Manny Ramirez Passes Mickey Mantle in HR's.....Who's the Better All-Time Hitter Between the Two ?

Search

Who's the Better All-Time Hitter Between the Two ?

  • Mickey Mantle

    Votes: 42 75.0%
  • Manny Ramirez

    Votes: 14 25.0%

  • Total voters
    56

Oh boy!
Joined
Mar 21, 2004
Messages
38,373
Tokens
Actually just voted for Manny now

:toast:

Just got back from visiting Canada. I think you would like it.

My friend said that he lives in a city where US Apache helicopters flew over the city with infrared cameras to see how many had grow lights in them. The term "lit up like a Christmas tree" was used along with "60% of the houses". The US realized it was futile to pursue it any further.

Also heard that the Hells Angels is big up there and there was a big war with the Asian gangs. The Asian gangs were run out of town. Don't mess with the HA. They don't mess with anyone unless you try to take their business.

:bong:
 

Professional At All Times
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
42,732
Tokens
Mickey Mantle and it's not even close regardless of the what the numbers might show. Plus the Mick wasn't on roids but more boozed up then anything else.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
162 game average numbers, with TheMick listed first, then Manny

Avg .298 .315
R 113 111
RBI 102 133
HR 36 41

2B 23 39
3B 5 1

OPS .977 1.006
K 115 128


Really a pretty persuasive case for Manny here.

Take the vaunted Mickster out of The Stadium with that short ass RF porch and he's likely down to well under 500 HRs, thus making him pretty much an earlier version of Eddie Murray.

d1g1t

Yeah, that it..Mickey Mantle was just another Eddie Murray :ohno:

Mantle also hit some of the longest home runs in Major League history. On September 10, 1960, he hit a ball left-handed that cleared the right-field roof at Tiger Stadium in Detroit and, based on where it was found, was estimated years later by historian Mark Gallagher to have traveled 643 feet (196 m). Another Mantle homer, this one hit right-handed off Chuck Stobbs at Griffith Stadium in Washington on April 17, 1953, was measured by Yankees traveling secretary Red Patterson (hence the term "tape-measure home run") to have traveled 565 feet (172 m). Though it is apparent that they are actually the distances where the balls ended up after bouncing several times [1], there is no doubt that they both landed more than 500 feet (152 m) from home plate. Mantle twice hit balls off the third-deck facade at Yankee Stadium, nearly becoming the only player (other than Negro Leagues star Josh Gibson) to hit a fair ball out of the stadium during a game. On May 22, 1963, against Kansas City's Bill Fischer, Mantle hit a ball that fellow players and fans claimed was still rising when it hit the 110-foot (34 m) high facade, then caromed back onto the playing field. It was later estimated by some that the ball could have traveled 620 feet (190 m) had it not been blocked by the ornate and distinctive facade. While physicists might question those estimates, on August 12, 1964, he hit one whose distance was undoubted: a center field drive that cleared the 22-foot (6.7 m) batter's eye screen, beyond the 461-foot (141 m) marker at the Stadium.
 

Honey Badger Don't Give A Shit
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
46,540
Tokens
At the plate..yes....He's the white Eddie Murray

Now I'll agree that Murray probably would not have played as good a CF as the Commerce Comet
 

Honey Badger Don't Give A Shit
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
46,540
Tokens
I'm screwin' around a bit....just looking for the next best Switch Hitter of all time

Mick was the best...certainly better than Steady Eddie

Perhaps if he had not jacked up his knee on that drainpipe in 1951, he might have logged a few more seasons and busted 600+ HRs
 

New member
Joined
Oct 11, 2004
Messages
2,418
Tokens
you baseball guys have always been funny to me. Most real baseball fans take the "magical numbers" and the old time players way to serious. Was Mantle great. Yes of course he was, but here is the funny thing. Mantle's last good year was 1964. That means if your 60 today you were 15 when Mantle was basically done. So to truly have seen Mantle play baseball you would have to be what 65, 70 years old right now. So basiaclly almost none of you have actually seen the guy play a game ever and are saying he is better than a guy playing right now. And your saying that based on stats you see on the back of a baseball card. You can't compare players today from players 50 years ago. How good would Manny be if he didn't have to play against blacks or latins? How good would he be if he faced the same pitcher 5 times every night insted of a starter, reliever and a closer? You can say what you want about how there are so many pitchers today that the position is watered down, but go look at video from the 60's and tell me the average pitcher then was as good as the average pitcher now. Its not even close, todays pitchers throw ungodly breaking stuff, and the average guy throws 94. Mantle was considered a real big baseball player in his day. Today the MLB average is 6'1" 208lbs. So the average guy today is bigger than the big guy from the 50's. I'm bigger than Mickey Mantle for christs sake.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 11, 2004
Messages
2,418
Tokens
Here's another funny thing to me about some of you baseball freaks. Baseball is the one and only game where all these numbers are magical. 500 HR's, 3000 hits, 755 HR's, 300 wins. And guess what, its the one sport where number shouldn't matter as much. Every era is different, every field has different dimentions. The mound was higher, than lower, the ball was dead, then live, and countless other differances over the years. So how can anybody realistically ever compare players to other players. At least in football every field is 100 yards long by 53.3 yards wide. In basketball every court is 94 ft long and 50 ft wide. A free throw is always 15 feet. Get what I'm saying, baseball is the only sport with so many inconsistencies. Yet baseball crazys want to compare players by numbers. Just know that todays athletes are bigger stronger and better than 50 years ago and appreciate them and enjoy the game. Quit the hissy fit cause some guy broke Hank Aaron's home run record. Guess what it will be broken again by Arod and probably again by the next guy. Who cares.
 

Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2008
Messages
24,627
Tokens
Mickey Mantle played with like no Knees. from an early injury as a teenager while playing football, to hurting himself on a storm drain in old yankee stadium in the outfield. Yet he still put up crazy numbers. plus you throw in the booze, partying etc. its not even close
 

Official Rx music critic and beer snob
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Messages
25,128
Tokens
Mickey Mantle played with like no Knees. from an early injury as a teenager while playing football, to hurting himself on a storm drain in old yankee stadium in the outfield. Yet he still put up crazy numbers. plus you throw in the booze, partying etc. its not even close

Today's players don't party? Really, that is Mantle's fault for not taking care of himself. If he did, he probably could have broken Ruth's HR record.
 

Rx Local Motion
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Messages
46,313
Tokens
this is eaZy....mickey played in the blk & wht era...normal people couldve played then....:):)

my Vote!
MannyWood!!!!!!!!!!!
:pope:
 

Pro Handi-Craper My Picks are the shit
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
4,098
Tokens
Ot Mickeys numbers if he hit in these small stadiums.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
2,898
Tokens
The steroid era enflates power numbers yet Mantle hit over 50 homers 2X in a non-steroid environment. He was only the 4th player ever to do that,
Ruth, Jimmy Foxx & Kiner were the others. Nowadays you have a juicer like Sosa hitting over 60 homeruns 3X and in those years did not even lead his own league in HR's. Ridiculous!

Having said that I think Manny is the 2nd best player of the steroid era
slightly behind Pulhous. Manny & Mantle will both go down as 2 of the top 25 offensive players of all time. Williams, Ruth, Foxx, Gerhig & Hornsby I think are undisputably the top 5. I voted for Manny but it really is a tossup!
 

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
75,154
Tokens
I can't believe anyone even asked. You had to see Mantle to believe how good he was.. I am not going to get into any debates over this.


Mickey Mantle= Del Posto's on Tenth Ave in NYC.
Manny=The Olive Garden in Lawrence, Kansas



wil..:103631605
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
I can't believe anyone even asked. You had to see Mantle to believe how good he was.. I am not going to get into any debates over this.


Mickey Mantle= Del Posto's on Tenth Ave in NYC.
Manny=The Olive Garden in Lawrence, Kansas



wil..:103631605
I never saw Mantle play, so I can't comment

But damn Wil, that's COLD.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
34,888
Tokens
I can't believe anyone even asked. You had to see Mantle to believe how good he was.. I am not going to get into any debates over this.


Mickey Mantle= Del Posto's on Tenth Ave in NYC.
Manny=The Olive Garden in Lawrence, Kansas



wil..:103631605

Might be one of the only posts of Wil's i ever liked or respected...
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,119,859
Messages
13,574,239
Members
100,878
Latest member
fo88giftt
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com