Fezzik, interesting reply. I happen to completely agree as I would pay a fair amount of money to someone who could hit 55% percent year after year, god only knows what I would pay for 60% winners year after year. If people do not understand this, they are either deluding themselves (want's post says it quite well) or they have not done sports investing long enough to know how hard it is to crank out 55% year after year (let alone 60%, which, save for a random gambling savant or two, is not attainable over a statistically relevant sample of time - i am talking years).
As for the mention of "MIller" beer, I am assuming you are speaking of JR Miller. I personally tracked every single play from Mr Miller via his website (which I will not list here for obvious reasons) for one full calendar year, from 6/17/03 - 6/17/04. Below are the results, and they are not pretty. I have no reason to lie or slam JR, I am sure he would attest to these results if he was asked. He does at least post every single play 5 mins after the game starts:
MLB - total picks 921, 419 W, 489 L, 13 ties, 46.15%, and a loss of 20.65 units
NFL - total picks 231, 113 W, 113 L, 5 ties, 50%, and a loss of 4.86 units
NBA - total picks 493, 228 W, 257 L, 8 ties, 47.01% and a loss of 38.18 units
NHL - total picks 356, 149 W, 169 L, 38 ties, 46.86% and a loss of 1.14 units
Arena - total picks 1, 1 W, 0 L, 0 ties, 100%, and a gain of .96 units
College - total picks 4, 2 W, 2 L, 0 ties, 50%, and a loss of .14 units
Totals - total picks 2006, 912 W, 1030 L, 64 ties, and a loss of 64.01 total units.
Thats a whopping 64% of your bankroll gone in one year.
If you had certain proof of someone who could hit 60% over a span of 10 years consistently, I would be right behind Fezzik in the line of people with their checkbooks open willing to pay almost whatever was necessary to get access to that information.