Brady = GOAT

Search

Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
4,313
Tokens
As sson as defensive lineman approach him they are pulling up.. you can see them think almost before they lunge for him.. he wouldve been getting rag dolled on the regg..and for all the whining he does they wouldve put a little extra ummph into it .. he would be a shell of what he is now with any other team in any other era .. maybe he couldve been aikman or phil simms.. but that woulve been his peak
 

Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Messages
9,778
Tokens
You must have missed Montana's college national championship game....

i agree that brady is in the conversation of greatest ever...
Brady had unbelievable games in college, but really who cares about college accomplishments.

I have no problem with you saying Montana is the greatest, but to dismiss Brady's wins is kinda silly based on what he has done 4th qtr his entire SB career.
 

Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Messages
9,778
Tokens
As sson as defensive lineman approach him they are pulling up.. you can see them think almost before they lunge for him.. he wouldve been getting rag dolled on the regg..and for all the whining he does they wouldve put a little extra ummph into it .. he would be a shell of what he is now with any other team in any other era .. maybe he couldve been aikman or phil simms.. but that woulve been his peak
Cool story, but in the reality we live he be the GOAT.
 
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
28,144
Tokens
The media and nfl analysts will always say he is the greatest. A 6th round draft pick coming from out of nowhere who worked extremely hard to get to be labeled "greatest of all time." IMO he's not. He is a product of the system just like anybody else who goes there. Matt Cassell was undefeated I think 8-0 or so and finished 11-5 and missed the playoffs. Maybe 10-6. But regardless, he played well and was quickly exposed for the decent quarterback he is at best as soon as he left. If Brady was on a different team, would he do the same I wonder. I think if you put Brady on Jacksonville or the Jets they are still a 5-11,6-10 type team. Favre went to the New York Jets a shitfest of a organization before Rex Ryan got there and changed shit around and Favre had them at 8-2 before tearing his labrum in his throwing shoulder and played through it and was terrible but point is.... Could Brady go to one of the worst organizations and turn them around? Favre could. That is what a goat is IMO. Matt Cassell was on his way to be the next Brady lmao.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
45,020
Tokens
The media and nfl analysts will always say he is the greatest. A 6th round draft pick coming from out of nowhere who worked extremely hard to get to be labeled "greatest of all time." IMO he's not. He is a product of the system just like anybody else who goes there. Matt Cassell was undefeated I think 8-0 or so and finished 11-5 and missed the playoffs. Maybe 10-6. But regardless, he played well and was quickly exposed for the decent quarterback he is at best as soon as he left. If Brady was on a different team, would he do the same I wonder. I think if you put Brady on Jacksonville or the Jets they are still a 5-11,6-10 type team. Favre went to the New York Jets a shitfest of a organization before Rex Ryan got there and changed shit around and Favre had them at 8-2 before tearing his labrum in his throwing shoulder and played through it and was terrible but point is.... Could Brady go to one of the worst organizations and turn them around? Favre could. That is what a goat is IMO. Matt Cassell was on his way to be the next Brady lmao.

You haters can keep on being deluded, but this discussion is all but settled after the last SuperBowl.

It's not even a reasonable discussion to have any more.
 
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
28,144
Tokens
Brady's stats over the last 6 years compared to the first 6 years of his career is absolutely ridiculous as well. Makes you wonder....what did he learn? Hmmm. Those images of knowing what the defense is in before the ball is snapped would help. I thought Peyton was the greatest ever pre snap...and he rightfully should be.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
4,234
Tokens
The media and nfl analysts will always say he is the greatest. A 6th round draft pick coming from out of nowhere who worked extremely hard to get to be labeled "greatest of all time." IMO he's not. He is a product of the system just like anybody else who goes there. Matt Cassell was undefeated I think 8-0 or so and finished 11-5 and missed the playoffs. Maybe 10-6. But regardless, he played well and was quickly exposed for the decent quarterback he is at best as soon as he left. If Brady was on a different team, would he do the same I wonder. I think if you put Brady on Jacksonville or the Jets they are still a 5-11,6-10 type team. Favre went to the New York Jets a shitfest of a organization before Rex Ryan got there and changed shit around and Favre had them at 8-2 before tearing his labrum in his throwing shoulder and played through it and was terrible but point is.... Could Brady go to one of the worst organizations and turn them around? Favre could. That is what a goat is IMO. Matt Cassell was on his way to be the next Brady lmao.

Agree 100000%

Brady would not do jack shit if he played in the 70's thru the 90's. He is the product of the system. If you want to compare pure QB talent as of today, Rodgers is better

All these passing QB's of the past 20 years all owe a thanks to Dan Marino...so many copied him and yes all that is documented
 

Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2008
Messages
2,719
Tokens
Mob, you don't even believe what you posted, since it it. Such a crock of shit....down 25 late 3 rd,
down 10 to the mighty Seahawks , with a tremendous defense in the 4 th quarter, led pats on 2 TD drives to take 4 point lead. Only a miricle catch had the Seahawks in position to get stopped by pats in close.
 
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
28,144
Tokens
Mob, you don't even believe what you posted, since it it. Such a crock of shit....down 25 late 3 rd,
down 10 to the mighty Seahawks , with a tremendous defense in the 4 th quarter, led pats on 2 TD drives to take 4 point lead. Only a miricle catch had the Seahawks in position to get stopped by pats in close.

I believe Dante Hightower won both of those superbowls honestly. The strip sack changed the game vs Atlanta. and the tackle he had on Marshawn Lynch where he gets off the Russel Okung block and saves a touchdown. Seattle then passed on the next play. Brady has done what he has done every superbowl.... shit the bed early and be clutch late. This time it took a ton of luck for sure. And for Atlanta to completely blow the game. I'm not making excuses on that game. It's all fate, nothing could be done even if all they had to do was knee the fucking ball three times.

From a discussion standpoint, you can't tell me he would have the same success with a different organization. It's the best organization in the nfl.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
45,020
Tokens
Agree 100000%

Brady would not do jack shit if he played in the 70's thru the 90's. He is the product of the system. If you want to compare pure QB talent as of today, Rodgers is better

All these passing QB's of the past 20 years all owe a thanks to Dan Marino...so many copied him and yes all that is documented

Dan Marino... ROFL. He was almost as big of a choker as Romo.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,120,947
Messages
13,589,138
Members
101,021
Latest member
bradduke112
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com