Off-color Murray struggles past Lorenzi.
WHAT HAPPENED: Eleven years ago, Andy Murray beat Paolo Lorenzi in two easy sets in the second round of US Open qualifying. While the outcome was the same here Saturday, the method was vastly different, with an out-of-sorts Murray eventually overcoming the 34-year-old Italian, 7-6(4), 5-7, 6-2, 6-3, to reach the fourth round of the US Open.
After 22 attempts, this was Lorenzi’s first showing in the third round of a Grand Slam, and stages don’t come much grander than this one. If the Italian did stop for a moment to take in the magnitude of the occasion, he might have appreciated the music that was pumped around Arthur Ashe Stadium during the warm up. The song in question was Lukas Graham’s "7 years" a tune about growing old and achieving before it’s too late, and the Italian veteran certainly made the most of this opportunity of a lifetime.
Few on the tour are capable of going toe-to-toe with Murray in extended rallies, but Lorenzi soon proved himself quite adept at doing so, with his topspin forehand preventing the world No. 2 from gaining any real rhythm. Murray, by contrast, was playing his weakest tennis of the tournament so far, and at 4-4 the Italian stole in to secure a previously unthinkable break. Murray needed to wake up, and he told himself as much during the changeover as Lorenzi prepared to serve for the opener.
Serving for a set can do strange things to the mind, though. The Italian faltered badly, and Murray quickly moved into a 6-5 lead. Lorenzi rallied to force a tiebreak, but the world No. 2 was just about strong enough to take the opener, sealing it with a dismissive forehand return that undoubtedly contained a lot of frustration at how the first set had gone.
Murray seemed certain to pull away after breaking at the first time of asking in the second set, but once again his level plummeted. Lorenzi immediately broke back to love, and Murray was now starting to look decidedly lethargic – intriguingly, a shirt change after the first set had revealed a small amount of taping on his left shoulder. Lorenzi sealed a second break courtesy of a Murray double fault, and although he once again failed to serve it out at 5-3 – Murray broke back after winning a 42-shot rally – Lorenzi broke once more to become the first man to take a set off the Brit this week.
By this point Lorenzi was doing a remarkably accurate impression of David Ferrer. Having only hit four winners in the second set, the Italian was earning points through his relentless running, making a mockery of his age and the fact he played for five hours against Gilles Simon on Thursday. Nevertheless, the third set started in the same fashion as the second, with a Murray break. This time, though, the Olympic gold medalist backed it up, and finally started to exert his authority on the match.
The key to that might have been a restringing of Murray's racquets. His coach Jamie Delgado could be seen courtside at one point, and Murray revealed after the match that he had changed the tension of his racquet. It made a difference. Once again, Murray started the fourth set with a break of serve, and just about managed to keep the indefatigable Lorenzi at bay to seal his passage into the fourth round.
WHAT IT MEANS: First, the good news. Murray became the third British player to reach the fourth round here, which is the first time that’s happened since 1985. Actually, that’s about it for good news.
We know Murray will raise his level when the going gets tough, but for the first two sets Murray arguably played as badly as he has at any point in a significant tournament this year – he finished the match with 63 unforced errors and only had a 53 percent success rate on his first serve.
While that level was still high enough to just about see off Lorenzi, this was nothing less than a grind. The world No. 2 is one of the fittest players on the tour, but tennis is a game of the finest margins, and the 3 hours and 17 minutes he spent on court here Saturday could take their toll later on in the tournament – particularly as Novak Djokovic has only played six games since the first round.
After blowing Lukas Rosol away in the first round, Murray looked a little out of sorts against Marcel Granollers, and decidedly off-color for the majority of this match. The Scot hasn’t been past the fourth round of the US Open since 2014, and his next opponent Grigor Dimitrov is firmly in the middle of a late-season resurgence. The Bulgarian famously beat Murray in the quarterfinals of Wimbledon 2014, and will pose a real test.
Credit must go to Lorenzi, though. Not many players look like they have more stamina than Murray, but the Italian appears to be one of them. This was a performance that demonstrated it’s never too late to make a breakthrough, and even if he never again replicates his efforts here, he can be extremely proud.
THE QUESTION: Can Andy Murray recover his best form in time for his fourth-round meeting with Grigor Dimitrov?