Best of the good Qb's.Farves, Marinos etc. 1st ballot hall of famer. Played in air controlled domes stadium 80% of his career in a division with Houston, Jacksonville, Tennesse, whos resume includes 1 Super Bowl and handful of playoff games between them in their history.
In a nutshell,was underachiever as a playoff QB .
The notion that he had a poor team around him is lunacy. Going 14-2 several times then going one and done and spitting the bit when your team needs you the most is what makes him a good QB not a great one.
6 TD's against Jacksonville in October at home dosen't make for great QBs.. Driving your team for two TD's in the 4th quarter down by ten in a Super Bowl against the best defense in at least 15 years is greatness.
Please try to understand the distinction.