Copied this from somewhere else. Can't vouch for its accuracy 100%, but it looks about right:
Football newsletters 2013 records
NCAA
Powersweep
43-28 excelled in 4 and 3 star releases combined 27-14 on these picks.
Playbook
20-23-2. Suffered greatly with 3 rated picks going 4-11. Underdog play went 11-7. 5 and 4 rated plays both went 8-6-1.
Pointwise
63-54-2 excelled in their top 1 rated play going 21-8-1. Outside of 3 rated plays 9-6 they suffered. 30-14 in 1 and 3 rated plays. 30-40-2 in the rest.
Red Sheet
43-32 Excelled in 89 rated plays going 21-10. 88 plays went 22-22.
CKO
65-57-1 Best plays 11 rated went 11-6 10 and 9 rated plays 25-26 and 30-26-1. Not the greatest of years for them.
Goldsheet
29-31 A down year for them, no rating system. In 2012 they went 34-20. A pretty big regression last year.
Winning Points
35-31-3 2 rated plays were their best going 21-12. Their top 4 and 3 plays went 8-7-2 and 5-11-2 a really rough year with top rated plays.
Gag Sheet aka Green Sheet or Nelly's
No records were maintained due to their threatening of their purchasers to not post the newsletter or get cut off. Personally they are overrated and raised the price of the newsletter this year by 12.5% from $8 to $9.
On a side note I don't think they are any good and for the hassle they put to their customers, they aren't worth it. Enjoy the posting of this newsletter while it lasts. They typically allow the first few weeks to get the word spread out on them then they cut people off. Tell them to stick their product up their ass.
NFL
Powersweep
21-25-2 Top rated 4's went 9-6 the rest were abysmal.
Playbook
30-18-2 The best for NFL last year. While the top rated 5's went 9-7 the 4's went 10-5-2 the 3's 11-6. A good overall NFL for Marc.
Pointwise
43-42-4 Look at the record and then digest that their 3 rated plays went 16-5-1. The 4's and 5's went a combined 27-37-3.
Red Sheet
7-8 They only released 88 plays last year, no best bet of an 89 play.
CKO
20-16-3 11's went 2-0 10's 10-5-2 9's 8-11-1 Toss out the 9's and it was a great year for CKO.
Gold Sheet
27-32 just as bad as NCAA. No ratings.
Winning Points
35-31-3 Their 2 rated plays went 21-12, the rest went 14-19-3 nothing of greatness here outside of their 2 rated plays which is their 2nd to last plays
Football newsletters 2013 records
NCAA
Powersweep
43-28 excelled in 4 and 3 star releases combined 27-14 on these picks.
Playbook
20-23-2. Suffered greatly with 3 rated picks going 4-11. Underdog play went 11-7. 5 and 4 rated plays both went 8-6-1.
Pointwise
63-54-2 excelled in their top 1 rated play going 21-8-1. Outside of 3 rated plays 9-6 they suffered. 30-14 in 1 and 3 rated plays. 30-40-2 in the rest.
Red Sheet
43-32 Excelled in 89 rated plays going 21-10. 88 plays went 22-22.
CKO
65-57-1 Best plays 11 rated went 11-6 10 and 9 rated plays 25-26 and 30-26-1. Not the greatest of years for them.
Goldsheet
29-31 A down year for them, no rating system. In 2012 they went 34-20. A pretty big regression last year.
Winning Points
35-31-3 2 rated plays were their best going 21-12. Their top 4 and 3 plays went 8-7-2 and 5-11-2 a really rough year with top rated plays.
Gag Sheet aka Green Sheet or Nelly's
No records were maintained due to their threatening of their purchasers to not post the newsletter or get cut off. Personally they are overrated and raised the price of the newsletter this year by 12.5% from $8 to $9.
On a side note I don't think they are any good and for the hassle they put to their customers, they aren't worth it. Enjoy the posting of this newsletter while it lasts. They typically allow the first few weeks to get the word spread out on them then they cut people off. Tell them to stick their product up their ass.
NFL
Powersweep
21-25-2 Top rated 4's went 9-6 the rest were abysmal.
Playbook
30-18-2 The best for NFL last year. While the top rated 5's went 9-7 the 4's went 10-5-2 the 3's 11-6. A good overall NFL for Marc.
Pointwise
43-42-4 Look at the record and then digest that their 3 rated plays went 16-5-1. The 4's and 5's went a combined 27-37-3.
Red Sheet
7-8 They only released 88 plays last year, no best bet of an 89 play.
CKO
20-16-3 11's went 2-0 10's 10-5-2 9's 8-11-1 Toss out the 9's and it was a great year for CKO.
Gold Sheet
27-32 just as bad as NCAA. No ratings.
Winning Points
35-31-3 Their 2 rated plays went 21-12, the rest went 14-19-3 nothing of greatness here outside of their 2 rated plays which is their 2nd to last plays
i don't think you would do bad if all you did was follow the 89 rated college plays at the Red Sheet. The 89 plays went 21-10 last year. Red Sheet and Pointwise are published by the same guy and he is a well respected handicapper.
------
More Newsletters Week 3
Platinum Sheet
Recap - Newsletters Week 3
CKO
Gold Sheet
Gold Sheet Extra
Pointwise
Gaming Today
Platinum Sheet
Nelly's Green Sheet
Marc Lawrence's Playbook
Red Sheet
Power Sweep
Power Plays
CKO
Gold Sheet
Gold Sheet Extra
Pointwise
Gaming Today
Platinum Sheet
Nelly's Green Sheet
Marc Lawrence's Playbook
Red Sheet
Power Sweep
Power Plays
