McNabb gets results with nothing - not one good receiver and not one above average receiver - average at best running game - and and an overated O line - imagine if he had the luxury of throwing a jump ball to Owens or Moss - he's the best QB in the league - Brady is the most underated QB in the league.
Peyton Manning is a complete reject, no suprise the guy got stuck at the 1 yard line yesterday. If Peyton was on a diffrent team that didnt have a great runningback, great wr, decent Oline and a tremendous TE on turf, he would rarely get a first down, if the guys isnt getting sacked he is throwing a pick.
Com'on
1. McNair
2. Manning
3. Farve
Farve is a legend and I am so glad to see this guy play, I never got to see Montana at his prime so I get to see Farve. But he has fell off a bit.
Manning is good but I think that he has players that are more offensively talented then McNair. Every time I see Manning throwing a touchdown pass his players are in perfect stride running past their defenders. When I watch McNair his receivers remind me of those players in Philly, the pass has to be right on because they don't get the kind of space that Mannings guys does. Plus McNair is mobile.
I know Hasselback and Kitna are playing well but lets wait till he plays like this consistently for a couple more years.
And I say this being a MCNABB fan and I got the jersey to prove it. McNabb is in the top seven for now until we can get a great receiver.
1. McNair
2. Manning
3. Farve
Farve is a legend and I am so glad to see this guy play, I never got to see Montana at his prime so I get to see Farve. But he has fell off a bit.
Manning is good but I think that he has players that are more offensively talented then McNair. Every time I see Manning throwing a touchdown pass his players are in perfect stride running past their defenders. When I watch McNair his receivers remind me of those players in Philly, the pass has to be right on because they don't get the kind of space that Mannings guys does. Plus McNair is mobile.
I know Hasselback and Kitna are playing well but lets wait till he plays like this consistently for a couple more years.
And I say this being a MCNABB fan and I got the jersey to prove it. McNabb is in the top seven for now until we can get a great receiver.
Hey Seymour
Saw your post and I totally agree with your opinion about McNabb and Brady. Being in Toronto there are a annoyingly large number of Bills fans who are against QBs in the AFC east (Brady).
With McNabb I tell them give him a solid offensive line, a consistent RB and a 1 WR (No not Thrash) and then we will see. Imagine him with an offense like Greenbay or the Colts. That would be something.
Saw your post and I totally agree with your opinion about McNabb and Brady. Being in Toronto there are a annoyingly large number of Bills fans who are against QBs in the AFC east (Brady).
With McNabb I tell them give him a solid offensive line, a consistent RB and a 1 WR (No not Thrash) and then we will see. Imagine him with an offense like Greenbay or the Colts. That would be something.
The guy is good and he steps up when needed:
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Houston Texans at 02:50
1-10-HOU20 (2:50) D.Carr pass to D.Armstrong to HST 38 for 18 yards (L.Schulters).
1-10-HOU38 (2:32) D.Carr pass to A.Johnson to TEN 20 for 42 yards (A.Dyson). (30 yards after catch.)
1-10-TEN20 (2:00) D.Davis right end pushed ob at TEN 5 for 15 yards (P.Sirmon).
1-5-TEN5 (1:53) D.Davis left end for 5 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
K.Brown extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Pittman, Holder-C.Stanley.
TEN 20 HOU 24, Plays: 4 Yards: 80 Possession: 1:02.
Houston Texans at 01:48
K.Brown kicks 66 yards from HST 30 to TEN 4. J.McCareins to TEN 25 for 21 yards (K.Wright).
Tennessee Titans at 01:42
1-10-TEN25 (1:42) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass incomplete to D.Mason.
2-10-TEN25 (1:35) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to D.Bennett to TEN 45 for 20 yards (M.McCree, D.Faggins).
1-10-TEN45 (1:06) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to C.Brown to HST 47 for 8 yards (D.Faggins).
2-2-HOU47
54) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to D.Bennett to HST 23 for 24 yards (E.Brown). (7 yards after catch.)
1-10-HOU2337) S.McNair spiked the ball to stop the clock.
2-10-HOU2336) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass incomplete to J.McCareins. TEN McCareins caught the ball out of bounds.
3-10-HOU2329) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass incomplete to J.McCareins (D.Faggins).
4-10-HOU2324) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to D.Bennett for 23 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
G.Anderson extra point is GOOD, Center-T.Ackerman, Holder-C.Hentrich.<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Credit must be given where credit is due. Not the fanciest QB, but he manages to get the job done.
Almost forgot:
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Titans quarterback Steve McNair started Sunday against Houston despite a cracked bone spur in his left ankle, hoping to help Tennessee clinch a playoff spot<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Houston Texans at 02:50
1-10-HOU20 (2:50) D.Carr pass to D.Armstrong to HST 38 for 18 yards (L.Schulters).
1-10-HOU38 (2:32) D.Carr pass to A.Johnson to TEN 20 for 42 yards (A.Dyson). (30 yards after catch.)
1-10-TEN20 (2:00) D.Davis right end pushed ob at TEN 5 for 15 yards (P.Sirmon).
1-5-TEN5 (1:53) D.Davis left end for 5 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
K.Brown extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Pittman, Holder-C.Stanley.
TEN 20 HOU 24, Plays: 4 Yards: 80 Possession: 1:02.
Houston Texans at 01:48
K.Brown kicks 66 yards from HST 30 to TEN 4. J.McCareins to TEN 25 for 21 yards (K.Wright).
Tennessee Titans at 01:42
1-10-TEN25 (1:42) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass incomplete to D.Mason.
2-10-TEN25 (1:35) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to D.Bennett to TEN 45 for 20 yards (M.McCree, D.Faggins).
1-10-TEN45 (1:06) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to C.Brown to HST 47 for 8 yards (D.Faggins).
2-2-HOU47
54) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to D.Bennett to HST 23 for 24 yards (E.Brown). (7 yards after catch.) 1-10-HOU23
37) S.McNair spiked the ball to stop the clock. 2-10-HOU23
36) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass incomplete to J.McCareins. TEN McCareins caught the ball out of bounds. 3-10-HOU23
29) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass incomplete to J.McCareins (D.Faggins). 4-10-HOU23
24) (Shotgun) S.McNair pass to D.Bennett for 23 yards, TOUCHDOWN. G.Anderson extra point is GOOD, Center-T.Ackerman, Holder-C.Hentrich.<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Credit must be given where credit is due. Not the fanciest QB, but he manages to get the job done.
Almost forgot:
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Titans quarterback Steve McNair started Sunday against Houston despite a cracked bone spur in his left ankle, hoping to help Tennessee clinch a playoff spot<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Only fair to also point out that McNair has not been physically able to practice for two weeks. Was not even able to participate in the walkthrough Saturday.
Probably only one or two quarterbacks in the league tough enough to go under these circumstances. Manning is a good quarterback. When he wins 1 playoff game, I will be willing to consider him amongst the elite.
VVV
Probably only one or two quarterbacks in the league tough enough to go under these circumstances. Manning is a good quarterback. When he wins 1 playoff game, I will be willing to consider him amongst the elite.
VVV
