No. 2 seed | 92-69 | AL Central champs
ALDS opponent: Tigers (56.4% chance of advancing)
World Series odds: 13.3% | ESPN BET odds: +900
Predicted date of their last game: Oct. 21
If they win it all, the 2024 World Series MVP will be ...Can we just pick the entire bullpen? No? Four relievers have won a World Series MVP (Larry Sherry, Rollie Fingers, John Wetteland and Mariano Rivera) so don't rule out
Emmanuel Clase. Indeed, while
Jose Ramirez is the obvious choice, his game hasn't translated to the postseason, with just two home runs in 124 at-bats. Let's go with Clase; if Cleveland wins, it's probably because he gets four World Series saves.
-- Schoenfield
If they go home soon, it will be because ... The starting rotation isn't good enough. Cleveland posted the best bullpen ERA in baseball by a substantial margin. Clase has been the best closer in the majors.
Cade Smith,
Hunter Gaddis and
Tim Herrin might be the sport's stoutest bridge to the ninth inning. The rotation is another matter. No. 1 starter
Shane Bieber underwent Tommy John surgery after two starts.
Triston McKenzie, two years removed from a breakout season, performed so poorly he was sent to Triple-A in June and hasn't returned to the majors. Without them,
Tanner Bibee (3.47 ERA in 31 starts) emerged as the top starter for a rotation that finished tied for 23rd in ERA and 24th innings pitched. The Guardians will need to piece together the pitching to make a title run. But too much reliance on the bullpen might be unsustainable.
-- Castill
Ready for his October close-up: The Guardians acquired
Lane Thomas before the trade deadline hoping he would fortify an offense in perpetual need of production. August was brutal, but Thomas showed what he's capable of amid a torrid month of September. He has been hitting mostly behind
Josh Naylor, but also in front of Ramirez at times. His presence will be critical in October. The Guardians finished in the middle of the pack in OPS and runs per game this season. They need someone besides Ramirez, Naylor and
Steven Kwan to produce consistently. They need the Lane Thomas who provided 28 home runs and a .783 OPS for last year's Washington Nationals. He might have tapped back into that.
-- Gonzalez
Why you should root for them: 1948. That's when Lou Boudreau, Larry Doby, Satchel Paige, Bob Feller & Co. led Cleveland to the World Series. Good times. Harry Truman was president. Jack Kerouac was gallivanting around the country with Neal Cassady. Don Draper was still living as Dick Whitman, years away from landing on Madison Avenue. The franchise has not won it all since then, giving it the longest active title drought in baseball. This team, with an offense that has contact, athleticism and just enough power, and armed with the sport's best bullpen, is built to quench that thirst. To do so, the Guardians will have to topple some superstars -- Judge, Ohtani among the possibilities -- which would make it that much sweeter to watch.
-- Doolittle