Donovan Mcnabb is a terrible QB.

[C-Gold]

Campbell has the same thing going this year, that Garrard had last year. Screens, dinks, dunks, a top running game and defense.

Look at Garrard today when his team was losing. He isn't that same "turnover free" quarterback. He sucks. These bums can't play QB, but game manager.

Leftwhich, Garrard and Campbell are all the same guy.

 

[krk1030]

Manning, Eli
Manning, Peyton
Brady
Drew Brees
Tony Romo
Jason Campbell
Kurt Warner
Aaron Rodgers.......List goes on and on:nohead:

You have to be kidding.

 

[$how$toppa]

Can't believe they couldn't punch that in. Got a feeling they're gonna give up a TD and win by 6.

 

[Selectrick]

Never was any good. Never will be and will never win a SB.

Passed for 270 yds. in 3 quarters...........terrible!!

 

[Jstack34]

C-Gold, do you even watch the games? The throws Campbell has been making are great, watch the throws he makes in the Arizona and New Orleans game--just hating because hes black has been a theme of yours---Krx-who do you have a problem with on that list? Mcnabb throws it at peoples feet or over their head

 

[whalewager]

yep..Praise the Lord...now if they can just close it out

 

[krk1030]

C-Gold, do you even watch the games? The throws Campbell has been making are great, watch the throws he makes in the Arizona and New Orleans game--just hating because hes black has been a theme of yours---Krx-who do you have a problem with on that list? Mcnabb throws it at peoples feet or over their head

Well i wont even get into how wrong you are about many of the QB's.

But simply you cant have it both ways. Cambpell has had half of a good season so if you base it only on this season..mcnabb > Brady, and manning

 

[C-Gold]

C-Gold, do you even watch the games? The throws Campbell has been making are great, watch the throws he makes in the Arizona and New Orleans game--just hating because hes black has been a theme of yours---Krx-who do you have a problem with on that list? Mcnabb throws it at peoples feet or over their head

Jason Campbell isn't 1/8th as good as Mcnabb. Mcnabb can read a defense and calls audibles.

Campbell = Byron Leftwhich, and he is trash.


I watch every single NFC east game, and Campbell doesn't impress me at all. He holds onto the ball fooooorrrreeevvverrr and throws check downs and screens. He isn't even a quarterback.

 

[C-Gold]

Well i wont even get into how wrong you are about many of the QB's.

But simply you cant have it both ways. Cambpell has had half of a good season so if you base it only on this season..mcnabb > Brady, and manning

Mcnabb is better than Manning? Has Donovan won any titles in his life? Little league, HS, college, or the pros? Look, he's a top 5 qb, but to compare him to manning is ignorant.

 

[Jstack34]

Being a better QB isnt based on winning titles-Im talking about right now, who is a better QB-Mcnabb and Campbell went head to head in a game if i recall, Mcnabbs team was up 14-0 because of a kick return and westbrook and then went on to do nothing. Campbell on the other hand lead his team back throughout the game---Mcnabb is top 5 in a dream world

 

[C-Gold]

Being a better QB isnt based on winning titles-Im talking about right now, who is a better QB-Mcnabb and Campbell went head to head in a game if i recall, Mcnabbs team was up 14-0 because of a kick return and westbrook and then went on to do nothing. Campbell on the other hand lead his team back throughout the game---Mcnabb is top 5 in a dream world

So if Jason Leftwhich throws a 1 yard screen pass to Santana Moss and he jukes a defender and runs 42 yards, you want to credit Jason?

He sucks. Mcnabb is much better. Mcnabb can and does read defenses, Jason just throws left or right, depending on which screen pass they throw. Occasionally he throws a play action. He doesn't just drop back and pick defenses apart because he can't READ the defense!

why do you think he has no int's? Because he is throwing check downs. He sucks.
:nohead:

 

[Jstack34]

So the deep bomb to moss in the new orleans game when they were down was a check down? Or the throws to ARE and Cooley down the middle? What about the td pass to Moss last week? Check down? Why does he have no ints? Because he doesnt throw the ball into bad spots and doesn't force things. Part of being a good QB is making the read of where not to throw it. Haters will always hate tho, no point in arguing with you when your go to is-he sucks, Mcnabb is much better. Mcnabb is old and washed up

 

[C-Gold]

He throws 1 deep ball on a play action pass because teams don't even honor his deep ball. Yeah, that's right, they don't honor his deep ball. He has a strong arm but isn't accurate and 99% of the time is throwing some pass 5 yards or less.

You want to jack off because he is throwing 5 yard drag routes to chris cooley? Geez, he really has to read the defense for that.

He is a game manager. Just like Trent Dilfer, Byron Leftwhich, or david garrard. They just do what old coach tells them to do, without trying to make some dumb throw.

The problem is they limit themselves too. Gibbs didn't trust campbell and neither does zorn. He's happy with the king of checkdowns hat.

 

[C-Gold]

How did you like Byron Campbell in that Redskins Giants game? Throwing screens at home against the saints and Cards is one thing, but the Giants fucked that knocka up!

They were talking about benching him here in washington and a 3-13 season on the radio. His backup Todd Collins did out play him last year.

 

[C-Gold]

Mcbabb 349 passing yards today, has Jason Leftwhich ever thrown that many yards? I think he has had 1 300 yard game in his life and it wasn't 349.

dink dunk dink dunk, I hope the steelers fuck him up.

 

[Jstack34]

Yea, referring to the first game of the year is a good way to look @ things, first game and the whole team was off, week 1 results have nothing to do with how the qb is playing now-if any1 said to bench him and 3-13 they are morons, only a complete idiot calls for the benching of a great qb 1 game into a season

 

[whalewager]

Nice win for me. He still sucks though.

 

[C-Gold]

Yea, referring to the first game of the year is a good way to look @ things, first game and the whole team was off, week 1 results have nothing to do with how the qb is playing now-if any1 said to bench him and 3-13 they are morons, only a complete idiot calls for the benching of a great qb 1 game into a season

Todd Collins was 4-0 last year while campbell was 5-7. Colliins had a higher qb rating, better td-int ratio, more yards per game, the team rallied around him and was just better.

Campbell played like dog shit in week 1, they had a new coach, and collins has sat and watched while campbell got on the radio like a crybaby that he is.

Guaranteed the redskins won't win anything with that turd.

 

[whalewager]

he sucks

 

[manchild]

he sucks

So! You would of rather drafted Ricky Williams instead of McNabb?