BEST D1 College FBALL PLAYER YOU"VE EVER SEEN..TELL ME.

[8ate]

herschel ; except he went pro early

 

[Webby]

Charles Woodson CB/WR/KR/PR Michigan, anytime he was on the field you had to watch him.

 

[auggiedawg]

NFL bust IMO. What did he do his last 5 yrs pro?

Charles Woodson CB/WR/KR/PR Michigan, anytime he was on the field you had to watch him.

 

[Fav10]

NFL bust IMO. What did he do his last 5 yrs pro?

thread said college not pro

 

[prodigy]

some very good names in this thread.

for me, its always been peter warrick. there have been plenty of great players over the years. but when he got the ball in his hands in the passing game or on a punt return, you truly felt he could go the distance every single time.

close second would be reggie bush.

and marshall faulk was electric in college too. hes probably one of the few who happened to be outstanding in college ... and then truly outstanding in the pros. thats rarer than people think.

 

[Joe_Hallenbeck]

I gotta give some love to to some option QBs. The below two guys were tough and had impeccable W/L records. They both won national championships as well.

Tommie Frazier (Neb)
Tony Rice (ND)

 

[GoSooners]

If we're talking about option QB's, Jack Mildren has to be listed with the alltime best..He's the one who pretty much put the wishbone/option on the map.

 

[billhill999]

Johnny Rodgers, Nebraska.

 

[Railbird]

Charlie Ward
Marcus Allen
Tim Brown
Ryan Leaf

 

[clowncar]

Vince Young

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

Art Schlister...you just had to know which side he was on...

 

[TexasEx]

Ricky Williams. The guy turned out to be a total bust in the NFL other than 2 years, but he was an absolute beast at UT.

 

[straightcashhomie]

Barry Sanders
Reggie Bush
Tommy Frazier

No particular order

 

[auggiedawg]

so....i cant read...................WV fan here

thread said college not pro

 

[jonchan312]

Herschel.
David Pollack.

 

[fivestarjake]

someone already gave out my answer but orlando pace was a pretty dam good lineman.

 

[seriousaddiction]

Ive never seen anyone more fun to watch than BUSH...hands down...whenever he got the ball he was most likely going to score....as for best---theres so many...walker, frazier, the list goes on and onnn...defense love for woodson?

 

[seriousaddiction]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrsMTNl7ZFk&feature=related


argument over

 

[SoonerBS]

Leroy Selmon and Earl Campbell are the two most dominate players at their positions that I've seen in person.

This is the first time I looked in this thread and I was going to answer exactly the same way . . . . . . . the only thing is that most of these guys in here have probably never seen these two guys play as much as we have, GS. But, I've seen all these other guys listed and I can't say that they were better than the two you listed.

 

[FairWarning]

Deion Sanders and Anthony Carter