Dr. Bob :
I have finalized the math and written up the first 3 of Saturday's Bowl games and have just one lean (on Colorado State). I am going to get a few hours of sleep but I'll work on the other two Saturday Bowl games and hopefully have those to you by early afternoon. I won't have a Best Bet on either of those games either and I'm not even sure which way I lean yet. The next batch of Best Bets will be released on Monday or Tuesday.
College Football Analysis by Dr. Bob
Note: The lines quoted are the consensus line at the time each game was released to my subscribers on my Best Bets release page. The lines have moved so make sure to pay attention to the line constraints at the end of each analysis for the current rating of each game.
I’ve released 3 Best Bets so far:
Miami-Florida (-1.5) 3-Stars at -2.5 or less, 2-Stars at -3.
Boise State (+4) 2-Stars at +3 or more.
UNDER (60.5) Illinois-LA Tech 1-Star UNDER 59 or higher
Nevada (-1) 32 UL LAFAYETTE 30
Sat Dec-20-2014 at 08:00 AM Pacific Rotation: 201 Over/Under 61.0
Louisiana Lafayette is representing the Sun Belt Conference in the New Orleans bowl for the 4th consecutive year and the Ragin’ Cajuns have made the mostly supportive fans happy with 3 consecutive wins (and spread wins). UL Lafayette certainly could make it 4 for 4 in a battle of two teams that are pretty evenly matched from the line of scrimmage and both have veteran senior quarterbacks at the helm. However, Nevada has the edge in special teams and that extra field position could be the difference in the close game.
Nevada’s offense is led by 4 year starting quarterback Cody Fajardo, who has easily had his worst season of an otherwise very good collegiate career. Fajardo has been an above average quarterback the last 3 seasons but this season he averaged just 5.6 yards per pass play while facing teams that would allow 6.5 yppp to an average quarterback. Fajardo also threw 11 interceptions, which isn’t horrible, but it’s a lot for a guy that had thrown an average of just 6 interceptions over the first 3 years of his career. Fajardo shouldn’t have any interception issues against a UL Lafayette defense that allows 66% completions and picked off just 7 passes on 414 opponent’s pass attempts during the regular season. The Ragin’ Cajuns allowed 7.3 yards per pass play this season to quarterbacks that would combine to average 5.7 yppp against an average quarterback and that bad number is despite a better than average pass rush (2.5 sacks per game). Fajardo is an elusive quarterback that doesn’t get sacked often and he should post pretty good aerial numbers in this game while also leading a good ground attack (223 yards at 5.4 yards per rushing play against teams that would allow 5.0 yprp to an average team) that should have no trouble gaining yards against a sub-par ULL defensive front that allowed 5.3 yprp this season to teams that would combine to average just 4.6 yprp against an average defensive team. Overall, Nevada’s offense rates at 0.3 yards per play worse than average while Lafayette’s defense is 1.1 yppl worse than average. Nevada is projected to gain 433 yards at 6.4 yppl in this game (with half a normal home field advantage applied in favor of ULL).
UL Lafayette’s veteran quarterback Terrance Broadway is in his third and final season leading the Ragin’ Cajuns and he also had his worst season by far after two very good campaigns after transferring from Houston. Broadway averaged over 9 yards per pass attempt in each of the last two seasons but that average dipped to 6.7 ypa and he averaged only 5.8 yards per pass play (which includes sacks) against FBS teams that would allow 6.3 yppp to an average quarterback. Not having the services of top WR Jamal Robinson most of the season certain affected Broadway, as Robinson averaged 9.8 yards per pass thrown to him last season (862 yards on 88 targets) and he averaged 12.4 yards on the 21 passes that Broadway threw to him (he caught 15 of them) this season while the other wide receivers combined to average just 7.0 yards per pass attempt. UL Lafayette’s very good rushing attack (239 yards at 6.0 yprp against teams that would allow 5.3 yprp) helped make up for the less efficient pass attack and overall the Ragin’ Cajuns’ attack rates at 0.1 yards per play better than average. That unit is projected to rack up 433 yards at 6.3 yppl against a sub-par Nevada defense that is 0.5 yppl worse than average (6.0 yppl allowed to teams that would combine to average 5.5 yppl against an average team) and is equally bad against the run and pass.
Both teams should move the ball well and in fact are each projected to gain 433 yards by my model. Nevada has an edge in special teams and is a bit less likely to turn the ball over and overall the math favors the Wolf Pack by 3 ½ points with Lafayette receiving half a standard home field advantage for playing this game in nearby New Orleans. The Ragin Cajun’s certainly have taken advantage of the home cooking the last 3 years so perhaps a full home field edge is justified, in which case I get Nevada by 2 points (with a total of 61 ½ points). I have no opinion on the side or the total in this game.
Utah State (-10) 28 Texas El Paso 17
Sat Dec-20-2014 at 11:20 AM Pacific Rotation: 204 Over/Under 46.0
UTEP applies to a 54-8-2 ATS big underdog bowl situation but that situation works because the big favorite usually isn’t that interested in a minor bowl game against an inferior opponents. That doesn’t appear to be the case here, as Utah State head coach Matt Wells and his senior leaders have said that they’re hungry for a win to secure their 10th win and atone for what they thought was a down season and to atone for the season ending 19-50 loss at Boise State. If Utah State plays their normal game then the Aggies should win by double-digits.
Utah State started the season slowly with veteran quarterback Chuckie Keeton struggling but the offense perked up when Keeton was injured and Darell Garretson took over behind center. I had a Best Bet on Utah State in Garretson’s first start against BYU and the Aggies started a run of 3 straight spread wins with Garretson at the helm with a 35-20 win as a 21 point dog to BYU. Injuries to Garretson and 3rd string quarterback Craig Harrison led to freshman Kent Myers burning his redshirt and starting the final 5 games of the regular season. Myers is an accurate passer (69% completions) and a very good runner (299 yards on just 32 runs) and the Aggies offense has also received a boost by running more fly sweeps with dangerous wide receiver JoJo Natson, who averaged 10.2 yards on his 45 runs this season and ran 17 times in the last 4 games. Myers mostly settles for short passes to help move the chains and the combination of accurate passing and an enhanced rushing attack has led to Utah State being 0.8 yards per play better than average offensively in Myers’ 5 starts, which is better than their +0.1 yppl season rating. That attack is projected to gain 378 yards at 7.2 yppl in this game against a horrible UTEP defense that has given up 6.4 yards per play this season to teams that would combine to average only 5.4 yppl against an average defensive team. UTEP doesn’t defend the run well (5.8 yprp allowed to teams that would combine to average 5.0 yprp against an average team) and the Miners take a lot of chances in their secondary, which leads a good percentage of interceptions but also to a lot of big pass plays (15.0 yards per completion allowed).
UTEP isn’t quite as bad offensively but the Miners are 0.7 yppl worse than average on the attack side of the ball (5.5 yppl against teams that would allow 6.2 yppl to an average team) and were limited to just 3.4 yppl in their two games against better than average defensive teams Kansas State and Louisiana Tech. Utah State’s defense has allowed just 4.8 yppl and 20.8 points per game this season (against teams that would average 5.3 yppl and 25.5 points against an average defensive team) and the Aggies should have no trouble containing UTEP’s poor attack. In fact, the math projects only 295 yards at 4.5 yppl for the Miners in this game.
Utah State has a huge edge from a yards per play perspective, as they are projected to average 7.2 yppl to UTEP’s 4.5 yppl. However, Utah State is a big play offense and UTEP’s defense gives up big plays, which should mean that the Aggies run far fewer plays. That’s built into the model, which projects UTEP with a +13 play differential in this game, but overall the Aggies have a huge edge from the line of scrimmage and a solid edge in special teams. Neither quarterback throws interceptions, as Myers had just 2 in 5-plus games and UTEP’s Jameill Showers threw just 5 interceptions in 12 regular season games. That math would have favored Utah State by 12 points using season stats but the Aggies are better offensively with Myers than they are overall this season and the math model calls for a 14 points win (and 45 ½ total points). I do think Utah State will avoid a letdown that plagues a lot of big favorites in minor bowl games and that expected letdown is already priced into the spread, which has come down from an opening number of 11 ½ points. However, I simply will not recommend going against a 54-8-2 ATS bowl situation that favors UTEP so I have no opinion on the side or the total in this game.
Colorado State (+3) 29 Utah 28
Sat Dec-20-2014 at 12:30 PM Pacific Rotation: 206 Over/Under 57.5
Colorado State’s breakout 10-2 season led to the loss of their head coach, Jim McElwain, who has left the program to begin his new job at Florida. Despite the loss of their head coach the Rams’ players still seem to be fired up for the chance to beat a Pac 12 team for a second straight year in a bowl game. Offensive coordinator Dave Baldwin will lead CSU to Las Vegas for this game against Utah, who should also be ready to play after missing out on a bowl game the last two seasons. However, if Colorado State is indeed not distracted by the loss of their head coach (there isn’t a trend one way or the other regarding interim coaches in bowl games) then the Rams have a good shot at an upset against a Utes’ squad that plays a lot of close games (5-2 in games decided by 7 points or less this season).
Utah isn’t that impressive from the line of scrimmage, as the Utes have been 0.4 yards per play worse than average offensively (-0.3 yppl with quarterback Travis Wilson at the helm) while their defense has been 0.3 yppl better than average (5.6 yppl allowed to teams that would combine to average 5.9 yppl against an average team). Utah’s strength is having the best special teams in the nation and those units made a difference in a few games this season. However, overall the Utes are certainly not as good as they’re top 25 ranking and 8-4 record, as they could just as easily be 6-6 had they been 3-4 in close games rather than 5-2.
Colorado State has better overall numbers from the line of scrimmage, as the Rams were 1.3 yppl better than average offensively and 0.3 yppl worse than average defensively. However, quarterback Garrett Grayson racked up really big aerial numbers against bad defensive teams while playing relatively much worse against mediocre and better than average defensive teams. While Grayson was 2.1 yards per pass play better than average overall (8.9 yppp against teams that would allow 6.8 yppp to an average quarterback), he was just 0.8 yppp better than average against the 7 mediocre or better than average pass defenses that he faced (Colorado, Boise State, Boston College, Nevada, Utah State, San Jose State, and Air Force) – averaging 6.8 yppp against teams that would allow 5.9 yppp to an average QB. Utah is 0.5 yppp better than average defending the pass (5.9 yppp allowed to quarterbacks that would average 6.4 yppp) and the Utes should do a decent job of containing Grayson and All-American WR Rashard Higgins. Colorado State’s rushing attack, led by former Alabama RB Dee Hart (1254 yards at 6.7 ypr), should have better than average success against a Utah defense that has been better than average defending the run for the season but has struggled against the run in their last 5 games (6.3 yards per rushing play allowed to teams that would combine to average 5.5 yprp against an average team). I’m not sure why Utah suddenly began to have trouble defending the run at the end of the season after being so good against the run through week 9 (4.1 yprp allowed to teams that would average 5.2 yprp against an average team). I’ll assume the Utes will play run defense at their season average but it’s certainly plausible that they’ll continue to struggle in that regard, especially with LB Gionni Paul out. Paul was #2 on the Utes’ in tackles before missing the final two games of the regular season and the defense struggled without him.
The math model projects Colorado State with an advantage from the line of scrimmage (423 yards at 6.2 yppl to 412 yards at 5.7 yppl for Utah) but Utah has a sizeable edge in special teams and that math favors Utah by 1 ½ points overall (and 58 total points). I’d get Utah by 3 ½ points (and 56 total points) if Grayson’s trend of playing relatively much worse against mediocre and good pass defenses continues but the line is at least fair if that is the case. The reason for liking Colorado State is a 40-7-3 ATS bowl situation that applies to Utah and a 7-34-1 ATS situation that applies to Utah. The record is 8-0-1 ATS when those situations favors the same team and I’ll lean with Colorado State plus the points and I have no opinion on the total.
*UNDER (60 ½) – Louisiana Tech (-6) 27 Illinois 24