Boy, would I love to get YOU in a poker game. If you kick to cut the score to 15, then kick again to cut the score to 8, YOUR TEAM IS STILL IN THE GAME. YOU KEEP THE PRESSURE ON THE DEFENSE. YOUR TEAM HAS THE MOMENTUM. If you go for two after the first score and miss, your team loses the momentum, and you essentially have to score FOUR TIMES. Two TDs, and two two-point conversions. And if you fail on ANY of the four scores, game over, you lose, go home.
Even though this is now in the Rubber Room hopefully this discussion can continue. I do not agree with the momentum argument at all here, if anything there is a bigger momentum blow if you go and miss after the third td than there is after the first td because if you miss after the first td you still have a chance.
Further, is the fact that you still do have a chance to tie the game in three scores if you go and miss after the first TD, whereas if you go and miss after the second or third TD you will need four scores now.
Again in context to the momentum argument, does that mean that a defense is not as likely to stop you after the third TD than they are after the first TD? I doubt it. Does it mean that suddenly your performance is elevated while their performance suffers? Again, don't see how that can be argued or validated in any way.
Now granted my argument is if you are down 22 with under 10 minutes to go in the game when there are just 3 or 4 more possessions for you to have a chance to score on. I do not agree with this argument if you are down 22 with more than 10 minutes remaining in the 4th because there are more chances to score and points are more important.
In a related argument, I also believe that some teams should go for two every time. Mainly the ones that have power running games or are legitimate dual threats at all times. This is further enhanced if you have a shaky kicker. A team like LSU or UF should definitely go for two after every TD because they have a better than 50% chance of getting the 2 pts after the TD. The penultimate team for this was the 2005 Texas Longhorns as they had a power running game, a dual threat QB, and a kicker in David Pino that missed something like 9 XP's on the season. Alas Mack Brown is less than smart so we never got the chance to see it would have worked (though I would say with 95% certainty that they would definitely have more points on the season if they went for two after every TD than if they just kicked the XP)