Is Big Ben a top 5 QB in this era?

[Knightrofins]

During my era, here's my list:

1) Brady
2) Manning
3) Brees
4) Rodgers
5) Favre

Which years does "your era" consist of?

I still think Marino, Montana, and Elway are some of the best qb's ever and would have DOMINATED in this era.

I also put Rivers in front of Big Ben. Ben has always had STUD receivers and better players around him. Ben will be a first ballot HOF but not a top 5 qb

 

[Enfuego]

Which years does "your era" consist of?

I still think Marino, Montana, and Elway are some of the best qb's ever and would have DOMINATED in this era.

I also put Rivers in front of Big Ben. Ben has always had STUD receivers and better players around him. Ben will be a first ballot HOF but not a top 5 qb

I'm defining the era as the time after Marino, Elway, Montana etc.

 

[ANOTHERDAY]

Which years does "your era" consist of?

I still think Marino, Montana, and Elway are some of the best qb's ever and would have DOMINATED in this era.

I also put Rivers in front of Big Ben. Ben has always had STUD receivers and better players around him. Ben will be a first ballot HOF but not a top 5 qb

I agree with Marino, Elway, and Montana fully

Those guys could have played in any era with no issues. I personally believe Brady would not even be mentioned if he played in the 80's or 90's. Brady was only suited for 2000's era, not back in the day

 

[Mr_Mark]

He is somewhere in the 5-7 spot.
Right below Tebow