What team would win? The Jets with Peyton Manning or the Broncos with Geno Smith?

[OneZero]

put those guys on the jets and no one even knows their names

I disagree greatly. Decker and D.Thomas were well known and put up pretty decent numbers with Tim Tebow.

 

[MikeB]

Do the coaches stay with the team or do they go with the players?

 

[Willie99]

Broncos

1) Rex Ryan

2) team over misfits

 

[The Guesser]

put payton on the jets and you would be telling me their te was an all pro as well as Decker

We already saw this scenario played out. Payton with Colts = 11+ wins every year with a crap team. When Payton was out, and Geno level QB's played, they get the #1 draft choice. Then they get a stud QB again, and they win again instantly. There is no doubt the Jets would be a playoff team with Peyton, and Denver would struggle mightily with Geno.

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

Jets. Peyton makes average look great. Geno would suck no matter who he had around him. Geno, Vick, and Taj Boyd...I dont care who you have on your roster when those are you quarterbacks, you do not have a chance to win unless your defense can hold every team to 6 points every week, then you have a chance in OT.

 

[Akillies]

Thomas made his Jacksonville debut in Week 5, but he has only 13 catches in four games and is averaging 8.9 yards per reception with one touchdown. It's evident he's not as effective with Bortles targeting him as he was with Peyton Manning.

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

Manning alone could take any team and put them in playoffs. And thAt is today