5 Greatest Lakers

Search

Professional At All Times
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
42,732
Tokens
silver7

After Kobe's night M&M are discussing this. Mine are & this is tough:
Magic
Kareem
Kobe
The Logo
Elgin
George was great, but don't know if he belongs in this gp? I saw him play more than any of the others.:think2:

Ditto my friend!
 

New member
Joined
Jan 30, 2009
Messages
4,271
Tokens
Could James Worthy, Robert Horry or Michael Cooper make the list? I was always a Kurt Rambis type of guy. Not pretty, but effective.
 

New member
Joined
Jan 24, 2010
Messages
144
Tokens
The problem with such a list is there are subjective values which come into play, such as who was dominanting at the time. For instance, the Lakers have had 4 of the greatest centers of their era, starting with George Mikan, who essentially defined the evolutionary process for modern basketball, then Wilt Chamberlain, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, and Shaquille O'Neal. They have had 2 of the greatest guards of their eras, Jerry West (the model for the NBA logo, no less!) and Magic Johnson, who revolutionized the roll of the hybrid player. Finally, what can you say about Kobe Bryant, pure talent! So we have seven people here, all who were dominant in their position of their era, and all were vital parts of multiple championship teams or were perennially the best player of their position (Chamberlain). Whom do you leave off?

That is why I find such lists too subjective for restricting individuals to a certain number. However, I don't believe that any other player can achieve the level of "greatness" that these seven provide.

My favorite players who don't make the list, incidentally, are Kurt Rambis, Derek Fischer, and Robert Horry. Rambis essentially defined the Nose Tackle approach to wearing down power forwards, while Fischer and Horry were (are) perennial Finals money players. In any case, it's a tough decision, and I wouldn't want to leave off any of the top 7.
 

New member
Joined
Dec 20, 2009
Messages
47
Tokens
i can name 4 Great Lakers that were a Lucky 3--pointer away from being SWEPT 4-0 in N B A Finals if not for Lucky 3 in Game 1

KOBE
SHAQ
MALONE
PEYTON (Gary)

4 Future hall of famers should have been Swept 4-0 rather than 4-1 by a bunch of young Pistons to cost me the Larger wager of my entire life . . amount will not be disclosed
 

Oh boy!
Joined
Mar 21, 2004
Messages
38,373
Tokens
And I think maybe I did big George a disservice. Or maybe mistitled the thread. As far as the greatest, i.e. who contibuted the most to the franchise, as opposed who's the most talented by todays standards. Mikan indeed has to be on the Laker Wall of Fame. As far as Ruth goes, he's undeniably one of the 5 or so greatest hitters of all time. But even he as did Mikan benefited from never having to face any black players or night games.

Sounds like I'm arguing against myself, & maybe I am. But on talent alone I just can't rank Mikan w/the 5 I listed. If we break it into eras, say prior to 1958, then yes George is top 5, not just Laker but NBA overall. Yes, he was one hell of a player in the hole, a real bruiser and a lovely hook. I'll leave it at that. After playing he had a law practice for many yrs, here in the TC's. Very nice man.

I guess we will never know how Mikan would have done if he had to face the competition in the NBA we have today. I'm guessing he would have risen to the level of the competition. Maybe worked on a different set of moves or different set of shots.

But I agree with you, he wouldn't be in the top 5 with the moves he had when he played.

:toast:
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,994
Tokens
i can name 4 Great Lakers that were a Lucky 3--pointer away from being SWEPT 4-0 in N B A Finals if not for Lucky 3 in Game 1

KOBE
SHAQ
MALONE
PEYTON (Gary)

4 Future hall of famers should have been Swept 4-0 rather than 4-1 by a bunch of young Pistons to cost me the Larger wager of my entire life . . amount will not be disclosed

Plus at least one of Kobe's rings were gift wrapped by the refs
in the worst ref'ed game ever (Lakers/Sacramento 2002 game 6).
 

New member
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
4,223
Tokens
Zits opinion doesn't count for anything concerning Kobe. He sill ignorantly believes that he raped the white skank from Colorado and is still bitter about it.

He is the definition of a Kobe hater. He hates Kobe, just because.
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
The problem with such a list is there are subjective values which come into play, such as who was dominanting at the time. For instance, the Lakers have had 4 of the greatest centers of their era, starting with George Mikan, who essentially defined the evolutionary process for modern basketball, then Wilt Chamberlain, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, and Shaquille O'Neal. They have had 2 of the greatest guards of their eras, Jerry West (the model for the NBA logo, no less!) and Magic Johnson, who revolutionized the roll of the hybrid player. Finally, what can you say about Kobe Bryant, pure talent! So we have seven people here, all who were dominant in their position of their era, and all were vital parts of multiple championship teams or were perennially the best player of their position (Chamberlain). Whom do you leave off?

That is why I find such lists too subjective for restricting individuals to a certain number. However, I don't believe that any other player can achieve the level of "greatness" that these seven provide.

My favorite players who don't make the list, incidentally, are Kurt Rambis, Derek Fischer, and Robert Horry. Rambis essentially defined the Nose Tackle approach to wearing down power forwards, while Fischer and Horry were (are) perennial Finals money players. In any case, it's a tough decision, and I wouldn't want to leave off any of the top 7.

I know what you are saying. I was kind of a Byron Scott fan growing up.
 

New member
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
1,559
Tokens
1. Johnson
2. Mikan
3. Kareem
4. Kobe
5. Baylor

Tough to leave West off the list, but from all I've read, Baylor was one of the most explosive scorers ever. That said, I'm too young to have watched either play.
 

Where Taconite Is Just A Low Grade Ore
Joined
Aug 20, 2000
Messages
8,490
Tokens
You're So Right

1. Johnson
2. Mikan
3. Kareem
4. Kobe
5. Baylor

Tough to leave West off the list, but from all I've read, Baylor was one of the most explosive scorers ever. That said, I'm too young to have watched either play.

I should have said the 6 greatest, then your list + "The Logo" would be perfect.@):)
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,994
Tokens
Zits opinion doesn't count for anything concerning Kobe. He sill ignorantly believes that he raped the white skank from Colorado and is still bitter about it.

He is the definition of a Kobe hater. He hates Kobe, just because.

Dear forum troll:

You and I both know that my clear and definitive statement on
the alleged rape is that only two people in the world know what
happened in that room and it isn't you or me.

Get a job yet?
 

New member
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
4,223
Tokens
Dear forum troll:

You and I both know that my clear and definitive statement on
the alleged rape is that only two people in the world know what
happened in that room and it isn't you or me.

Get a job yet?

Bitter old man, let the hate go, life is to short.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,994
Tokens
Bitter old man, let the hate go, life is to short.

Because I (like 70% of the rest of the world) think Kobe is a scumbag
I'm a bitter old man?

ROFL.

I'm about as well adjusted and happy about the success I've had
so far in life as I can be. And, if 45 to you is old, I got news for you kid...

On a more serious note, the Austin job market is picking up, any
leads yet?
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
34,881
Tokens
Mikan, Slater Martin, Jim Pollard, and Vern Mikkelsen all had Hall of Fame careers. Yet Mikan was the undisputed king. During the BAA playoffs in 1949, he averaged 30 points per game while the rest of the Lakers combined for 50. In 1952, he scored 61 points in a game against the Rochester Royals.

RIP VERN

http://msn.foxsports.com/nba/story/...ikkelsen-dies-at-85-minneapolis-lakers-112213

Four-time champ, Hall of Famer Vern Mikkelsen dies at 85

<!-- galleryList size--><!-- photo --><!-- if we have photo caption add 'caption' to the class list-->
<!-- if we have photo caption add 'caption' to the class list-->
112213-NBA-1953-Minneapolis-Lakers-team-TV-Pi_20131122174236189_660_320.JPG
<!-- Blurb div --> Vern Mikkelsen (#19, center), shown with his teammates in 1953.<!-- Needs to come from BE -->

<!-- video --><!-- GALLERY --><!-- gallery -->

<!-- -->







Updated Nov 22, 2013 8:14 PM ET
<!-- -->


LOS ANGELES (AP)

Vern Mikkelsen, a Hall of Fame basketball player who won four NBA titles with the Minneapolis Lakers, has died. He was 85.
Mikkelsen died on Thursday night surrounded by family, the Los Angeles Lakers announced on Friday. He was a six-time All-Star during 10 years with the Lakers, teaming with George Mikan and Jim Pollard in a frontcourt that to this day is considered one of the best the league has ever seen.

<!-- r3rdParty-1 -->


Up Next
0

Image.aspx

Glove Actually: Early Returns on Anthony Bennett
The season is young, but it's never too early for the Glove to evaluate the number one overall pick, Anthony Bennett. Plus, GP names who he thinks are the top contenders in the Western Conference.
Share














Glove Actually: Early Returns on Anthony Bennett

The season is young, but it's never too early for the Glove to evaluate the number one overall pick, Anthony Bennett. Plus, GP names who he thinks are the top contenders in the Western Conference.
Date 11/7/13,Duration 3:41,Views 10619
Video by: Fox Sports











<form style="display: none;" id="_fw_form_slot35684_fs-article-inline-video-player-1_a"><input id="_fw_input_slot35684_fs-article-inline-video-player-1_a" name="_fw_input_slot35684_fs-article-inline-video-player-1_a" value="slid=slot35684_fs-article-inline-video-player-1_a&ptgt=p&envp=g_iframe&w=300&h=60" type="hidden"></form>

Though he was known for his hard-nosed defense, Mikkelsen averaged 14.4 points and 9.4 rebounds in his career and emerged as one of the league's first true power forwards. He was inducted into the Naismith Basketball Hall of Fame in 1995.
"I was a good basketball player, but I attribute greatness to those individuals who sacrifice their time, talents, and efforts for the benefit of others," Mikkelsen wrote in the forward to "The Vern Mikkelsen Story," which was published in 2006. "I did some of that, too, though not nearly as much as I would have liked to, looking back on it."
Arild Verner Mikkelson was born in Fresno, Calif., in 1928 and grew up in the northern Minnesota town of Askov, about 95 miles north of Minneapolis. He played college ball at Hamline in St. Paul, at the time a basketball power that sent two other players to the Lakers as well. Mikkelsen was drafted in 1949 and helped lead the Lakers to championships in 1950 and three in a row from 1952-54.
One of the league's original enforcers, Mikkelsen was a physical player and fouled out a record 127 times before retiring in 1959.
"He was the protector of Mikan," said Wolves president Flip Saunders, who got to know Mikkelsen during 10 years as a coach in the organization. "He loved being around here. And he was one of the best story tellers."
He was later the coach and general manager of the ABA's Minnesota Pipers.
"Vern was one of the first in a long line of great Lakers players, and a key link to our franchise's early years in Minnesota," Lakers President Jeanie Buss said in a statement. "We appreciate his contributions to the Lakers and our legacy, and we send our condolences and best wishes to his family."

Mikkelsen's name hangs in the rafters at Staples Center on a banner that also is home to the retired jerseys in the organization. Mikkelsen remained a revered figure in Minnesota long after his playing days, a gracious story teller who remained close to the game long after he retired.
In his later years, Mikkelsen overcame two strokes, diabetes, prostate cancer and the death of his wife of 47 years in 2002. And he remained upbeat through it all.
"Keep on doing your best with what you have to work with, as we all have an obligation to take care of ourselves and live as long as possible, respecting each day as a great gift with the intention of sharing the simple, meaningful things of life with family, friends and our community," Mikkelsen wrote.
He was influential in bringing the NBA back to Minnesota in the 1980s and the Timberwolves planned to hold a moment of silence to honor him on Friday night before they played the Brooklyn Nets.
"During his playing days at Hamline University and the Lakers, Vern was a dominant force on the court and one of the game's great power forwards," the Wolves said in a statement. "Vern was a great friend to our organization and we offer our condolences to his family."
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
3,441
Tokens
After Kobe's night M&M are discussing this. Mine are & this is tough:
Magic
Kareem
Kobe
The Logo
Elgin
George was great, but don't know if he belongs in this gp? I saw him play more than any of the others.:think2:

You got it right.
Gotta include Wilt and Shaq who spent part of their careers as Lakers and won titles to make this list the 7 Greatest Lakers.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,118,927
Messages
13,561,607
Members
100,711
Latest member
credihealth
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com