Which NFC North Team has the Better QB ?

[D2bets]

Favre is the most overrated QB of all time. 310 fricken INT's and 128 fumbles. Listen, he was good (notice WAS), but not among the top 5 maybe not even top 20 ever. I guess if you rate lonegivty high then he moves up but he is not in the class of the best in anyone's lifetime.

 

[FairWarning]

Favre is the most overrated QB of all time. 310 fricken INT's and 128 fumbles. Listen, he was good (notice WAS), but not among the top 5 maybe not even top 20 ever. I guess if you rate lonegivty high then he moves up but he is not in the class of the best in anyone's lifetime.

Probably a top-5 for competitiveness, but you are correct about the rest.

 

[barman]

By the way, FAVRE is ABSOLUTELY AWESOME........GREATEST EVER IN MY LIFETIME.

Being as you and I are same age, I'm calling this the wackiest post you've ever written during my almost five years as an RxForum reader

 

[barman]

packers and it isnt close

Reason #461 why ST is my Life Role Model

 

[RobFunk]

I have had a decent look at these guys in August and I have to say Rodgers at this point. But Cutler is going to be great for Chicago.

 

[MinnesotaEconMajor]

Favre is the most overrated QB of all time. 310 fricken INT's and 128 fumbles. Listen, he was good (notice WAS), but not among the top 5 maybe not even top 20 ever. I guess if you rate lonegivty high then he moves up but he is not in the class of the best in anyone's lifetime.

Also gotta remember the guy played with some pretty crappy to mediocre supporting casts. (<)<

 

[REDEYE]

Can't quote everyone is this thread , but could very easily do that with these ridiculous posts. Has Rodgers even had a 4th qtr comeback in his short history ? What has he done yet ? How does his career accomplishments warrant any discussion as best qb in Division !! Favre most overrated QB of all time ?? How can you be the most overrated QB when your the only one who has ever had 3 MVP'S plus a Super Bowl. I suppose Dan Marino was head and shoulders above the best ever too, right ? Thats who is the most overrated QB of all time !! Favre is a top 5 of all time, but I would rank him slightly behind Cutler at this stage. Rodgers can get into the conversation when he leads the team to a winning record or a playoff win, not just what he might do some day.