Here's the thing with Lidge, he's Jekyll and Hyde.
Like the girl with the curls, when he's good, he is very good..........
Two things, two very big things, he has a fragile psych, he had a mental breakdown which took a long time to get over after Pujols schooled him.
Case in point, after losing the WS in 2005,(a series where he wasn't very good by the way) what happened to him in 2006?
11 wild pitches that season in 75 innings pitched. WTF is that?
4 batters hit. WTF is that?
1.4 ratio. WTF is that, 1-4 WL record, 7.20 ERA, ummm you get the idea.
He has a Donny Moore psych, and he blew his brains out over Henderson's tater in 1986.
The second thing is steroid allegations.
Can't overlook that.