To me its pretty cut and dry on #1 and #2. Jack dominated a era over HOF players like Watson, Trevino, Palmer, Ballesteros, Faldo, Norman, and Player. Hell even Crenshaw, Couples, Floyd, and Miller are alot better then most players today.....Tiger won his 14 majors in a down era and only Mickelson of his rivals is a HOF. Els damage came mostly before Tiger. Now if you want to get into this exchange of the players being better now, then, we have to downsize Joe Montana, Terry Bradshaw, Walter Payton in the NFL and similar players in all sports. The problem with your argument with the players being better now then back when Jack was playing, is you have nothing to base it on. Hitting it 25 -40 yards farther off the tee because of better technology is not a good reason why the players in Jack's era aren't as good....or that they might be in better shape. The guys I mentioned above were mentally tough, winners, and wanted to win. I don't see that in the last 15 years outside of Tiger and occasionally Phil.