I get why some feel that politics has a place in the offshore forum. The Offshore forum is less about "offshore" topics and more like our favorite bar where we see a lot of the same locals. The offshore forum is where we get to know each other on a more personal level and thus it is where a lot of friendships are formed. Its a sacred place that should be fought for! How we behave here, sets the tone for the behaviors we as posters find acceptable and that tone carries over to other sub forums.
With it being such a divisive time in politics, I feel like the division created during these arguments will have a long last effect on relationships. This animosity between some people would not be found otherwise if is wasn't for politics. The offshore forum should be the place that brings us together. We should talking about our similarities, ie interest in sports/gambling. If the political rhetoric continues during football season when traffic greatly increased, I think there could be negative consequences. The tension and sharp words seen by newbies may cause them to step back from the fray. Or if they dive right in, they instantly have enemies - all because of political views. I think it's a lose-lose situation for new members.
As well, I think these arguments give away theRX's only true advantage over our competitors and that's a non-combative atmosphere. Covers, SBR, EOG, TGF, and Peeps all seem to embrace that argumentative posting style. Of course, some of you don't mind it, but others do. Its certainly not a friendly atmosphere. Nothing good is coming from talking politics here. It could and probably has already created tension between long time posters, further dividing our loyal RX community. Is that what we want here?? Sides? Enemies?
I think ALL political topics and even mentions in threads should be moved to the political forum. It's there for a reason. I'd hate for RX to lose that advantage or even worse for the OS to become more like the Poly Forum.
Its football season! Let's come together and talk sports, debate sports, and enjoy the forum. We're not here to piss someone off, to be pissed off ourselves, that's what politics does.
I think a proactive approach of limiting these types of conversations to the Political Forum is in the best interest of the brand and growth of theRXForum. Obviously you are free to disagree but everything great about theRX is strained when politics take center focus.
Some very excellent and valid points, arguments for Political Threads being -EV. It is though just 2 months from the most bizarre Presidential Election this country has ever seem and the Division that you speak of is a climate that exists within this country. Ignoring this, pretending that deep Division is not a reality within USA or acting like its not important is, IMO, a bad strategy.
Discussion of such, a good strategy IMO. trying to identify where the differences are and especially where those are based upon misinformation or lack of knowledge, very +EV IMO.
Serious Problems exist on this planet, problems we've had for centuries to some degree or another. This combined with the extraordinary Political Situation we are in right now with this Presidential Race creates, for me, a circumstance in which the expectation and desire that discussion of such stuff not exist or be limited within Offfshore is a wrong viewpoint to have.
Were Life all Wine & Roses outside of RX the Division here would be concerning but life beyond RX is not that plus Division, disagreement is as Natural, as Inherent to human existence as breathing is. Might be "just me" but I don't take Disagreement with me to be a Grave Thing, like, anything close to a "Dealbreaker" where regards interacting with people beyond that disagreement.
Some guys do, yeah and definitely some guys are vastly less interested in Political Discussion than others.
Maybe YOURS
IS the correct side of this debate: that Political Discussions are -EV within Offshore vs. my feeling that these are important discussion to be had.
Its entirely possible that you are right and I am wrong, on this. Lack of Discussion, ignoring issues though...these exact behaviors have gotten us to a place where we are getting ground up beneath the wheels of a villainous Government thats wholly owned by Special Interests, Corporations and Foreign Governments.
Not that we could have done much to stop that and you may be right also in saying that totally nothing positive gets accomplished by Political Threads within Offshore and nothing positive has any hope of happening as result of these but I do think it is within our basic Nature to have such discussions.
And chiefly to expect that such Threads would not get made during this bizarre Presidential Election is unrealistic.
"Why do they have to exist in Offshore Forum though?"
Because Offshore is, as you described it, the General "Catch-All" Forum of stuff thats going on in Member's lives.
Which includes, as you described, stuff that can serve to bring members together but our lives are also comprised right now of stuff that members have differing viewpoints on.
I'm Down with Whatever though, in regards to how Admin decides to deal with Political Threads within Offshore, Overall, that there even has to BE Political Discussion filled with such Division is unfortunate but its always been this way on this planet, with very few exceptions within all lands and times and amongst all peoples, to such a degree in fact that this too feels like "The Way It Has To BE" here.
Bottom Line is that Earth's People are cast together into a tiny Sandbox and there a percentage of those people stirring up crap making the Sandbox less pleasant that it could be and your request that this not be discussed within a Forum thats designed to be a place where stuff that impacts our lives gets posted, seems "Flawed".
I do appreciate and understand your POV though and, again and most importantly: My Own Opinion on this deal could very well be wrong, and yours right.