Which one of these statements are true?

[blueedwards]

Moon I can't argue with.. But the others :ughhh: I can't think of another great black QB..

You mentioned a few guys who were above average QBs..

where did you say they had to be great qb's?

 

[gynecologist]

where did you say they had to be great qb's?

I didn't.. But since we're on the subject, how many great black QB's have their been in the history of the NFL?

 

[lander]

Mind you we suck, but Bills top 3 DE's are all white - Shoebal, Kelsay and Denney. Schoebal is an annual all-pro.

This is really a non-issue ... who cares? Black people have been faster for a long time now -- just watch the Olympic sprints. Is is really a shocker that the speed based positions - WR, RB, DB are dominated by the fastest race?

Exceptions to every stereotype, yeah we know.

 

[jesse1111]

Outside of Mcnabb and if you replace DE with CB I would say Both.

 

[jesse1111]

Where the Hell is Fisher DeBerry at? He can chime in on this.

 

[lander]

there are good white DEs, RBs and CBs, not so much.

Name the last white player to start at RB (excluding full backs, of which Alstott is one).

Hoover and Goings started for a bit, no?

 

[gynecologist]

lander I meant to put DB instead of DE.. My bad, again it's because I'm white.

 

[blueedwards]

I didn't.. But since we're on the subject, how many great black QB's have their been in the history of the NFL?

about the same as whites...if you start in the mid-1980's and look at it as a percentage of the total qbs starting in the nfl.

 

[gynecologist]

Outside of Mcnabb and if you replace DE with CB I would say Both.

McNabb is solid. Warren Moon was very good. After that I can't think of any very good black QBs..

Not being racist, just being truthful. Can't think of good white RBs or DBs either..

 

[gynecologist]

about the same as whites...if you start in the mid-1980's and look at it as a percentage of the total qbs starting in the nfl.

Marino,Elway,Favre,Manning,Brady,Montana,Young,Kelly,Aikman... :ughhh:

 

[blueedwards]

Marino,Elway,Favre,Manning,Brady,Montana,Young,Kelly,Aikman... :ughhh:

ok, let say warren moon is the only great black qb to play the game and all nine of the guys you listed are the great white qb's since 1980. here is the math:

white - 9/300 = 3.0%
black - 1/30 = 3.3%

therefore, there are more great black qb's as a percentage.

 

[TTinCO]

Where the Hell is Fisher DeBerry at? He can chime in on this.

:missingte Absolutely classic quote. I love it when these old men don't give a shit any more & lay it out like it really is.

 

[fhmesq44]

hoover is a fullback and goings is black, at least half black. All the other answers have been incorrect. Answer is Brock Forsey.

Sehorn was the last white CB, there are a number of safeties, Lynch being the best. Schweigart and Archuleta come to mind as well. Sure there are more but off the top of my head I can't think of any.

McNair has had a pretty damn good career and has always been a winner, same with McNabb. Culpepper was good until he just fell apart. Cunningham had a good career.

 

[jesse1111]

Sehorn got a lot of respect from me. Dude had to be fast as a white corner in the NFL.

 

[royboy_3831]

tiki barber

A+

 

[royboy_3831]

McNabb is solid. Warren Moon was very good. After that I can't think of any very good black QBs..

Being such a big Trojan fan I thought you might have more respect for Vince Young. :thumbsup:


Yeah I know he hasn't proven himself as great qb in the NFL yet, but I think he will in time, guy is a winner.

 

[MrJ]

Stupid argument since it's got more to do with culture than race. Take a look at sports outside America.

 

[Railbird]

Vince Young much better than Donovan bounce pass Mcnabb

 

[levistep]

Whoever answered neither is living in some fucking fantasy world.

 

[RebuyGuy]

:scared1: