The shove call was postflop though...
If you all reconstruct the pot using the numbers then by the time the dude shoved after flop , I dont see what other choice you have....now you are getting 3 to 1 .
BB said the post was over 1k, so that mean it went something like this preflop
....... 2/5 raise to 25 , call, call, call, reraise to 450,,,,fold fold fold call
The way I see it is if you are gonna make such a big call preflop then when the flop comes dry like that you certainly cant fold by that point.