Kruser,
I just read the entire thread and thought I would post my 2bits.
Your heart is truly in the right place although you should be included in the list. The guys you mention are the ones I follow on here. I only found this place recently and it couldn't have happened at a better time. My offshore account has grown thanks to you and the guys you mention, even though I only play between $20 and $50 per play. It takes a long time to make $$ that way but I am making it. Good timing too having lost my job recently.
I like the idea of doing something for these guys, I truly do. HOWEVER, in reading this, I tried to look at it from possibly their perspective.
The fact you are wanting to do this speaks volumes about your appreciation for their picks. You ARE a class act, as are they. In my opinion, what I would appreciate, is someone sending me a private email saying thanks, or if the opportunity arises and sincere handshake and a thanks or perhaps buying them a drink. They are winning with their picks and can afford dinners.
Any thought to asking them if we can make a donation to their favorite charity in their name as a thank you? Maybe they have a charity they really like and that may actually mean more to them than a dinner.
I will probably be in touch to see what you decide ultimately.
Thank YOU for your efforts in this endeavor and as always for your plays!