Who is most OVERRATED NFL Head Coach?

[mson]

Marty Shittenhammer, he blows now and he will always blow.

 

[JackStraw77]

Andy Reid, has wasted tons of draft picks and will never win a Superbowl.

 

[DrunkenHorseplayer]

Bill Parcells and Bill Belichik; both are seen as a magic talisman and both are no better or worse than your average coach.

 

[blueedwards]

Bill Parcells and Bill Belichik; both are seen as a magic talisman and both are no better or worse than your average coach.

i disagree. you think dave wannstedt or rich kotite could've won 3 superbowls in 4 years? how about herm edwards or dennis green?

sure the players are more important than the coach but the coaching does matter. you put belichik on the bears in the mid-to-late 80's and you have more than one superbowl, i guarantee that.

 

[Fishhead]

Andy Reid, has wasted tons of draft picks and will never win a Superbowl.

*Fishhead has awarded Jack 100 RX PTS

 

[Tulsa]

How long has Reid been at Philly? I like the guy, and he seems like a decent fellow. BUT.... Hasn't he been there forever? They need to make a change and head off into a new direction.

13 years or so he has been their head coach.

tulsa

 

[Willie99]

BILL BELECHICK.....just had lots of great assistants...they left!
Look at him this season w/o them!


BELECHICK 2005 = EXPOSED

a classic call

the most overrated coach? Norv Turner

 

[CHOPTALK]

Most underated Sean Payton

 

[DrunkenHorseplayer]

Now that we know that Belichik hasn't won a ring without cheating, this debate should be over.

 

[sharky99]

Not sure how San DIego can still have Turner as coach, not for what happened the other night, he just seems to get outcoached periodically. If you consistently get outscored and outplayed in the 2nd half of games, your getting out coached with adjustment teams are making at halftime. Too much inconsistency and bad coaching decisions have make SD a team that will never win any significant games or championships

 

[jb777]

Overrated: Jim Harbaugh, Underrated: Tom Coughlin

 

[jb777]

How long has Reid been at Philly? I like the guy, and he seems like a decent fellow. BUT.... Hasn't he been there forever? They need to make a change and head off into a new direction.

13 years or so he has been their head coach.

tulsa

Correct, he shoulda been gone in 2006. Still here, still a bone head.

 

[SampS]

Andy Reid and Norv Turner

 

[JustinCruise]

John Madden

 

[JustinCruise]

Current: Rex Ryan

 

[pocketrockets]

Bump

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

Mike Tomlin
Tony Dungy all time most overated.

Who is dumber? Ron Rivera, Mike Tomlin or Rex Ryan?

 

[neverbend]

Rich Kottite the guy who took over the Jets after Pete Carroll was fired,

 

[wilbur]

Mike Tomlin
Tony Dungy all time most overated.

Who is dumber? Ron Rivera, Mike Tomlin or Rex Ryan?

Rex Ryan toes down

 

[Greenbacks]

Put my vote in for the TUNA.

:smoker2:

The Tuna is probably one of the greatest of all time...In my book at least.