fro11 said:being a philly fan and watching every game since mcnabb has been there.. i wonder what kind of highlight cuts these announcers get. mcnabb often throws ball in the dirt, throws laser beams at player 5 yrds away that cant be caught and normally has NO touch on the ball. he is overrated..
funny thing is him and andy reid are butt brothers, they will go down together, reid would never pull donovan or blame him for losing a game. they will go down together..
jakethompson said:1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Carson Palmer
4. Donovan McNabb
5. Drew Brees
It's a sad state for NFL QBs when Drew Brees makes my top five list.
royboy_3831 said:He was very productive in San Diego as well, you're not giving the guy enough credit.
his top 5 qb's were in this order:
1. peyton manning
2. tom brady
3. philip rivers
4. *TONY ROMO*
5. *VINCE YOUNG*
* -YOU HAVE TO BE KIDDIN ME
THE SAINTS CANT GET ANY LOVE BECAUSE DREW BREES IS DEF TOP 3!
Vince Young and Phillip Rivers over Carson Palmer, Drew Breese and Donavon McNabb!!!
This is the worst top 5 I have ever seen.