Do you have a 10 mile round trip to work..?
Do you have a sig other? Do you lease 2 cars lol?
Do you like paying full coverage on your CARS (plural)?
i have a cheap mechanic-
if you buy cars right you can drive them for almost free.
i buy at auction and avoid the dealers, many good deals can be found from private owners likewise.
This is true. Especially some of the older American cars just keep on going and even if repairs needed parts are cheap especially if used. Yes, if you know what you're doing and don't constantly end up with lemons or cars that have expensive parts for repairs then sure. I will concede what you're saying.
When you're leasing you never own it and always paying, when you buy a new car it' the worst investment you can make.
For most people used cars are a hassle and ongoing expenses and breaking down at inconvenient times. What you're saying is also true. If you know what you're doing and buy the right car then sure.
Also, it's a status thing, at this point in my life I can't be seen driving an old car. Has to be brand new. It's not just me, most people feel this pressure especially those that work in an office setting. I can't imagine pulling into the employee parking lot and not driving a brand new car. It would stick out like a sore thumb.
Oh and you mentioned cheap mechanic. That's huge too. You have a good thing going then. I used to have a ma an pa type joint where I knew the guy from my old man. Basically just charged for the parts never labor. Helped me a lot when I was driving beaters during college. He's passed away and his son sold the shop. Hard to find a cheap mechanic and/or one you can trust not to work you over.