wasn't pretty. Plus, 20 fantasy points in a given week wasn't such a struggle last year, when he topped 5,000 passing yards and 40 touchdowns. Stafford scored 22 or more points in eight games. For most of Sunday, he wasn't the same guy. If Stafford hadn't accomplished what he did a year ago, finishing fifth overall with 333 fantasy points (more than 20 per week), expectations would be considerably lower today. Well, perhaps they still should be.</offer>
<offer></offer>
<offer>Stafford salvaged his game Sunday, but don't pretend all is well, and it's why I ranked him as a borderline top-10 quarterback in my end-of-season rankings this past Tuesday. I sure would look into selling high on him if you've got another top-12 quarterback option. Yes, I would rather have Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Tom Brady, Robert Griffin III, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton and both Mannings than Stafford, and looking at Detroit's pending schedule, it might not be long before Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, Tony Romo and even Andrew Luck catch him, too. Perhaps the hip injury that likely hindered Stafford in September remains a factor. The Lions came off their bye week and looked terrible offensively for three hours, with the most consistent aspect of their game being their repeated penalties.
Philly's secondary folded late, but Stafford will be facing better defenses the next two weeks in the Chicago Bears and Seattle Seahawks. It will be tougher to trade a quarterback coming off a 12-point game, or if he's limping. Next week the Lions are back in Chicago, scene of Stafford's four-interception performance in Week 10 last year. The Bears' defense entered this Week 6 tied with Aaron Rodgers for fifth overall in fantasy points, and this unit has scored the same five touchdowns Stafford has in five games. The final four weeks of the season, at fantasy playoff time, Stafford will be in Green Bay and Arizona, then hosting the Atlanta Falcons -- will they still be undefeated by then? -- and then the Bears again. That's just not appealing.
Fantasy owners can choose to trust the Stafford who excelled late Sunday, but we can't erase what happened through three quarters, with fewer than 100 passing yards, or really, the first mediocre month. It took a while for Stafford to get in sync with Calvin Johnson on Sunday, as Megatron had just one reception entering the fourth quarter. He finished with 13 points, which isn't so special, but it beats nothing, and Cincinnati Bengals stud A.J. Green and New York Giants "dancer" Victor Cruz are just as dominant at this point, perhaps more so. Green and Cruz will replace Johnson atop my year-to-end wide receiver rankings Tuesday.
None of this means Stafford and Johnson owners should wantonly sell off their first- or second-rounders for nobodies, but fantasy football is a game about value, and so far 2012 has not looked much like 2011 for these fellows. There's no harm in keeping these guys, but if you're a trading fool and want to cash in on perceived value, don't let the final 20 minutes of Sunday's comeback win cloud your judgment.
Second down: New York Jets running back Shonn Greene totaled 12 fantasy points in his past four games, rushing for no more than 40 yards in a game, so Sunday's 161-yard, three-touchdown explosion in Indianapolis shouldn't be overrated. I can't sell high fast enough. Seriously, Greene is better than he looked the past month, but the Jets don't face the Colts again. They have the New England Patriots and Miami Dolphins the next fortnight. Greene was below average much of 2011, as well, topping 15 fantasy points in only two contests. This was not Greene turning the corner to stardom, this was the Colts being the Colts.
Third down: Patriots tight end Aaron Hernandez returned to the lineup Sunday and had six catches, 30 yards and a 1-yard touchdown. Meanwhile, Rob Gronkowski owners continue to grumble that their second-round pick is underachieving. The fact is both fellows should be top-10 tight ends, but it's a bit late to get proper return on draft-day investment for either. Hernandez was a risky play in Week 6, but won't be moving forward. While he didn't appear fully recovered from an ankle injury that cost him essentially four games, this is a top-10 tight end. Same with Gronkowski, though he's clearly not 100 percent. If you can still sell high on Gronkowski, pointing out his 2011 numbers, do so.
Fourth down: Two struggling Dallas Cowboys running backs thrived Sunday, which tells us … we're past the point of fearing the once-vaunted Baltimore Ravens defense. That defense, which lost several key players Sunday, allowed a franchise-record 227 rushing yards Sunday. Over the past two weeks, opponents have rushed for a league-high 352 yards between the tackles. In other words, Arian Foster, Trent Richardson, Darren McFadden and Rashard Mendenhall (twice!) should enjoy future meetings. As for the Cowboys, DeMarco Murray and Felix Jones each topped 90 rushing yards, but don't get too excited. Murray sprained a foot and left early, opening the door for the forgotten Jones, who entered play with five fantasy points all season. Murray's status for Week 7 remains unknown, but certainly his durability has been in question before. Jones will likely be a popular add, but we've seen his act in the past.
</offer>