Dave Malinsky
Cleveland Indians @ New York Yankees
PICK: Cleveland Indians
We do not have to get too complex with this one – with Alex Rodriguez sidelined and some problems with the middle relief corps once again, the Yankees have only played .500 baseball through their first 10 games. That just is not good enough to merit being anywhere near this price range, especially with the absence of Xavier Nady and Hideki Matsui compounding the lineup woes.
Mariano Rivera has yet to be scored on this season, but the Yankee bullpen has an ERA of 6.52, which tells you all you need to know about how the rest of the group has performed. With Joba Chamberlain only working 69.2 innings in 12 starts LY, and not ready for more than six innings right now (only 19.2 frames in six spring training appearances, then six innings vs. Kansas City in his only work since then), it is difficult to build a bridge from him to Rivera, assuming Chamberlain has anything special to begin with – of the 18 batters that he retired vs. the Royals nine came on fly balls, and now he faces a lineup with the punch to do so much more when they make contact, especially now that Victor Martinez has regained the power that was missing LY.
Anthony Reyes has worked to a 3-1/2.45 tune since joining the Cleveland rotation, allowing only 34 hits in 40.1 innings in that span. While the tutelage of Dave Duncan and Tony LaRussa has worked with so many pitchers it was simply a bad fit in St. Louis for Reyes, and his career is being turned around by having the freedom to use his natural stuff, instead of being turned more into a finesse/control type. He brings us more than enough to back in this price range, and yesterday’s late-game breakout also means that Kerry Wood got the day off, leaving him fresh to close this one out.